Blind tasting event at Camra festival leaves bitter taste in the mouth for some
A beer produced by a big brewery chain winning one of the Campaign for Real Ale's top awards has left a sour taste in the mouth for some Camra members.


In a blind tasting at the Great British Beer Festival at Olympia, Abbot Ale, a five per cent beer from Greene King was judged silver medal winner in the organisation's Champion Beer of Britain competition.
Gold went to Elland 1872 Porter, a 6.5 per cent beer from Yorkshire brewery Elland, with bronze won by Shropshire's Salopian Brewery for Darwin's Origin – a 4.3 per cent bitter.
In comments on Facebook some Camra members have questioned how Bury St Edmonds-based Greene King, which is one of Camra's partners for the festival which finishes on Saturday, did so well.
One member said it was travesty and undermined everything Camra should stand for for Abbot Ale, which features in the pubs of JD Wetherspoon – another festival partner– to win silver in the national competition.
Another said Salopian should consider itself the runner-up and a third said it was a farce.
Abbot, first brewed in 1951, had won the competition for premium bitters to get to the final with Darwin's Origin – first brewed in 2009 – winning for session bitter.
Salopian also took home a bronze in the pale, blond and golden ales category for its Oracle brew.
Laura Emson, Camra’s national director responsible for the competition, said winners were crowned purely on the quality of the beer judged on the day.
"As ever, it was a highly competitive final, with the judges having a difficult decision to make. Congratulations to all the finalists – it really shows the wide range and amazing cask beers which are available for all to enjoy.
“Huge thanks to all the competitors for taking part and to the judges who had a tough decision to make."
Judging takes place over almost a year from individual nominations at the outset, to local and regional competitions taking place, ahead of a day of rigorous and intensive judging at GBBF.
One member has called for Camra to review it's policy and terms of sponsorship for the Great British Beer Festival and restrict major sponsors from being able to enter CBOB in future, to remove the ability to question unfairness with financial benefit for future competitions.
Gary Timmins, another national director and chairman of the Walsall branch of Camra, said: "Our competitions are robust and open to scrutiny."
He said they were all done through blind tastings and nominations from members. No one has any idea which beer is which when it comes to the judging.
"Both Greene King and Wetherspoons offered sponsorship and both support real ale," he added.
Mr Timmins said Salopian's success was kudos for the West Midlands region.
"The West Midlands was well represented in the competitions with success for both Salopian and Hobsons," he added.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.
