Smartphone bans and fireworks – readers’ letters, plus daredevil flying at Halfpenny Green in 1973


Concerns over plans to ban smartphones in schools, the impact of fireworks on people with breathing difficulties and the issue of slavery and reparations
Concerns over ban on phones
Following the announcement that smartphones are to be banned from pupils’ bags or pockets in schools in England, the RNIB is concerned a blanket ban could disadvantage children and young people with vision impairment.
Research shows that pupils with vision impairment achieve, on average, 33 per cent lower attainment than their peers, and the sight loss charity says every effort must be made to close this gap.
Smartphones are an essential accessibility tool for many pupils with vision impairment, particularly where tablets are not available. Screen readers, magnification apps and colour contrast settings help students access the same information as their classmates.
Children and young people with vision impairment are entitled to the same access to learning as their peers, but sadly this is not always the case. A blanket ban risks leaving some without an essential tool to help them learn and reach their full potential.
Government guidance makes clear that schools must make reasonable adjustments for disabled pupils under the Equality Act. This means blanket bans should not override a student's need to use their own device where it is necessary because of their disability. Removing that access risks putting pupils with vision impairment at a significant disadvantage.
We urge the Government and schools to make explicit exemptions to any mobile phone ban for pupils with vision impairment, in line with existing guidance. Without these reasonable adjustments, students risk being excluded from learning – not because of their ability, but because the tools they rely on have been taken away.
Aarifah Karim, RNIB
Fireworks not good for air
My wife suffers from COPD, Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease. For the last two nights the air purifier which normally helps her to breathe has been registering 10. A very high level of air pollution. Caused we believe by fireworks which were being set off nearby. I beg those who enjoy celebrating with fireworks to consider residents with lung conditions. Smoke from fireworks can increase breathing difficulties. Please do not let off fireworks near houses.
Name and address supplied
Slavery was found in mines
With regard to Mr Alan Jones's comments about slavery he mirrors my thoughts exactly. Here in Wales people were treated incredibly badly, living in squalid conditions and working in the same. From the coal mines and slate mines to the steel and iron works they were just as enslaved as anyone else. No wonder unions became so strong.
Reparations will not and must not be considered if they are not available for all.
Nigel Griffiths, Hanmer
- You can enjoy other pictures from the past and more with our weekly FREE Nostalgia Newsletter - with scores of archive pictures and exclusive features on the history of Shropshire and Mid Wales - all sent to your inbox every week. Sign up here
Have an opinion? We want to hear from you.
Share your views by writing to Readers’ Letters at [email protected]
Letters to the editor must include the writer’s name and address. Letters will only be published anonymously in exceptional circumstances. The editor reserves the right to edit letters for length, clarity or style.
Do you have a picture from the past to share?
We would love to hear from you. Whether you have an old photograph, need help identifying a street or recognise a familiar face, send your images to [email protected]
Please include your name, where you are from and as much information as possible about the photograph. We will publish as many as we can online and in print.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.