Matt Maher analysis: Aston Villa edge closer but the champagne order is on hold

Villa might have ended the weekend one step closer to winning the race for Champions League football, yet frustration stems from a sense they should already be putting in their Champagne order.

placeholder image

For the second time in three home league matches, Unai Emery’s team were 2-0 up but failed to win with Chelsea following Brentford as the second team from west London to stage a comeback.

By the finish, the hosts were grateful for the point they did take, after Robin Olsen’s vital stoppage-time save to deny Cole Palmer a winner was followed by a VAR reprieve when Axel Disasi thought he’d snatched all three points for the visitors.

Emery’s tactic in the aftermath was to focus on a bigger picture in which positives are undoubtedly plentiful.

Saturday’s results mean Villa can finish no lower than fifth, are guaranteed Europa League football and their best finishing position for 27 years. For the first time since 1990, they will end a season above Manchester United in the table and by a considerable margin too.

Yet having got themselves into such a great position to secure Champions League football, Emery knows failure to do so now will represent a major disappointment. His animated reaction on the touchline as the clock ticked down stoppage-time, when Olsen was slow to get the ball back in play, told the true story. So too did his eyes, as he attempted to deliver an upbeat post-match message.

Villa are now clear favourites to finish fourth. Mathematically, it is back in their hands and the eye-test says they look a surer bet than a Tottenham team beaten 7-2 on aggregate in its last two matches.

At the same time, there is an inescapable feeling they have made the finish far trickier than it needed to be. From a position where it might have required only one more win to seal the deal, Villa may need a little more from away matches at Brighton and Crystal Palace and the final home game against Liverpool sandwiched in between.

The latter, a fortnight today, feels particularly key in the wake of Saturday and Villa’s ongoing troubles at home against the seven teams Emery has always referenced as bigger “contenders” for Champions League football than his own.

Since beating both Manchester City and Arsenal in the space of 72 hours in December, Villa have lost to Manchester United, Newcastle and Tottenham at home, the latter two matches by emphatic margins. Chelsea were also 3-1 winners in the FA Cup and more than worthy of at least their point on Saturday after a rousing second-half show.

Villa had made the perfect start when Marc Cucurella put through his own net inside four minutes and though the rest of the first half sat deep, they did so with purpose, Morgan Rogers finishing off the last of several dangerous counter-attacks in style to double the advantage just before the break.

Yet in the second half, with the game seemingly in their hands, Villa simply sat back. It is a style which does not suit them. This time there was no threat on the counter, only sustained pressure from the visitors, the game taking a not dissimilar pattern in style to that seen in last month’s sobering 4-0 defeat to Spurs.

Chelsea, it must be said, were very good. You don’t spend a billion pounds without buying some decent players. Mauricio Pochettino’s trouble has been keeping the best ones fit and putting them together as a team. For the second time in the space of three months, they seemed to find some magic at Villa Park.

That said, for the first hour the visitors’ threat lasted only to the edge of the home side’s 18-yard box.

Despite having more than 70 per cent possession, a first-half Nicolas Jackson header planted on to the post was one of precious few clear-cut opportunities and it was not obvious how they would make a breakthrough until Villa gifted them one. Douglas Luiz dallied as the hosts tried to play out from the back, Conor Gallagher pounced and Noni Madueke fired low into the bottom corner. Even after that, it took a superb goal from Gallagher with nine minutes remaining to level the scores.

Villa got lucky in stoppage-time, not so much with the VAR call which overturned a fairly obvious refereeing error but with the mistake from Diego Carlos which led to Palmer bearing down on goal.

Olsen came to the rescue, though the fact the Sweden international was even on the pitch was a reminder the home side’s fortune was finite. The hamstring injury to Emi Martinez, which saw Villa’s No.1 exit the action at half-time, is now a larger concern than the result. Ditto the groin problem picked up by Youri Tielemans, one of the most impressive performers of the past month.

Emery, of course, has proved a master at finding solutions despite chronic injury troubles throughout the campaign. Encouragement can be found in the manner in which Villa have consistently responded to setbacks. The collapse against Brentford was followed by a 2-0 win at Arsenal, the ultimate reminder they are a team who can beat anyone, anytime, anywhere.

It will not take many more wins to achieve their dreams. Saturday simply told you they are unlikely to do it the easy way.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice