Shifnal school could expand to take pupils from Albrighton housing, trust tells inquiry

The issue of a new secondary school is a major part of plans for 800 Albrighton homes

A Shifnal school could expand to take more pupils from Albrighton, an inquiry has been told.

The Marches Academy Trust, which manages Idsall School in Shifnal, has written to a planning inspector as part of an inquiry into plans for 800 new homes on green belt land in Albrighton.

The controversial Patshull Lane proposal, from Boningale Developments, also includes a local centre, a care home, and a secondary school.

The scheme was rejected by Shropshire Council in December, but Boningale appealed the decision and specifically asked for it to go before a planning inquiry.

The inquiry opened earlier this month, and is set to conclude in October - although in a surprising move, Angela Rayner, Secretary of State for Housing, has announced she will now make the decision on whether to approve the scheme, not the planning inspector.

In a letter sent to the inspector presiding over the inquiry, Sarah Finch, CEO of the Marches Academy Trust, says the organisation would be prepared to expand Isdall School to meet additional places required from Albrighton.

She specifically states the plan could be a “sustainable and cost-effective” alternative to building a new school in Albrighton.

Her letter states: “The trust recognises the importance of ensuring that sufficient educational capacity is available in the Albrighton area and, where additional places are required, would support the expansion of Idsall School as a sustainable and cost-effective alternative to the development of a new secondary school in Albrighton.

“The trust considers that expanding provision at Idsall School would enable additional demand to be accommodated within an established and successful school, whilst making efficient use of existing educational infrastructure.

“The Trust is keen to continue playing a proactive role in ensuring that sufficient high quality school places are available to meet the needs of communities across Shropshire.”

A letter has been submitted to the inquiry on behalf of Boningale Homes in response to the comments from the Marches.

Prepared by Kerrie Norman, from consultants Flinders Chase, it dismisses the offer, and questions if it would physically possible without building on the school’s existing playing fields.

She says Boningale’s proposal for a school as part of its development is a ‘prudent’ option, and “deliverable solution”.

The submission states: “In my view, the letter from the MAT (multi-academy trust) is generic and makes no reference to the scale of expansion in pupil numbers that they could or would support.”

It adds: “The letter makes no reference to the public statements given by the current head teacher of the school that she does not support expansion and that the school is currently full.

“The MAT is unlikely to have been made aware that if they are to host all additional secondary pupil demand, the scale of expansion will require building on their school playing fields.”

The submission also says that such an expansion could provide “challenges” with increased traffic in the area.

It states: “The only feasible location for a new building is in the main school car park and on the current school playing fields.

“There are substantial planning challenges with building on school playing fields, as the Sport England exception tests must be met and the playing fields must be replaced.

“Additionally, there are likely to be challenges with highways and transport with a very large increase in the number of pupils attending the school and travelling by both bus and private vehicle.”

It concludes: “My view is that it is not realistic for Idsall School to accommodate all secondary place demand and that a safeguarded school site is necessary. The provision of the secondary school land at the proposed development makes prudent provision for education and offers a deliverable solution.”

The inquiry is set to resume on October 6.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice