Motion to remove towpaths as safe school walking routes for Shropshire children fails
A total of 38 members voted against the motion.
Anyone who voted not to remove canal towpaths as "safe walking routes" for the purpose of school transport eligibility should have it “on their consciences”, one Shropshire councillor said.
At a full council meeting yesterday (May 14) a total of 38 members voted against the motion, with 21 for and five abstaining.
The motion was put forward by Councillor Carl Rowley, who represents St Martins for Reform UK.
It came after parents in Weston Rhyn were dismayed when they received a letter from Shropshire Council saying that any new pupils at St Martins School would no longer receive free transport - something they have received for 39 years.
.jpg?trim=98,0,62,0&width=640&quality=65)

Instead, pupils were expected to walk to and from school – even if their siblings were still having free transport.
The local authority said the route had been "reassessed" and a "safe alternative" had been identified from Rhosweil Canal Bridge, along the canal towpath, which joins St Martins Road.
Following a backlash by worried parents, Shropshire Council said it would reconsider the decision, saying it understood people's concerns.
The Canal & River Trust, which manages the towpath, said that while the suitability of the canal as a route to school is a decision that had to be decided collectively by parents, the school, and Shropshire Council, it would "love to talk" to the local authority about what could be done to improve it.
At yesterday’s meeting Councillor Andy Hall (Lib Dems Whitchurch North), the portfolio holder for children's services, said the council has written to parents to update them that a review is under way. He added that any changes will be delayed until at least September 2027, if they come into effect at all.
"At the time, the route was assessed by WSP [the council's engineering and professional services partner] as safe in accordance with the council's unsafe walking routes policy, which was approved by the previous adminstration's cabinet on March 8, 2023," said Councillor Hall.
"Given the safeguarding concerns raised, I have asked officers to review all routes previously deemed safe by WSP to ensure that assessments are undertaken on a case-by-case basis.
"In considering this motion, I am mindful of the cost of officers' time in the duplication of work, particularly at a time when this council can ill afford additional expenditure, in the knowledge that the necessary reviews and assurance works are already underway to address the complexities involved."
Councillor Sam Walmsley (Lib Dems, Clun) also did not support the motion.
"It is of course essential that decisions made by Shropshire Council prioritise the safety of children and other residents," he said.
"I am a parent, I have two daughters, and throughout their time in primary school, they walked to school and throughout their time I was concerned about their safety.
"They weren't walking on canal towpaths - they were using pavements next to roads and there's a clearer risk there than there is on a canal towpath.
"A slip, a trip, or jostling with other pupils could easily put a child in front of a car. In my younger years, when living elsewhere, towpaths were my preferred option for travel at times, offering a safe, practical and enjoyable way to get around.
"I would have been entirely happy for my children to have used them too. Shropshire Council should not unneccessarily restrict these options in finding the best route for children to walk to school."
Councillor Bernie Bentick (Lib Dems, Meole) added that 2,400 students and children in his division walk along the roads every day, cycle or use public transport.
"Three times per term, there are road traffic collisions on the roads that approach the schools," he said.
"I welcome to review the policy regarding safe walking routes, but I would hope that includes the commitment of West Midlands Ambulance Service to relocate their base in Mercian Close. I reject this motion to look at a very small section."
.jpg?trim=60,0,60,0&width=640&quality=65)

Councillor Rowley told members that they should think hard in what they are voting for.
"While I acknowledge Councillor Hall's comments that they are looking into it, September 2027 is not good enough," he said.
"This needs to be sorted before then. Parents and the school need to know whether or not the transport will be available.
"Highway paths are maintained by the county council, towpaths are not. The reason why this bus was in place was because the roundabout is too dangerous to cross. What is going to happen is the new children will have to walk along a towpath whilst their older siblings get the bus to school.
"There is no additional expenditure, it's already in place."
Councillor Rowley added that there is a risk that the canal could breach, like it did in Whitchurch.
"If you're going to vote against this, then I want it to be on your conscience - every single one of you," said Councillor Rowley.
"If that canal breaches, with children on it, every single one of you should hold your head in shame. This is a child safety issue. You really need to think where you're going with this.
"The children also have to cross a level crossing. The side the path is on, there is no gate to cross a high speed railway line.
"Children just stood there waiting for a train to cross - one push is all it will take. And they will be in front of a train, and I dread to think.
"All I am asking is for towpaths to be removed from the policy and a bus to be put back in place. And the expenditure is already there.
“I really need you to think about this - and don't put politics into it to go against a Reform councillor."
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.