Rural Shropshire residents up in arms over proposed byway for private road

The issue is set to be decided by a planning inspector as the council takes a 'neutral' stance.

Residents in rural Shropshire have objected to proposals to turn their secluded private road into a byway.

Now a government planning inspector has been called on to decide whether walkers, horse riders, and cyclists should be able to use the route at Crudgington Green, between Shrewsbury and Newport.

Telford & Wrekin Council decided to take a "neutral stance" on the issue after objectors and supporters provided "contradictory" evidence.

The council received evidence in 2001 from seven users who stated that they had been using the private road at Crudgington Green, north of Telford, for a period of at least 20 years before then.

But after making the proposal official in 2023, the council received a flood of objections from people living in the lane.

The private road at its junction with the A442 at Crudgington Green.placeholder image
The private road at its junction with the A442 at Crudgington Green. | Google Maps

Documents sent to the Planning Inspectorate show that the council has not been able to contact the original supporters of the move to check issues with them.

"Given the age of those who have provided the statements of use, it is not clear that any of them are still alive or contactable," statements say.

The 1,758m-long proposed byway leads from a junction on the A442 Queensway to a junction on the Crudgington Moor Lane.

Some 11 objectors have told the council that people who have been living in the lane for 60, 70 or 80 years have "private and as owners andcontrollers we are entitled to use the lane, on the basis that everyone is expected to contribute from time to time to repairs."

The council has told the inspector that evidence for the route came from seven statements of use.

In August 2021 it started an investigation and decided in 2022 to make a formal order which was confirmed the next year.

Officials decided that the proposers had made a case that the route "may be reasonably alleged to subsist".

"The statements of use clearly show that the claimed route was used continuously as a restricted byway by the public, as of right and without hindrance, for a period of 21 years between 1976 and 1997."

But the council acknowledges that there is evidence that a landowner had challenged members of the public on the route, which is contested.

"Any challenge to use of a claimed route needs to be brought home to users clearly and unequivocally," the council has told the inspector.

There is also contradictory evidence about signs.

"The statements that users not recognised were advised that Crudgington Green was private is contradictory to the user statements that specifically state that this did not happen to them," the officials state.

"The level of use described has been taken at face value in the absence of evidence to contradict it.

"The statement that the use is exaggerated should be supported by evidence."

They add that devaluation of property is not relevant to the legal test of whether a right of way may be reasonably alleged to subsist.

The council states that whilst it considers that the evidential threshold required to publish an order has been satisfied, there is a "clear contradiction" in the evidence provided by the users and that of the objector.

A planning inspector will decide the issue on the basis of written statements.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice