Campaigners “unsurprised” at further delay to Bute Energy’s Radnor Forest Wind farm planning application

Campaigners “unsurprised” at further delay to Bute Energy’s Radnor Forest Wind farm planning application

A decision on the future of a huge proposed wind farm on Radnor Forest has been delayed, after planning inspectors, for a second time, asked the applicant, Bute Energy to provide more information.

The “Nant Mithil Energy Park”, which is widely regarded as Bute Energy’s flagship project would comprise 30 wind turbines up to 220m tall on and around the highest hills in Radnorshire.

A series of delays have beset the application since it was first submitted to the planning inspectorate, Planning and Environment Decisions Wales in December 2024.

Surveys had to be repeated during 2025 before the application was finally verified in early November.

Following public consultation, the inspectors asked Bute Energy for further information on several areas of the application.

Another representation period was then held to consult the public on that further information.

Now, the inspectors have again asked Bute to provide additional information.

They have suspended their examination of the application until the end of September, with Bute given a deadline of August 11 to respond.

The Inspectors want Bute to provide the following an updated Environmental Impact Assessment which includes the environmental impact of proposed power line connecting to the site (Towy Usk line) and the transporting of Abnormal Indivisible Loads (AILs) ie blade delivery to the site

They also want clarification on deliverability of the project, referencing the transportation of abnormal loads to the site, new Welsh Government’s policies on undergrounding of power lines, and concerns of the National Air Traffic Services, an updated peat and soil survey information, and noise issues.

The inspectors clearly want to be assured that all the significant environmental effects of the project are laid out for examination, whether they lie inside or outside the site boundary.

They advise Bute Energy that it should “have regard” to the representations received, “including the representation provided by CPRW / ReThink.”

Jenny Chryss, RE-think Campaign Lead said: “These aren't just matters of fussy detail. There are fundamental issues here relating to an industrial-scale proposed development which would change the landscape and character of Radnorshire.

“With professional support, RE- think and CPRW raised a lot of these issues in our joint submission and I’m pleased to note the Inspectors’ recognition of this.

“In our view, rather than ensuring that all the information is provided, Bute Energy has so far tried to present this wind farm proposal as if it would sit in splendid isolation. Clearly the project could not exist without road access for the turbines and blades and would be pointless without a power line to transport the energy generated. For the latter, there is recent caselaw which makes Bute Energy's approach even more worrying.

"To be honest, this new suspension doesn't come as a surprise given the huge gaps in the information that Bute Energy has provided to date.

“This is the second time that the Inspectors have had to come back for more information from the applicant. First time round the response was full of holes and now it seems they've still got important questions to answer.

“Bute Energy’s inexperience in the industry has always been evident, but this latest fiasco brings it home loud and clear.

“People living near Radnor Forest and along potential transport routes are worried sick about the effects that this proposal would have, should it be approved. Many live in fear that it will have a direct and appalling impact on their homes, their local environment, lives and businesses. But even at this late stage we are all still in the dark about exactly who

will be most affected and where.

“The Inspectors are absolutely right to keep pushing for further clarity, but keeping people waiting for a decision, maybe for many more months or longer, due largely to Bute Energy's incompetence, is unacceptable."

A spokesperson for Bute Energy said: “Nant Mithil Energy Park represents a significant opportunity for Wales’ energy security mission and for investment in people, communities and business in Powys and across mid Wales.

“We continue to work closely with PEDW and relevant partners, and we welcome the scrutiny and rigour the planning system provides.

“We are committed to working with PEDW and others to provide the clarity and information they and communities need about our proposals.”

RE-think will be attending the Royal Welsh Show again this year.

Jenny added: "RE-think has come a long way since we set it up in 2023 in response to Bute Energy's massive wind farm and power line proposals.

“Our attendance at the show is now expected by our large, and growing band of supporters. It's a great opportunity for us to spread the word and talk to people, often from outside the area, who we may not normally have an opportunity to engage with.

“Over the last three years we have worked incredibly hard to put the message across about the enormous size and number of industrial-scale wind developments proposed across Wales by Bute Energy and others.

“People should realise that there is no precedent for this in either England or Wales. Only Scotland has seen such devastation as rural Wales could be about to experience. RE-think fully supports decarbonisation, but we are very happy to explain to people who visit our stand why building over-sized wind turbines on a mass scale is not the way to go about it."

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice