Matt Maher: Sandpapergate has returned a bigger scandal than before

The manner in which Australia dealt with the original incident looks like coming back to haunt them.

Quite often the cover-up can turn out to be worse than the crime.

That is certainly threatening to be the case with Sandpapergate which, eight years on from bringing the downfall of one Australia captain, could now very well bring down another.

At least for the moment, Pat Cummins retains the support of Cricket Australia.

Just how much longer that can realistically remain the case is open to question. Australia are just a few weeks from starting a home Test series against New Zealand and none of the questions Cummins will face in the build-up are likely to be about his team’s chances against the Black Caps.

For those who need bringing up to speed, a quick recap: Back in 2018, then Australia skipper Steve Smith and his vice-captain David Warner both lost their jobs after it emerged another player, Cameron Bancroft, had rubbed sandpaper on the ball during the third Test of a series in South Africa.

All three were given suspensions of varying lengths, following an investigation which determined no other member of the team - of which Cummins was part - were aware of tampering.

Fast forward to earlier this month and recently retired batsman Usman Khawaja releases an autobiography in which he claims that not only did the whole team now, so too did the entire staff. This was quickly backed up by Warner, who described Khawaja’s version as “100 per cent accurate”.

Cummins, captain of the team since 2021, then called a news conference in which he called Khawaja’s claims “100 per cent wrong” and “nonsense”.

In a session totalling nearly 68 minutes, he took every question until journalists in the room had no more to ask.

Yet what at first seemed a show of strength, now seems foolhardy. In response to Cummins, Bancroft broke his silence in a 4,000-word essay siding with Khawaja and Warner.

"The final straw for me to write this account was Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins' press conference," said Bancroft.

"It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone."

All of which adds up to an almighty mess. A Cricket Australia statement backing Cummins is expected over the weekend but it won’t answer the long list of new questions to emerge.

One suspects those attempts to limit the damage in 2018 are going to cause even greater chaos, all these years on.

Related topics:

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice