Revealed: Shropshire doctors shared serious concerns over 'discriminatory' cross-border treatment delay plan

One medic said: “We should offer treatments to patients irrespective of whether they metaphorically grow roses or daffodils in the garden”

Senior Shrewsbury hospital medics expressed major concerns over Powys health chiefs’ plan to deliberately delay treatment for Mid Wales patients, it has been revealed.

In lengthy discussions over the controversial policy approved last year, the executive medical director of Shropshire’s acute hospital trust told his counterpart in Powys: “I can’t ask our consultants to knowingly delay the care of some patients to treat less urgent patients just because they live one side of the border.”

The policy - under which Powys Teaching Health Board (PTHB) asked English hospitals treating its patients to slow down the speed of care - was introduced in March last year as it sought to save money.

Under the plan, which caused outrage amid Powys’s population and politicians, patients requiring non-urgent planned treatment were told they would wait no longer than 104 weeks - in line with Welsh health service waiting times.

Prior to the board’s decision, Powys patients treated in English hospitals were expected to be seen based on the quicker English targets, which are now for 65 per cent of all elective patients to be treated within 18 weeks.

The policy - which does not apply to cancer, emergency, urgent, or under-18s treatment - was implemented as the Welsh health board sought to cut spending; it is required to pay health boards for the cost of the treatment they provide to its patients.

The policy remains in place - although Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust (SaTH), one of the English hospital trusts that provides a significant number of Mid Wales patients with treatment, has told the Shropshire Star it is treating Welsh and English patients “the same”.

While the concerns of the Powys public and its politicians about the proposal are on record, it has now been revealed that the plan was met with dismay at the top level of SaTH - one of the organisations asked to delay treatment for Mid Wales-based patients.

Royal Shrewsbury Hospital which is currently the site of a major construction project to improve services. Picture: Vista Consultingplaceholder image
Royal Shrewsbury Hospital which is currently the site of a major construction project to improve services. Picture: Vista Consulting

Records of communication between the two organisations released under the Freedom of Information Act show there were major worries from SaTH’s medical director, Dr John Jones, over the potential harm to patients and concerns it would place doctors in an “impossible position”.

Dr John Jones, Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust (SaTH) executive medical director. Picture: SaTHplaceholder image
Dr John Jones, Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust (SaTH) executive medical director. Picture: SaTH

A series of emails and letters sent in the wake of PTHB’s March 2025 decision and seen by the Shropshire Star reveal SaTH’s worries that the policy was discriminating against Welsh patients.

Powys’s own chief executive responded saying the board had reviewed legal and professional advice and would not be changing course.

The letters also reveal that SaTH had not implemented the policy request by PTHB as of July 1 last year, with a letter explaining that a meeting over plans to agree financial arrangements between the trusts to pay for the treatment was escalated to chief executive level.

And in its communication to the Shropshire Star last week SaTH said it is still treating English and Welsh patients “the same”, despite the request from the Mid Wales board.

PTHB subsequently confirmed SaTH had “indicated” that it is not implementing the Welsh board’s plan and that the two organisations “remain in ongoing discussion”.

On July 8 last year Dr Jones wrote to his counterpart at PTHB, executive medical director Kate Wright, after being updated on the plan.

In the email he voiced concern at being “expected to deliberately delay the care of patients that we know we could treat more quickly”.

He said: “I am afraid I can’t ask our consultants to knowingly delay the care of some patients to treat less urgent patients just because they live one side of the border. Consultants will feel responsible for harm and may indeed be asked by others to account for delays that may lead to harm.”

‘Discriminatory’

A further communication from Dr Jones just days later expanded on the concerns, warning of his belief that the policy “is discriminatory” based on where patients live.

In a lengthy email the medical director pointed to the experience of the Covid pandemic, where patients came to harm after prolonged delays.

He said: “Putting in place a system in the trust that forces doctors to offer different treatment timescales to patients depending on where they live is discriminatory and conflicts with doctors’ primary duty for the care and safety of patients.”

Dr Jones said the lessons of delays during Covid showed that patients had deteriorated after being classed as ‘routine’.

He said: “It is over simplistic to consider that it won’t affect patients who are not urgent because prioritisation is influenced by time to treatment.

“We know that patients who were rightly categorised as routine during the prolonged delays in treatment in Covid came to harm because their benign conditions progressed.

“We also know prolonged treatment times remove a safety net to protect patients who have unsuspected serious disease.”

Dr Jones said that working out the geographical location of patients to apply treatment would go against their medical guidance.

He wrote: “It is counter to core guidance to doctors to be trying to work out which end of the street, for example, a patient’s address in Llanymynech is when advising patients of different treatments whose preference might be influenced by length of wait.

“It is not for the trust to decide on the health board’s commissioning intentions but it is for the trust to offer care that is not directly or indirectly prejudicial based on ethnicity.

“We should offer treatments to patients irrespective of whether they metaphorically grow roses or daffodils in the garden.”

‘Impossible position’

Dr Jones’s communication was followed by an official letter from SaTH the following month, on August 5.

The letter detailed 10 issues, stating: “As responsible officers for doctors employed in our organisations we would like to highlight that our doctors must never unfairly discriminate against patients or colleagues.

“It is our view that your proposals put our doctors in an impossible position to be confident that they are meeting their core guidance.”

The lengthy communication highlighted a series of issues, saying: “Under your proposals doctors will be impeded in their ability to provide treatment promptly even though the resources in the hospital would allow them to do this.”

It added: “Doctors will therefore have to explain the long wait, in the knowledge that they could treat the patient earlier, and then have to manage a very difficult consultation getting drawn into a risk-based discussion which is entirely based on an artificial constraint.”

It continued: “Doctors will find themselves in a position where they have to explain that patients have come to harm, that they could have treated earlier, but had to artificially extend the treatment time so that others were treated ahead of them.”

The letter concluded by saying: “For all the reasons stated above the proposal to discriminate against Welsh patients even if contractually sound does not absolve doctors from maintaining public trust.”

On September 1 the chief executive of PTHB, Hayley Thomas, responded to the letter.

In it she moved to correct Dr Jones’s description of the changes as a “proposal” and said the matter had been formally approved.

She added that the board had taken fresh legal advice on the measures, and was committed to carrying them out.

She wrote: “As you are aware this is not a ‘proposal’ but a commissioning intention that was agreed by our board in March and communicated to the trusts in early April so that we could plan together to implement it.

“We acknowledge that this was not an easy decision to make, and throughout commissioning discussions we have acknowledged the issues raised by NHS providers in relation to implementation.

“Following the points raised by your medical directors we have taken the opportunity to refresh and review our legal and professional advice, and we remain committed to the robustness of the rationale of these measures.”

What do PTHB and SaTH say now?

This week, in response to queries about the issues raised in the communications, PTHB said its position is that “Welsh residents should be treated in accordance with NHS Wales policy and performance standards, whether their care is provided in Wales or in England”.

It added that it had reviewed its plans in the light of the issues raised by Dr Jones last year.

A statement from the board sent to the Shropshire Star last week said: “In relation to correspondence between Powys Teaching Health Board and The Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust, we recognise that colleagues may hold differing professional views.

“These matters were discussed openly and professionally between the organisations.

“We carefully considered the issues that were raised, including clinical, legal and equality considerations, before reaffirming our commissioning intentions which remain in place during 2026/27.”

Detailing its position on the decision to bring the policy in, the health board said the move was a balance of financial responsibility and providing care in line with Welsh Government standards.

It added that the policy is subject to “ongoing review”.

It said: “The decision was taken following careful and conscientious consideration of the health board's responsibilities, including to provide patients with care and treatment in line with Welsh Government performance standards and to achieve financial balance, and was aligned with Welsh Government policy and the England-Wales Cross Border Healthcare Statement of Values and Principles.

“The health board keeps the impact of its commissioning intentions under ongoing review through its governance, quality and performance arrangements, including feedback from patients, providers, complaints, concerns and incident reporting.”

PTHB said its ambition is to reduce waiting times in the future, but that it believes the fairest way to operate is to ensure Powys residents are treated according to the same standards as the rest of the country - irrespective of whether the treatment is provided in Wales or England.

It said: “We fully understand that nobody wants to wait longer than necessary for treatment and we recognise the anxiety, frustration and uncertainty that waiting can cause for patients and their families.

“The health board remains committed to reducing waiting times for everyone in Powys and believes that the fairest and most equitable approach is to ensure that people are treated according to the same NHS Wales standards wherever their care is provided.

“Our commissioning intentions for planned care in England remain unchanged and continue to be carefully monitored for their impact on quality, safety and patient experience.”

Asked about its position, SaTH said last week: “We are continuing to treat Welsh and English patients the same, based on clinical priority and the length of time they have been waiting.

“We are working closely with Powys Teaching Health Board, seeking to deliver the best possible care with our combined available resources. Patients are advised to please attend their appointments as normal."

PTHB told the Shropshire Star on Friday (August 7): “The Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust have indicated that they are not implementing our commissioning intentions and we remain in ongoing discussion.”

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice