Top West Mercia officer will face 'Plebgate' questions

Former Cabinet Minister Andrew Mitchell, who is at the centre of the Plebgate rowplaceholder image
Former Cabinet Minister Andrew Mitchell, who is at the centre of the Plebgate row

Shropshire's top policeman will face MPs next week after concerns were raised about the "honesty and integrity" of police officers involved in the "Plebgate" row.

Home Secretary Theresa May has also demanded an apology over allegations the officers lied to deliberately smear Government chief whip Andrew Mitchell.

West Mercia Police Chief Constable David Shaw will appear before the Home Affairs Select Committee to answer questions about the row, which resulted in the resignation of Mr Mitchell last year.

It followed an argument on September 19 when Mr Mitchell was told by police not to take his bike through the main gates of Downing Street.

He later apologised for an outburst but denied claims he had described policemen as "plebs".

Chief Constable Shaw's appearance before MPs follows a report from the Independent Police Complaints Commission released yesterday.

It said it believes a West Mercia Police investigation had been wrong to conclude there had been no case to answer for misconduct in connection with a meeting between Mr Mitchell and three officers, which was held after the incident in Downing Street.

The Tory MP had met Police Federation representatives from West Mercia, Warwickshire and West Midlands Police on October 12, in an effort to clear the air.

But, following the meeting, Police Federation member Inspector Ken MacKaill, of West Mercia Police, claimed Mr Mitchell had refused to provide them with an account of the incident and called for his resignation.

A recording of the meeting later revealed Mr Mitchell had in fact spoken in detail to the officers, telling them he had sworn at them but hadn't called them plebs.

An internal investigation conducted by West Mercia Police, supervised by the IPCC, into claims that Mr MacKaill and his colleagues were trying to discredit Mr Mitchell, concluded that none of the officers had a case to answer for misconduct or gross misconduct.

It said while the Federation representatives' comments to the media could be view-ed as ambiguous or misleading, there was no deliberate intention to lie. But the IPCC said yesterday it disagreed with the conclusion. Deborah Glass, IPCC deputy chair, said: "In my opinion the evidence indicates an issue of honesty and integrity, not merely naive or poor professional judgment."

A joint statement from the chief constables of West Mercia, Warwickshire and West Midlands Police said Mr Shaw welcomed the opportunity to appear before the Home Affairs Select Committee next week.

Mrs May called for disciplinary action to be taken against Mr MacKaill and his two fellow officers from the Police Federation.

The Home Secretary said the incident struck to the heart of public trust in the police and urged the Chief Constable of West Mercia to apologise to Mr Mitchell.

Mrs May told MPs in the Commons that the IPCC report made "troubling reading".

She said the conduct of the officers involved was "not acceptable at all", adding "The police need the trust of the public."

Former Labour Home Secretary Jack Straw said the IPCC report suggested that Mr Mitchell had been the victim of "wholly unacceptable behaviour" by some officers.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice