Concerns raised over fresh plans for The Stew in Shrewsbury

The lease-holder of The Stew in Frankwell Quay has been seeking permission to convert the former riverside warehouse in to a habitable building for a number of years.

Plans have been back and forth between the developer, Gareth Leese and planning chiefs at the council with no resolution, and now a compromise has been submitted to Shropshire Council's planning department.

But an inspector for Historic England has said there are still concerns about the scale, and recommended that the authority seeks amendments, safeguards or further information.

Inspector Julie Taylor said: "As you will be aware from our previous discussions, whilst we are of the view that the revised proposals are a considerable improvement on those previously submitted, we are still concerned by the scale of the proposed development and that it steps forward off the gable end of the existing building.

"In our view, stepping the extension back from this key elevation, and omitting the top most storey, would result in a less dominant and more sympathetic solution.

"However, from our discussions we are aware that the applicant is adamant that this quantum of development is essential in order to bring forward a viable scheme, and ensure the future of the building.

"This being the case, and in view of the harm that the revised scheme would cause to The Stew and surrounding heritage assets, it is vital that the submitted viability statement fully justifies the extent of development proposed.

"If however, such an economic case cannot be adequately substantiated, we would recommend that the proposals be amended to address our concerns.

"With regard to any extension, in view of the sensitive location we would suggest further detailed drawings be submitted for your consideration, in order to show all architectural details, finishes and materials."

Last year he submitted plans for a development of flats, a spa and a cafe.

But objections were raised regarding the visual aspect of the design with many saying the proposed futuristic roof was out of keeping in a conservation area and would harm the historical heritage of the building.

Mr Leese has worked with a leading Shrewsbury architectural firm to come up with a compromise and new designs have been submitted to Shropshire Council's planning department.

Previous suggestions for the building, which dates back to the 18th century, had included a boutique hotel with a swimming pool.