The overall 90-minute performance possibly didn't quite eclipse the teams' shambolic showing against Walsall in November's 3-0 FA Cup drubbing at the Banks's Stadium.
But the manner of defeat, the significance of it and the vitriolic response it produced from the home crowd made it the bleakest day of the campaign so far.
Town's latest loss was their sixth in a row at the Greenhous Meadow and also the fifth straight home game in which they have failed to score.
Add to that the fact that Saturday's game was as good as over after just 21 minutes and it is easy to see why the team were booed off at the final whistle.
The crowd made their anger well known in the stadium as well as on the radio and internet forums.
And it certainly feels like we have reached a pivotal moment in what has been an erratic and frustrating campaign.
Whether there would have been the same fiery response had Town been edged out by the promotion-chasing Millers in a tight, evenly-contested affair is doubtful.
But the hosts' chances of salvaging anything from the game were left in tatters after what manager Graham Turner called an embarrassing first 20 minutes.
Shrewsbury defender Connor Goldson, who played despite a recently broken nose, had to be alert to block a decent Ben Pringle effort inside the first few minutes. But that aside there had been no real scares.
But Town, who were missing both of their first-choice central midfielders Luke Summerfield and Aaron Wildig through injury, fell behind after just nine minutes.
Striker Tom Hitchcock powerfully headed home from ex-Shrewsbury loanee James Tavernier's right-wing cross.
It was a good finish by the on-loan QPR man, who also netted against Town last month during a loan spell at Crewe.
But it will have infuriated Town boss Turner, who had warned his side in the days leading up to the game about the Millers' direct style of play and aerial prowess.
Also worrying was the fact that it came from an attack down Shrewsbury's left side, as had MK Dons' opening two goals in the 3-2 defeat last Saturday.
And their defensive shortcomings were again exposed when Miles Addison out-jumped his marker to crash a seemingly unstoppable header towards goal from a Pringle corner a few minutes later.
Only a truly outstanding save from goalkeeper Chris Weale, who had to claw the ball back from behind him, prevented it crossing the line. But their relief was short-lived as Pringle netted Rotherham's second on 18 minutes.
Weale did well to deny Tavernier, whose loan spell at Town was ended prematurely by a foot injury early in the season. But the hosts were unable to clear the danger and Pringle eventually rifled home from the edge of the box.
It was a hammer blow, as Turner's men had suggested they might still be able to claw their way back into the game up to that point.
Striker Tom Eaves had been unlucky not to level within two minutes of Hitchcock's goal, having struck the upright after keeper Adam Collin had failed to cover his near post.
But when Tavernier poked home on 21 minutes following a one-two with Hitchcock, the game was all but over.
Asa Hall, handed a starting role in the absence of Wildig, had a chance to cut that deficit soon afterwards but drilled wide.
And Goldson also failed to work Collin with a long-range effort which sailed over.
That has been one of the defining features of Town's unenviable home run recently, with visiting goalkeepers simply not being tested anywhere near enough.
And it continued to be the case on Saturday.
When Eaves managed a routine effort on target shortly before the interval it drew ironic cheers from the frustrated home fans.
The crowd had been noticeably silent approaching the 30-minute mark as Rotherham continued to make the running.
Kieran Agard, who was a constant thorn in Shrewsbury's side, hit the side-netting after a blistering run into the box.
And he went close again soon afterwards with a fierce 20-yard drive which Dave Winfield deflected over.
Town had Winfield to thank again when his block prevented Hitchcock pulling the trigger inside the box. But only the width of the crossbar prevented Pringle making it 4-0 from a superb curling free-kick just before the interval.
It had been a horrendous first-half from the hosts and although they did manage to up the tempo after the break, the visitors were able to coast to the finishing line with few scares.
Dave McAllister gave them a rare uncomfortable moment when his powerful effort was deflected just wide after good work from Eaves and Sidney Schmeltz down the left.
And Schmeltz, on loan from Oldham, had their defence scrambling to clear a dangerous cross after out-muscling Agard soon afterwards.
But Winfield was again needed to prevent substitute Wes Thomas extending the visitors' lead after Lee Frecklington had played him in on goal. Alex Revell and Thomas also missed the target from decent positions in the final quarter of the game.
And Frecklington spared Winfield's blushes, miscuing a simple tap-in after the former Wycombe Wanderers man had misplaced a back pass to his keeper seven minutes from time.
Shrewsbury substitutes Tom Bradshaw and Paul Parry combined well in stoppage time to create a decent chance for the former, who scuffed wide from a tight angle. But the hosts could have no complaints about the final scoreline as they yet again come up short on their own patch.
It should be remembered that Shrewsbury's recent home woes have come largely against the cream of the division.
Rotherham's visit to the Meadow marked the fourth time in six home games that Town had come up against top-seven opposition, following matches against Walsall, Preston and Leyton Orient. But defeats against Tranmere, 21st in the division, and Oldham, 17th, cannot be as easily excused, and it is impossible to ignore the worrying patterns emerging.
Town were again toothless for the most part going forward and have now started to ship goals at an alarming rate – with eight in their last three games. They remain out of the relegation zone, albeit by a point, and their League One survival prospects remain in their own hands. But changes are clearly needed to ensure that remains the case in the 'business' end of the season.
Town's need for offensive reinforcements has been well-documented in recent months, but their recent defensive displays would suggest new recruits at the back should also now be firmly on the agenda.
There were also plenty of calls for changes at the top, with Turner's own position at the club being called into doubt by indignant supporters.
Whatever the fall-out from Saturday's result may be, things clearly cannot go on as they are.

9. d45e1103-2f7b-49d8-aee2-0c1a4e62e98e.jpg
Lee Frecklington of Rotherham United and John Marsden of Shrewsbury Town

10. 511077fc-6a41-42b0-869e-0de271166f0f.jpg
Tom Eaves of Shrewsbury Town tries to get past the Rotherham midfield .

11. cd63acba-97f2-4cd4-8ed0-e1471079583e.jpg
Jon Taylor of Shrewsbury Town is tackled by Robert Milsom of Rotherham United

12. 8f3dffa1-31df-4c66-908a-b242b5934fdb.jpg
David McAllister and Connor Goldson of Shrewsbury Town battle with Lee Frecklington of Rotherham United

