‘No evidence’ of mental illness or ‘baby blues’ in Telford mother who fractured baby daughter's skull

Sarah Ngaba denies the murder of her baby daughter but admits infanticide.

A Telford mother who caused the death of her baby daughter by fracturing her skull was not suffering depression brought on by “baby blues” or a “severe mental illness”, a jury has been told.

Sarah Ngaba, 32, accepts that she caused “dreadful, life-shortening and life-limiting” head injuries to seven-week-old Eliza, who died nearly three years later, but denies murder, claiming she is instead guilty of infanticide.

Jurors at Birmingham Crown Court were told the sole issue for them to decide is whether the balance of Ngaba’s mind was disturbed at the time of the attack caused by a failure to fully recover from the effects of giving birth.

The trial had heard how Eliza died aged two in August 2022 from an infection after her injuries left her vulnerable.

Sarah Ngabaplaceholder image
Sarah Ngaba | West Mercia Police

Ngaba had originally been charged with inflicting grievous bodily harm but faced a murder charge following Eliza’s death.

Ngaba’s defence representatives claim she was not in her right mind when she killed Eliza due to “depression and anxiety” caused by the birth.

The jury had been told during the trial told that Eliza was born in Homerton Hospital in east London on September 19, 2019 because Ngaba, who was living in Shropshire, wanted to be near family members during childbirth.

The court was told that after Ngaba had returned to Telford Eliza was taken to hospital after being attacked on the morning of November 13, 2019.

The jury previously heard that Ngaba, formerly of Briarwood in Brookside, Telford, had stopped to buy a lottery ticket on the way to take her baby to hospital after she attacked her in their Brookside home.

Last week the jury heard from two psychiatrists who both agreed that there had been “no evidence” when they examined the defendant in prison earlier this month that Ngaba was suffering from any “severe underlying mental illness such as schizophrenia or bipolar [disorder]”.

However, a psychologist who had provided evidence to the court that Ngaba was also not suffering learning difficulties and was bright enough to have passed NVQs in college was ordered to be dismissed by the judge.

The jury was told that Dr Robert Lambert-Simpson, a psychologist, had been struck off for “racism” in a misconduct hearing after providing evidence to the police following his assessment of Ngaba in 2020.

Yesterday (Monday, May 18) in his closing arguments to the jury, prosecutor Jonas Hankin KC told the jury that Ngaba’s claim that she was suffering from depression at the time she attacked Eliza was untrue.

He said that there was no evidence of “baby blues” or “depression” caused by the birth of Eliza, and any “depression and anxiety” claimed by Ngaba was caused by her current situation of being in prison and the fact that she did not bond with her baby.

He told the court that while Ngaba had failed to bond with Eliza: “A failure to bond is not a consequence of giving birth - it is a product of having a baby she did not want.”

He added that Ngaba was not “suffering a depressive disorder, albeit one that was mild, that could move the balance from baby blues to a disturbance of the mind”.

He then told the jury: “The true verdict according to the evidence is murder not infanticide.”

The jury is expected to retire to consider its verdict today.

Related topics:
Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice