Bereaved Shropshire families to sue over baby ashes


Bereaved families who never had the ashes of their babies returned to them after cremation are taking legal action against Shropshire Council.
An independent inquiry into infant cremations at the council-run Emstrey Crematorium in Shrewsbury, which concluded earlier this year, uncovered 51 cases where ashes were not returned to grieving loved ones.
Lawyers for affected families are claiming the council breached the Human Rights Act. It was previously said that remains were not returned because the equipment used for cremation between 1996 and 2012 was on the same setting for adults and children, which made it difficult to recover small amounts of ashes.


Ian Cohen, from solicitors Slater and Gordon, is representing 22 families who are now taking legal action against the authority. Mr Cohen believes the crematorium breached Articles 8 and 9 of the Human Rights Act 1998 – namely the right to respect for an individual's private and family life and the right to an individual's religious thoughts and beliefs – as he said they suffered psychological injury as a result of not receiving their babies' remains.
He said: "Every parent will understand the fundamental need to look after and protect their children and those feelings don't stop after they have passed away.
"The families we have spoken to cannot help but feel that they have failed to protect their children and that is as a result of the actions of Shropshire Council."
George Candler, the council's director of commissioning, said: "Shropshire Council confirms that they have received a letter of notification from Slater and Gordon in respect of Emstrey Crematorium, and this has been passed to the council's insurers, who will deal with the matter confidentially in the usual way."
Mr Cohen also said the biggest issue for his clients was to ensure that mistakes were not repeated. He has written to Justice Minister Caroline Dinenage to ask when the national consultation is likely to go ahead.
It emerged earlier this year that parents in other parts of the UK had suffered similar experiences.
Mr Cohen said: "Our clients are very concerned that some three months have passed and they are yet to have any contact from Mrs Dinenage or the Ministry of Justice. The minister has also accepted that sadly other families have had similar experiences elsewhere. There is a real desire from these families to be involved in the consultation."
Bereaved families in Shrewsbury founded the Action for Ashes group, visiting 10 Downing Street earlier this year with a petition signed by 61,000 people calling for the return of ashes to be a legal requirement. Campaigners say they also want a national inspector for crematoriums appointed.
In June, Shropshire Council leader Keith Barrow and other council chiefs held a press conference where they spoke about the public inquiry held into the issue.
A Ministry of Justice spokesman said: "Parents should not have to experience any additional grief like those affected by the issues in Emstrey have faced. We are taking action to make sure that after a cremation infant ashes are returned to their families.
"As we have always said, a public consultation on the rules for cremations will be launched later this year to which bereaved parents will be invited to respond."


Action for Ashes founder Glen Perkins, 54, from Monkmoor, Shrewsbury, said: "It's hard to find the words really when you consider that somebody or a group of people have breached your human rights but I'm glad this has been brought because it's intensified everything. Our lawyer Ian Cohen is currently representing 22 families. I'm so glad these families have come forward."
Mr Perkins started the campaign after he was told there would be no ashes from the cremation at Emstrey of his daughter Olivia, who had died aged four months from sudden infant death syndrome.
Mr Perkins also voiced concerns that there has not yet been word from Justice Minister Caroline Dinenage about the national consultation.
He said: "It's now October and we haven't heard anything since July. It's just not good enough. A letter has been sent to the Ministry of Justice by our lawyers – I've got no idea what's in that letter – and one has been sent to Shropshire Council. Again, I don't know what's in that one.
"I know Shropshire Council are not speaking and it's been handed to their insurers, so I think what happens with Shropshire Council is more likely to be a civil case. There will be compensation but accountability is the important thing and what I want."
Mr Perkins is also calling for a national investigation.