Health trust under attack


A former Shropshire hospital boss today ripped into planned changes to county health services, branding a public consultation document as "defective" and "unacceptable". David Sandbach wants NHS watchdogs to get the document withdrawn and rewritten or ask Health Secretary Patricia Hewitt to intervene.
Shropshire County Primary Care Trust has been consulting on proposals for "significant changes" in its services. These include cutting hospital beds and closing wards at Ludlow and Bishop's Castle.
Mr Sandbach, former chief executive of Telford's Princess Royal Hospital, says in a response to the trust he is "not happy" exact bed numbers at Ludlow are being determined during a consultation period.
"A competent management would have these worked out prior to consultation," he says.
The expected gross saving of reducing the beds is £290,000 but Mr Sandbach asks what the net saving would be.
"If there is a difference the between the gross and net, then the document should explain how the difference is to be used, for example for patient services or for savings to balance the PCT's books," he says.
He calls for more detail in the trust's statement that it is exploring options for the long-term future of the Ludlow site and criticises proposed changes to older people's mental health services in Ludlow.
He claims the consultation document is "defective" on this issue.
He says members of the public are in no position to know if the consultation document makes "fiscal sense."
There is no clear understanding of how things will improve, for example in terms of reducing admission rates at the Royal Shrewsbury and Princess Royal hospitals.
"This lack of transparency is not acceptable and renders this document useless as far as providing enough information to make an informed comment," says Mr Sandbach.
"The lack of transparency in this document is remarkable and needless to say unacceptable."
By Health Correspondent Dave Morris
Popular stories:
- Battle to stop hospital care plan being axed
- How easy is it to travel by bus?
- Clicking online was not so great
- Rare Meccano up for auction
- Angels are hoping for a hit