Star’s front row seat for sporting history
- Local newspaper week
Leader – New rail link is bad news for Shropshire
Tuesday 10th January 2012, 10:59AM GMT.
Were the High Speed Rail link planned to pass through Shropshire, the protests on environmental grounds would make the objections to new electricity pylons across the county look tame indeed.
But as HS2 is not in our back yard, Salopians have the luxury of evaluating the scheme on how Shropshire will benefit.
And not only will Shropshire not benefit, but it is quite likely that its train services will suffer through an effective downgrading of Wolverhampton station, which is a major portal to the county.
The emphasis of HS2 is more towards the central and eastern part of the country, rather than the western areas, and so the prospect is for fewer services and a link to the capital for western areas which is actually poorer.
It is a little-reported fact that the high speed trains will not go into the centre of Birmingham at New Street, but will go to a new station on the eastern outskirts of the city.
This will mean passengers for Birmingham centre will need another train journey to get there, devaluing one of the main arguments in favour HS2, in that it will cut down journey times.
Rather than being a link into the heart of the Midlands, it actually bypasses the heart of the Midlands and points northwards and eastwards, an accurate indication of the direction of the planned further extension.
So, at the cost of a huge outlay at a time of austerity, attractive countryside will be blighted for the sake of saving a few minutes. The way air travel has developed has proven that speed is not necessarily king.
HS2 is a modern Concorde which will do nothing good for Shropshire.
The money would be better spend on upgrading and improving existing routes.
Harsh winter is not a thing of the past:
Thirty years ago today Shropshire was the coldest place in England ever recorded. It was deep in snow and in the middle of a big freeze-up which had begun in early December.
That record of minus 26.1C at Edgmond still stands today.
For those who did not live through it, and who are currently enjoying the unseasonably mild spell, it is difficult to imagine such Arctic temperatures in this fair county.
Older readers will scoff, and say you should have been there in 1963. Or 1947.
It does make you wonder whether today’s youngsters will ever get the chance to regale their grandchildren with tales of memorable bad winters.
To fail to experience them is a sort of deprivation.
They will not even be able to boast of heatwaves, if the trend for a warmer climate continues unabated into the future.
It would though be extremely naive to think that we will never get another 1947, 1963, or 1982.
It is not a question of if, but a question of when.
Shropshire Star on Twitter
Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
LIVE traffic updates
Road, rail and airport - latest
Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new Shropshire Star app
Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.
What tosh! Of course travellers in Shropshire will benefit. The current journey from Shrewsbury to London is horrendously slow given the distance and is inconvenient. Speeding up trains between London and Birmingham has got to be a good idea and opens the door to freeing capacity on the existing line, from London to Birmingham, for possible through trains to Shrewsbury.
Report abuse
Oh boy ! Aren’t some people naive. Because the theory will be that the massed populace will want to get to London 25 mins earlier then there will be less demand for the existing services, which will therefore be neglected.
If someone from Shrewsbury (or Wolverhampton for that matter) wants to use HS2 then they will have to change at New St and wait for a shuttle to the new Super Interchange, where they will wait for HS2. The combined waiting time will negate any benefit from HS2.
Please remember HS2 does NOT come to Birmingham City Centre, it only comes to the suburbs.
Report abuse
Why are you repeating what the “leader” says…? I think you’ll find that HS2 does come right into the heart of Birmingham.
Is this deliberate misinformation by those who oppose HS2?
Report abuse
“It is a little-reported fact that the high speed trains will not go into the centre of Birmingham at New Street, but will go to a new station on the eastern outskirts of the city.
This will mean passengers for Birmingham centre will need another train journey to get there, devaluing one of the main arguments in favour HS2, in that it will cut down journey times.”
That’s just plain wrong. Is it an error of research or deliberate misinformation to suit the point of view of the leader writer?
There will be a spur from HS2 into a new station in the Curzon Street area of Birmingham, inside the Middle Ring Road, close to Moor St station, 10 minutes on foot to New St Station and 10-15 minutes on foot to the city centre (Town Hall).
Report abuse
This article/letter/whatever it’s meant to be is such utter rubbish I don’t know where to begin.
For starters Birmingham’s high speed terminal will be in the centre of the city, about 5 minutes walk from New Street station. Not so much as “little reported” as simply incorrect. Call yourself a journalist? I hope you don’t get paid for writing this nonsense.
As for Shropshire – what do you think will happen to the existing West Coast Mainline? It will be freed up and so allow for direct trains to London from places that currently do not have such a service… like from Shrewsbury! I can see Shrewsbury to Wolverhampton being electrified in the 2020s with trains running Shrewsbury-Euston via the current West Coast mainline.
As for improving existing lines – that is happening. The Great Western mainline is being electrified and will mean a better journey for those of us in the south of the county (yes, county – not country) who travel to London via Newport/Bristol. Shrewsbury to Wolverhampton is currently having a linespeed upgrade.
If the writer of this nonsense would actually do some actual research and not just repeat what he’s heard down the trendy wine bar perhaps he’d realise that there is real progress being made on Britain’s railways and that High Speed 2 is going to make a huge difference to the country as a whole. But no, instead a lot of people will read this “article” and believe the rubbish written in it. It is shameful.
Report abuse
Shrewsbury and Shropshire should benefit hugely. HS2 should free up capacity on the exisiting lines for additional services (such as Shrewsbury to London).
The other comments are correct. This whole article is full of errors and flawed logic!
Report abuse