Peter Rhodes on felling trees, hunting recruits and a lesson from Just William

May I apologise for some of my colleagues in journalism who have been agonising over the felling of an ancient oak near a Toby Carvery in Enfield. Each outbids the other with claims to be heartbroken, traumatised and outraged at the spiritual vacuum left by the felling. We have all got a little overwrought.

placeholder image

Reality check, please. The oak was judged by Mitchells & Butler's tree experts to be dying and seriously dangerous. As any insurance broker will tell you, if you ignore a public-liability warning like that, you may as well tear up your policy. Let us suppose the company had dithered and the oak had fallen and killed a blameless pensioner. Those zealots queuing up to condemn the felling (Headline: “Heartless pub bosses ripped down our beloved oak”) would be the first to condemn the lack of felling. (Headline: “Greedy pub bosses killed our Elsie”).

I don't share the modern fad for tree-worship. Human history does not suggest we love trees and trees, after millennia of ruthless deforestation, have no reason to love us. You must have noticed how every storm brings a deadly harvest of “freak” accidents caused by falling trees. I have the tiniest of suspicions that if a tree can kill you, it will. You hug trees if you wish but I will stand well back, thanks.

Donald Trump claims to be a great deal-maker but his latest threat to abandon peace talks in Ukraine, unless he sees a real chance of success, suggests he's a graduate of the Violet Elizabeth Bott School of Negotiating.

In the Just William books by Richmal Crompton, Violet Elizabeth, the spoiled offspring of a millionaire, repeatedly reminds William that if he doesn't do exactly as she wants, “I'll thcream and thcream 'till I'm thick.” Very Trumpian.

Meanwhile, from Vladimir Putin's Russia come reports of police raiding nightclubs in the hunt for young men thought to be dodging the draft for the war in Ukraine. Sometimes, it is not enough to appeal to your citizens' patriotism or sense of duty. I recall a British Army recruiting campaign in the 1980s when a recruiting sergeant admitted to me his envy for the press gangs used by the Royal Navy in Nelson's day: “When you're looking for recruits, you can't improve on half-a-dozen big blokes with truncheons.”

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice