Moving Puccini performance raises funds for charity at Shrewsbury Abbey – review
Verismo Opera delivers a moving performance of Puccini’s La Fanciulla del West at Shrewsbury Abbey
Shrewsbury Abbey has hosted many memorable musical evenings, but Verismo Opera’s concert performance of Puccini’s La Fanciulla del West will surely stand among the most affecting. Presented in memory of 10-year-old Cleo Postlethwaite and raising funds for The Brain Tumour Charity through the Team Cleo Fund, the night combined artistic excellence with a profound sense of shared purpose.


From the opening sweep of the prelude, the orchestra, led by Alex Postlethwaite and featuring many of Shropshire’s finest players, created a lush, full-bodied sound that filled the Abbey’s vast acoustic. Their playing had warmth, colour and a freedom that Puccini’s score rewards. Whenever the music allowed them to surge, they did so with thrilling energy, yet always with sensitivity to the singers.
The miners’ chorus set the tone with a touching portrayal of homesickness and camaraderie, their ensemble sound both rugged and tender.
The arrival of Minnie, sung by Ukrainian soprano Khrystyna Makar, was a genuine coup de théâtre. Makar’s entrance – gun-slinging and commanding, while radiating compassion – brought an immediate shift in atmosphere. Her voice carried both steel and softness, shaping Minnie as a woman whose kindness transforms the men around her. It was a performance of striking emotional clarity.
American bass-baritone Brad Morrison gave Sheriff Rance a dark, resonant authority. His rich tone and imposing presence made his ill-intentioned pursuit of Minnie genuinely unsettling.
Opposite him, Liverpool-based tenor Lewis Quinn, the artistic force behind Verismo Opera, sang Dick Johnson with lyrical warmth and sincerity. His portrayal made Johnson’s redemption through Minnie’s forgiveness feel both believable and moving.
On the podium, Bedwyn Lloyd Phillips proved himself a gifted operatic conductor. His direction was confident, clear and full of musical instinct. He supported his cast with care and guided the orchestra with a flair that belies his young age. His future in opera looks bright.
Before the performance, Stacey Vincent of The Brain Tumour Charity spoke insightfully, reminding the audience of the purpose behind the night: a community of musicians giving their time, waiving their fees and performing in Cleo’s memory. It grounded the evening in something larger than music alone.
As the final "addio, addio" faded, with Minnie and Johnson walking off into the Californian sunset together, the Abbey erupted into a standing ovation – an instinctive and heartfelt tribute to the performers, the organisers and the cause that brought them together.
A superbly sung, beautifully played and deeply meaningful performance. Verismo Opera offered Shrewsbury an evening of artistry and compassion that will linger long in the memory.
By Jane Park