Ollie Westbury analysis: Shrewsbury defensive shortcomings are laid bare on derby day

Shrewsbury Town’s defensive frailties haunted them once again at the weekend.

placeholder image

This time it was in the big one, the cross-border derby, the match which every Salop fan was desperate to see their team win.

And Town ended up losing 3-0 as their local rivals coasted to a comfortable victory.

The result was partly self-inflicted as Paul Hurst’s side hit the self-destruct button from a defensive perspective once again.

The manager said after the game they gave their opponents a helping hand, which they most certainly did with some really poor defensive mistakes.

Salop headed into the clash on the back of a positive result against Leyton Orient, where they had managed to keep their first clean sheet of the season.

Town fans would have been desperate for revenge after Wrexham beat them earlier this year, 1-0 in the FA Cup.

At times, they competed in between both boxes with some neat and tidy passages of play, but they were unable to do anything with their possession – not managing to create a real clear opening in front of goal.

In their opening five League One games, Town have already managed to concede nine goals and have a goal difference of minus five.

Wrexham should not be regarded as the underdogs. They have huge riches to their name. Proven by the fact their new signing Mo Faal, who has arrived from West Brom for £500,000, did not even make it off the bench. Phil Parkinson used Paul Mullin and Stephen Fletcher as attacking substitutes instead.

Hurst was brave in his team selection. Taylor Perry, who has been excellent over the last two weeks, was left out for Funso Ojo, who made his debut – that seemed harsh on the former Wolves man.

The Town boss also decided to leave Tommi O’Reilly, arguably their best player so far this season, on the bench too. Tom Bloxham got the nod, and in fairness, he was Town’s best attacking option in the first half.

They were tactical decisions, but nonetheless, massive calls to make after such a good result last weekend.

Anyone can judge them in hindsight, but Hurst had his reasons and they probably would not have impacted the result anyway.

The Red Dragon’s skipper James McClean had the game’s first clear-cut chance when a scuffed shot fell to him in the box, and he riffled a right-footed effort off the crossbar.

Ollie Palmer, who joined the hosts from Wimbledon in 2022, then gave Wrexham the lead.

Dejected Shrewsbury Town players after they are easily beaten by their cross-border rivals. (AMA)placeholder image
Dejected Shrewsbury Town players after they are easily beaten by their cross-border rivals. (AMA)

A well-worked move saw the ball head out to the left. McClean put the cross in, and Palmer had too much space at the back post to side-foot the ball past Toby Savin.

Toto Nsiala was required to make a vital block to deny striker Palmer his second of the afternoon – again the ball coming into the box from McClean.

Town did settle as the half went on. Leo Castledine headed straight at Arthur Okonkwo and he almost saw a cross deflect into the corner, but they were half chances.

Elliot Lee then made it two for the hosts just before the break. A long run from Ryan Barnett put it on a plate for the midfielder to fire in beyond Savin.

Wrexham got their third after the break, another terrible goal to concede from a Shrewsbury perspective.

Nsiala kicked the ball up in the air, Savin came charging out when there was no need – he ended up in no man’s land – and Jack Marriott slipped the ball into an empty net.

Paul Hurst made three changes after that goal, bringing on Charles Sagoe Jr, Tommi O’Reilly and Josh Feeney for his debut. But, by that point, the damage was already done.

Wrexham have had an excellent start to life in League One and with this victory made it four wins from their opening five games.

Lee shot wide from distance, while Phil Parkinson introduced Mullin, who headed straight at Savin as the hosts looked really comfortable in the closing stages.

Mullin and Seb Revan had other chances to pile on the misery for Salop’s travelling supporters, but missed as the game ended 3-0.

The introduction of Feeney for the first time in a Salop shirt was a positive. Given the start to the season the centre-backs have made, Town have been crying out for some defensive reinforcements.

Feeney had a difficult task against Mullin, but coped with him well in a couple of one versus one situations.

Mal Benning has had a difficult start to the season so all eyes will be pointing at George Nurse, and when he may be able to start his first competitive match.

He is still coming back from two ACL injuries, but could be the answer on the left side with Benning out of form.

The games are not about to get any easier for Town, they face Nathan Jones’ Charlton next weekend in what will be another difficult fixture.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice