Shrewsbury Town player ratings after Birmingham City thumping

Michael Appleton's first game in charge of Shrewsbury Town ended in a bruising defeat - here are the player ratings. 

placeholder image

Jamal Blackman 

Made an important save early on to deny Jay Stansfield on what was always likely to be a busy afternoon. Not a lot he could have done with any of the goals, but he conceded four nonetheless. 

Helpless: 5

Luca Hoole

A couple of driving runs, but he was up against Keshi Anderson, and the former Blackpool man was very lively. Hoole was withdrawn at half-time. 

Struggled: 4

Josh Feeney 

The youngster was beaten far too easily for Birmingham’s third goal. It was a tricky afternoon for all involved. 

OK: 5

Aaron Pierre 

Tough afternoon for Pierre and Town’s defence on the whole. The marking for the first three goals was non-existent.

Off: 4

George Nurse 

He got caught out a couple of times up against Jay Stansfield on the left of Shrewsbury's defence. Town were given a working over against a top Blues side. 

Tricky: 5

Mal Benning 

Hard to remember anything Benning did good or bad over the course of the 90 minutes. Tried hard as he always does. 

Quiet: 5

Alex Gilliead 

Recalled to the starting XI but struggled to get into the game as the home side completely dominated the ball and the flow of the game. 

Tough: 5

Dom Gape 

An interesting week for Gape, who was brought in by Ainsworth only for him to leave, like everyone else, he struggled in this clash. 

Struggled: 5

Taylor Perry 

He put himself about, and there was the odd rare moment of quality, but he wasn’t able to influence the game as he would have liked. 

Quiet: 5

George Lloyd 

As always with Lloyd, he covered some distance at the top of the field, but there was very little service to the former Cheltenham man. 

Tried: 5

John Marquis 

A first appearance for the striker since that red card he picked up at Peterborough. He did OK in moments in the first period but was quiet after the break. 

Toiled: 5

Substitutes: 

David Wheeler 4 (Hoole 45), Jordan Shipley 6 (Gape 75), Vadaine Oliver 6 (Perry 75), Morgan Feeney n/a (Nurse 81)

Subs not used: Young, Dinanga, Stewart. 

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice