Shropshire Council 'lacked realism' over finances as damning report warns 'radical options' may be needed
The report criticises previous “weak financial management”.
A damning report has outlined the shocking scale of Shropshire Council’s ongoing financial crisis - and the difficult decisions required to balance the books
The council’s financial woes have been no secret in recent years.
In September 2025, four months after the Liberal Democrats took control of the council following 16 years of Conservative rule, the new leadership was so concerned about the state of the books that it declared a ‘financial emergency’.
Since then the council has applied to the government for nearly £200m of emergency loans - known as exceptional financial support (EFS) - to stave off potential bankruptcy.
As part of the agreement to supply the funding the government insisted on an independent review of the council’s financial position.


The review, completed by the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) in May this year has now been published.
It delivers a stark picture of the council’s position and the size of the task ahead - and says the council should not be able to seek a referendum on council tax increases without exploring other opportunities.
The report warns “radical” options could be needed describing the authority as in “extremely poor financial health” with “minimal likelihood” that it will solve the issues “within the next few years”.
The report criticises the council’s ‘lack of adequate financial management’ over a number of years under its previous Conservative leadership, along with the impact of council tax freezes from 2010 to 2016.
It questions how budgets were developed, saying they “lacked realism”, and adds that the authority’s reserves were whittled away to cover for the gaps.
Pulling no punches the report says that the current predictions show the council’s financial gap getting significantly worse, not better - and that it lacks the savings to cover the difference.
It states: “Shropshire Council is in extremely poor financial health.
“There is a considerable financial gap between what it expects to spend each year and the income and other funding it expects to receive.
“The medium-term financial plan (February 2026) forecasts a gap of £120.718 million in 2026-27, rising to £180.318 million in 2030-31.
“There are insufficient reserves to cover these gaps and whilst requests for Exceptional Financial Support (EFS) would provide some respite, this is a temporary measure that will not resolve the underlying issue.
“Instead, the magnitude of borrowing required to fund the EFS compounds the problem.
“There is minimal likelihood that the council will be able to extricate itself from this financial situation within the next few years.
“The financial pressures facing Shropshire Council are due to significant increases in net expenditure and a lack of adequate financial management in the past, as well as the legacy impact of freezes in council tax between 2010 and 2016.
“The costs of adult social services and children’s services are the main drivers of the increase in expenditure, largely due to significant increases in the proportion of adults aged 16-64 requiring long term support and the proportion of children in need – especially those in residential care.”
The report says previous savings targets were unrealistic, and missed their mark by tens of millions of pounds.
It stated that “budgets lacked realism and the council’s reserves were steadily eroded to pay for the consequent continued overspends”.
It adds: “Past savings targets were ambitious, but they were not backed up by any realistic delivery plans and thus regularly fell significantly short.
“When CIPFA reviewed the 2024-25 savings plans in May 2024 it reported that the planned savings were developed late-on in the budget cycle and lacked rigour.
“In practice the financial outturn report to council on 17 July 2025 confirmed that there was a significant shortfall of some £42.8 million.
“A similar pattern emerged in 2025-26. At period 11 the financial monitoring report to Cabinet in April 2026 confirmed that £42.15 million of the planned savings of £59.876 million would not be delivered.”
The report also takes aim at the lack of planning for how the council would function following mass redundancy programmes and “weak financial management”.
It states: “A poorly executed restructure of the workforce in 2024-25 removed some 217 posts without a clear plan for how the council would operate in future.
“The heavy reliance on voluntary redundancies led to a loss of experience and capability in business-critical areas of the council and a light leadership structure risks undermining progress in driving the changes needed.
“The finance function has become heavily dependent on a small number of key individuals, has gaps in key areas, such as debt management, and finance business partnering lacks the strategic and analytical approach required.
“This pattern of weak financial management was not adequately addressed by the leadership team at the time.
“Gaps in the internal control environment identified by Internal Audit were not addressed; optimism bias was rife; subsequent external reviews identified inconsistent engagement between services and the leadership and that staff were reluctant to raise issues or concerns.”
The report commends the efforts taken by the new leadership, but says the scale of the task remains - with the EFS borrowing adding costs of around £8m a year.
It warns that the uncertainty across the world could increase the costs of those debts, and adds that the council has “no clear strategy” to get rid of assets to balance the books.
It states: “The actions to date represent a positive step, but in the meantime the financial pressures facing the council have not yet been addressed.
“Each exceptional financial support tranche generates a permanent annual minimum revenue provision charge and an interest obligation from the year after it is drawn, running for twenty years.
“The 2024-25 tranche of £26.8 million generates a £2.20 million cost per year from 2025-26.
“The 2025-26 tranche of £71.4 million adds another £5.85 million annual cost from 2026-27.
“Wider geo-political uncertainties raise the prospect that borrowing costs might rise in future if interest rates change, and there is no clear strategy in place within the council for a more ambitious programme of asset disposals to offset the borrowing costs.”
The report warns that while the council has plans to address the situation - it needs a tighter focus if it is to tackle the problems.
It states: “The council confirms that the expectation is that from April to September 2026, the focus will be on the development and early delivery of a medium-term transformation and savings portfolio and strengthening the organisational capacity and capability to deliver it.
“This will be a critical time for the council. There needs to be greater focus on addressing the financial gap.
“Without a Financial Recovery Plan, the scale of the EFS required remains difficult to quantify and there is a risk that difficult decisions are deferred and the financial gap will continue to grow.
“The transformation plans being developed need to be supplemented by a robust approach to asset disposals, a scaling back or stopping of discretionary services that the council can no longer justify, and a consideration of more radical options to reduce costs, such as opportunities for economies of scale by sharing service delivery with other authorities.
“Before the council makes any request for further increases in council tax above the general threshold without recourse to a referendum, the council should demonstrate that it has adequately explored all such opportunities.”
Reacting to the findings Helen Morgan, Lib Dem MP for North Shropshire, said: “This report lays bare a shocking catalogue of poor financial decisions made under the Conservative administration over several years. Unrealistic council tax freezes, overly ambitious savings targets with no plans, and a botched redundancy programme that pushed away talent.
“There is rightly positive praise of the recent steps taken to tackle the financial mess that was left. But those who turned a blind eye or stubbornly pursued white elephant schemes should hang their heads in shame today and this report should serve as a wake up call to the scale of the problem the council is now having to turn around.”
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.