Rough justice as our cells fill up and inmates are let free
Prisons are full - but why are we letting prisoners out early? asks Roshan Doug
Remember when Tony Blair’s government came to power promising to be tough on crime? I was a chair magistrate at the time and knew it was gloss without substance.
We were told Labour understood victims’ concerns, would protect the public, and tackle the roots (not just the symptoms) of crime. Yeah, sure.
Our current government’s answer to Britain’s prison crisis is even more ludicrous – and thus harder to defend. From tomorrow, a new release model begins being introduced. Under the Sentencing Act (2026) thousands of prisoners serving ‘fixed, determinate sentences’ will be released after serving just one – third of their sentence. One third.
So when a judge announces six years, the public hears six years. But an eligible prisoner could potentially be back in the community after two. That is not a minor technicality. It raises a basic question: what exactly does a prison sentence mean?
I understand that prisons are overcrowded. I understand that rehabilitation matters. But releasing prisoners early because there are not enough cells is not a strategy. It is an admission of political failure.
And there is another – perhaps a more important – question which deserves a straightforward answer: what about foreign national offenders who can legally be deported? More than 10,000 non-Britons are held in custody in England and Wales. That does not mean 10,000 illegal immigrants – some are on remand, some are legally resident and circumstances vary.
But where a foreign national offender has no continuing right to remain in Britain and can lawfully be removed, why should scarce prison space be occupied by them while British prisoners are released early because there are not enough places?


I am not suggesting every foreign prisoner should simply be put on the next plane (though I’m sure many of us wouldn’t mind). Appeals, human-rights obligations and other legal requirements have to be respected. But where deportation is legally available, surely it should be pursued as efficiently as possible.
Every prison place matters. If one is occupied by someone who could lawfully be removed from Britain, that is one fewer place available for an offender who has to remain here.
And this is where the wider direction of travel worries me.
Look at New York under Mayor Zohran Mamdani. Apparently crime has fallen during his first year in office. But his administration has also supported decriminalising certain consensual sex-work offences and New York continues to wrestle with how seriously lower-level offences such as shoplifting should be treated.
I am not saying Britain is about to become New York. But we’re on that trajectory. And anyway, there is a difference between reducing crime and reducing the consequences of crime.
If we start deciding that certain offences are not serious enough to warrant stiff punishment, while simultaneously releasing prisoners early because the prisons are full, we risk sending a rather odd message: Commit a crime – but don’t worry too much. The prisons are full anyway.
Perhaps I am old-fashioned, but I don’t find that terribly reassuring.
The other problem is sentencing has become increasingly difficult to understand. Daniel Thomas, for instance, gets arrested and locked up for protesting against boats. But those held after a terror scare at RAF Fairford base were released on bail within hours.
I think sentencing should mean something. When a judge sentences someone for six years, the public assumes six years means six years. Then come automatic release points, licence periods, recalls and early-release arrangements.


Perhaps we should put the real sentence on the paperwork: ‘Six years – subject to space, policy changes and whatever ministers decide next.’
If someone burgles your home, assaults you or commits a serious offence against you or your family, you expect the sentence to reflect the seriousness of what happened. Discovering that the offender is being released early because the prison estate is under pressure is bound to feel like another injustice, a proverbial slap in the face.
And if that offender is a foreign national who could legally be deported, the question becomes even more obvious: why wasn’t removal pursued first?
This is not an argument against rehabilitation. People can change. But rehabilitation does not necessarily mean remaining in Britain.
The government needs to confront the underlying problem rather than simply moving prisoners through the revolving door faster.
Build sufficient prison capacity. Improve the management of the prison estate. Speed up deportations where the law permits. And make sure sentencing means something to victims as well as offenders. I don’t want a government announcing they are serious about sentences while quietly reducing them when the prison system becomes inconvenient.
We have to acknowledge the causes of overcrowding – years of poor planning, insufficient capacity, and difficult decisions being pushed further down the road.
If a foreign national offender can lawfully be removed from Britain, perhaps a scarce British prison place should be reserved for someone who actually needs to remain here. That isn’t extreme. It is basic common sense. What is difficult to defend is asking victims to accept early release while insisting there is no alternative.
So much for the gloss – tough on crime, tough on the causes of crime. Instead – unpalatable as it may be – Labour is simply not working… for Britons.
Roshan Doug is a social commentator, educationalist and former Birmingham poet laureate