'Shameful': Calls for immediate halt to Powys health board's deliberate delays for operations in Shropshire hospitals
A health board is facing calls for an immediate halt to its policy of deliberately delaying operations for Powys patients in English hospitals.
Powys Teaching Health Board (PTHB) is currently actively requesting that English hospitals, including those in Shropshire, delay planned care treatment for its patients.
The health board enacted the controversial policy, for non-cancer and non-emergency treatment, in July last year as a cost-saving measure.
The request means that patients from across the border face waiting potentially nearly twice as long for surgery as those living in England.
Powys does not have any major hospitals, requiring its residents to be treated at their nearest hospitals across the border in Shropshire and Herefordshire. But in practice the cash-strapped health board cannot afford the cost of operations being carried out more quickly over the border.
As a result the Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust (SaTH) and the Robert Jones and Agnes Hunt Orthopaedic Hospital (RJAH) have been asked to delay appointments and potential surgery for patients.


English patients are currently treated with a target of an initial outpatient appointment within 18 weeks, and for any treatment within 65 weeks.
That target is expected to drop to 52 weeks by March this year.
PTHB has asked SaTH and RJAH to provide outpatient appointments within one year, and treatment within two years - in line with Welsh waiting time targets.
The request has been met with differing responses.
SaTH says all patients are still being treated the same - on the basis of clinical priority.
RJAH says it is complying with parts of the request.
It is understood the trust is not carrying out the request for initial outpatient appointments because of the clinical need to assess a patient's condition - and the risks that delays could pose.
It is complying with the request for treatment targets of 104 weeks.
Ned Hobbs, chief operating officer at SaTH, said: "We are continuing to treat Welsh and English patients the same, based on clinical priority and the length of time they have been waiting.
"We are working closely with Powys Teaching Health Board, seeking to deliver the best possible care with our combined available resources. Patients are advised to please attend their appointments as normal."
A spokesman for RJAH said: “We have not implemented all aspects of the Powys Teaching Health Board (PTHB) policy, and our focus is on providing safe, timely and high-quality services.
"We are continuing to work with colleagues from PTHB to ensure as many patients as possible are treated.”
The PTHB requests are in line with Welsh NHS waiting time targets - which are longer than those in England.
The board said the policy does not apply to cancer patients, urgent and emergency referrals, patients under 18, or people receiving follow-up care.
A spokesman said: "From the beginning of July 2025, we have been working with hospitals in England so that wherever you live in Powys, you will receive planned care treatments (inpatients and day cases) and outpatient appointments based on the NHS Wales waiting time measures."
It added: "This is not a decision we have taken lightly, and it reflects the way we are funded. We must take action to live within our means, or we will build up bigger financial difficulties for the future.
“We continue to work with trusts in England on the implementation of these measures.”
The policy has been criticised by Powys residents and politicians who say it creates a two-tier health system where patients are living in pain while hospitals have the ability to treat them.
Only this week Montgomeryshire Welsh Assembly Member Russell George raised the issue in the Senedd, highlighting the shocking plight of a Montgomeryshire woman who has been waiting for 78 weeks for a hip replacement.


She could wait up to 104 weeks.
He said: "It is a shameful position. For Powys Teaching Health Board to be asking providers to slow down treatment when capacity is available in English hospitals is completely unacceptable."
Mr George has called for funding to be made available from the Welsh Government to address the situation.
The MS raised the issue with Welsh First Minister Eluned Morgan earlier this week. During the exchange the First Minister said the average waiting time in Wales is 19 weeks.
Mr George urged the Welsh Government to use part of an extra £180m allocated to the health and social care budget to address Powys's 'two-tier' status.
Following the exchange he said: "Powys patients are waiting many more months for treatment than English patients, when waiting for treatment in the very same hospitals.
"That is indefensible. A targeted allocation to Powys would let the health board buy extra available capacity in England, so all Powys patients could be seen based on the quicker English waiting-time standards to end this two-tier system."
He cited the example of one patient, a Mrs Hancock, who has been waiting for treatment for well over a year.
“The First Minister cited an average of 19-week waits, but making this claim is just offensive to people like Mrs Hancock who has been waiting in pain for over 78 weeks, and still waiting, even though there is the capacity to treat her now."
He added: "That is why I am continuing to ask for part of the health spending uplift to specifically end this cross-border inequity."
Newtown Councillor Kelly Healy waited a year and a half for an operation on a back problem following a slipped disc which left her facing ongoing pain and discomfort.


The operation finally took place last December, six months early, because her specialist decided it was an emergency and any further delay would put her at long-term risk.
She said the PTHB policy was "inhumane" and "disgraceful".
She said: "It is a terrible way to treat people. I am guessing Shrewsbury hospital won't do it because it is inhumane. How can you comply with something that is inhumane?
"People are spending months and years in pain when they don't have to."
She added: "I know people who have waited two years. For a long time longer than me, that is why we are trying to overturn this.
"They have the capacity to do the operations, but they won't pay for it. It's not that they don't have the surgeons, it is about saving money."
Councillor Healy, who is 43, said the policy fails to consider the long-term impacts on people living in pain.
She said: "It is how I felt before my operation, it is depressing, it gets you down. I was not sleeping, I ended up hallucinating, and I lost my job because I could not function properly.
"I think about all those people who do manual jobs. What do you do if you have a manual job and you have a slipped disc? What on earth do you do while you wait?"
Welshpool Councillor Graham Breeze said the policy should immediately be scrapped, with the health of Powys residents treated as the priority.
He said: "I think it is disgraceful, absolutely disgraceful. That is not the way to run a health authority and it is little wonder they are in the difficulties they are if that is the line they are taking.
"If their line to improve the financial situation is to make the health of the people of Powys suffer there are serious questions that need to be answered. I simply do not think it is right and proper that such a decision should be made."
A spokesman for the Welsh Government said: “We are committed to reducing waiting times and ensuring everyone in Wales – including those in Powys – has equitable and timely access to treatment. This has been supported by an additional £120m which included new funding for Powys Teaching Health Board.
“We have been clear that all NHS Wales organisations must plan and deliver services for their population in line with Welsh Government targets and within the financial and staffing resources available.”
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.
