Councillor fears 'draconian' plans could see owners fined over dog mess – even if it's cleaned up
Dog owners could be fined for "the audacity" of allowing their dog to foul in an area where the public has access – regardless of whether it's cleared up – a councillor fears.


Ludlow councillor Andy Boddington's claims come after Shropshire Council launched a public consultation to gather feedback on plans to implement a Public Spaces Protection Order (PSPO) for the prevention of dog fouling and the collection and disposal of dog waste by dog owners.
The PSPO has five key components, but one proposal in particular – which would prohibit dog owners from 'allowing dog fouling in the public area' – has been met with backlash from county councillor Andy Boddington.
It is listed separately from a second proposal to prohibit 'failure to appropriately remove and dispose of dog waste if a dog has been allowed to foul'.
The councillor for Ludlow North fears the first rule would apply regardless of whether dog mess is cleared up by the owner or if people pay for access to that public area.


He says: "There is a welcome prospect of dog owners being fined if they don’t clear up poop. Shropshire Council has had these powers since 2013 but it hasn’t used them more than a few times.
"The proposed Public Space Protection Order (PSPO) will extend the power of issuing a fixed penalty notice (FPN) to a wider range of council officers and the police.
"The most contentious issue is the council’s plan to slap a fixed penalty notice on a dog owner whose dog poops anywhere the public can access.
"This applies to fields to which landowners have given access and to an owner whose dog poops at a dog show.
"It applies to fields let out to allow owners to exercise their dogs on a lead. Pooing on what remains of the Foldgate Lane field will be subject to a fine.
"These will not be fines for failing to clear up the mess a dog has left.
"They will be fines for the audacity of allowing your dog to poop in an area where the public has access, even if you pay for that access, even if it is cleared up."
A breach of the PSPO could be dealt with through the issuing of a Fixed Penalty Notice of up to £100, or a level 3 fine (max £1,000) on prosecution.
In response to Councillor Boddington, Shropshire Council said the details surrounding fixed penalty notices and dog fouling have not yet been decided and people are encouraged to share their views on the PSPO consultation.
Councillor Boddington says these are the "most draconian anti-dog rules in Britain" and fears that they will have a "significant impact" on the visitor economy, meaning dog owners who get fined will not come into town again.
"By putting forward such an ill-thought out Public Space Protection Order, which is supported by opposition party leaders, Shropshire Council is bringing public authorities into disrepute," Councillor Boddington added.
"It is damaging its integrity and its relationship with responsible dog owners. It is undermining public support for the decent measures it is proposing.
"I can’t find any other council that has introduced such oppressive measures."


A dog owner from Ludlow who gave his name as Andrew shared his fears with the Shropshire Star that fining people even if they clean up after their dogs will make Shropshire Council a "laughing stock".
He said: "Shropshire Council is tabling a motion to fine dog owners whose dogs foul on public footpaths.
"Now, this is all good and well, however, according to Andy Boddington’s latest newsletter, it will also apply to dog owners who clean up and dispose of their dog’s waste.
"This begs several questions: considering the fact that the majority of mature dogs are house-trained and therefore don’t go at home, where are they supposed to do their business?
"Are the council going to provide public toilets for dogs? Will dogs be expected to wear nappies? What about people who don’t have gardens where their dogs might be able to go?
"Fining owners for allowing their dogs to full public areas is, I’m sure, something that all can agree on, but fining people for cleaning up after their dogs will make Shropshire council a laughing stock."
Under the proposal, dog owners would be prohibited from
- allowing dog fouling in the public area
- a failure to appropriately remove and dispose of dog waste if a dog has been allowed to foul
- dog exclusion from play areas, equipped and fenced sports areas
- dogs on leads by direction
- dogs on leads on the highway
There is an exemption to any exclusion requirement for registered assistance dogs.
Dan Morris, Shropshire Council’s Cabinet member for highways, said: “Whilst there are plans to issue fixed penalty notices for dog fouling the details haven’t yet been decided and that’s why we’re seeking people’s views as part of the consultation.
"Such feedback will enable us to adjust the draft proposals so that they are reasonable and enforceable.
“We therefore encourage people to look at our proposals and tell us what they think.”
To share your thoughts in the consultation, visit shropshire.gov.uk.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.