Shropshire Star

Dave Edwards: If referees couldn't agree whether it was a penalty against Wolves - how could we?

They say refereeing decisions in football even themselves out over time – that has not been the case in Wolves’ situation.

Plus
Published
Wolves players question the penalty decision by referee Josh Smith for handball

They have been on the wrong end of a lot of VAR decisions, and this is yet another controversial one.

I was at the game, I was commentating and I possibly called it wrong at the time. But I still do not quite know the exact rule.

I had the privilege of having the VAR comms in my ear, so I could hear what they were saying and as the penalty was given straight away I thought it was extremely harsh.

As there was a deflection I assumed VAR would look at it, but from what I hear then is because his arm is in an unnatural position the decision is going to stand.

I tried to relay that in my comms, that the rules say it is a penalty.

The response I got from fans took me back to the days of being a player, I got a lot of abuse and it prompted me to look back over it.