Telford children's home row taken to government inspector

The care company and Telford & Wrekin Council accuse each other of being unreasonable as firm appeals for costs

A care company has urged a government inspector to make Telford & Wrekin Council pay its costs after officials refused to change a planning condition to control the number of staff at a children's home.

But the council has hit back at Ashlee Homes Supported Living for getting planning permission and then attempting to alter management arrangements at bungalows that are used to house four children in St George's.

The Walsall-based care company accuses the council of refusing it with two reasons that do not "withstand scrutiny", are "unsupported by substantive evidence" and that directly contradict previous decisions.

In statements lodged with the Planning Inspectorate the company says the application does not seek to change from four the number of children being looked after.

"The only change sought is to the document controlling the operational details of the care use," the company's agent writes.

The agent claims that council fear of noise, intensification and amenity is "bare assertion unsupported by any acoustic, traffic or quantitative evidence."

The site at Freeston Avenue has 10 parking spaces which the company says is enough over the course of a day.

"The single most significant factor in this appeal — and the one that the council has not addressed — is that the council itself approved the 10-space provision in September 2025, on exactly the same site, for exactly the same land use, accommodating exactly the same number of children.

"The physical parking provision has not changed. The use class has not changed. The number of children has not changed."

But the council hits back in its statements.

Council officials say it has "not behaved unreasonably, either procedurally or substantively; and the appellant has not demonstrated that any alleged behaviour has caused unnecessary or wasted expense.

"The appellant’s submission fundamentally reflects a disagreement with the council’s planning judgement, rather than any identifiable failure in the decision-making process that would meet the high bar required for a costs award," council officials write.

Officials add that the condition was imposed to "secure the acceptability of the development by controlling staffing levels, operational patterns and parking demand and movements."

The local planning authority countered the company's claim that the council was unreasonable with a counter punch of its own.

Officials wrote that they would "present a counter argument that the appellant has been unreasonable to a degree through submission of this application".They add that the application was a variation of planning permission approved in October 2025.

Council officials say they had presented concerns at an early stage in the original application process.

"The appellant then amended the scheme, reducing the number of staff to not exceed five per shift.

"The application was presented at the council’s planning committee and approved on the basis of the revised details, only for the appellant to then submit an application to revert the scheme back to the original staff numbers."

Officials at the council say it is "reasonable to assume based on a worst case scenario that there could be up to 21 staff members on site during a typical day."

They add: "The figure is not used to reflect a concurrent arrangement and should therefore not be read in isolation or out of context."

Officials conclude that they had "significant concerns" particularly over enforceability of parking arrangements.

Residents in the Freeston Avenue area had objected to the change as had St George’s & Priorslee Parish Council.

A planning inspector is set to decide the case after an exchange of written statements.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice