Pothole row accuses council of prioritising ones in Shrewsbury

Councillor Kevin Pardy, who is the deputy mayor of Shrewsbury Town Council, received statistics via a Freedom of Information (FOI) request.

Shropshire Council has been accused of prioritising potholes in the Shrewsbury wards that are run by the ruling Liberal Democrats.

Councillor Kevin Pardy, who is the deputy mayor of Shrewsbury Town Council, received statistics via a Freedom of Information (FOI) request that showed the amount of potholes repaired and roads resurfaced within the 17 wards during the first full year of the Lib Dem administration.

According to Councillor Pardy, of the 1,107 potholes repaired, 775 (70 per cent) were in Lib Dem wards. He added that the average number of repairs per those wards was 70.45, compared to 53.3 for the remaining ones.

And during the year, all the three roads resurfaced were in Lib Dem wards.

The Labour councillor said: “Having had suspicion that there was an imbalance in repairs, I visited three Liberal wards before the request for statistics.

“Potholes repaired were no larger than potholes in any other ward nor were they in any position more dangerous than in other wards.

“I did note there was a number of repairs immediately outside of a Cabinet members’ home. Harlescott Grange received the joint highest number of repairs at 176 which tied with the deputy leaders’ ward, Quarry and Coton Hill.

“Harlescott also had two out of three roads resurfaced. As the statistics are so obviously imbalanced, I cannot believe that highways have not been influenced, it is not coincidental.”

Councillor David Vasmer, the portfolio holder for highways who also sits on Shrewsbury Town Council, said: “It’s disappointing that my fellow Shrewsbury Town councillor is trying to score cheap party-political points and inspecting Liberal Democrat wards instead of concentrating on highways issues in his own ward of Sundorne.

“I often get emails from councillors of all parties wanting me to help them get some action on a highway issue in their ward. No matter which political party they represent, I do my best to help.

“If Councillor Pardy wishes to approach me about potholes in his own ward, I would be very willing to lobby on his behalf, but as far as I’m aware he has not approached me so far.”

Councillor Vasmer added that the FOI response will have been influenced by the search criteria used in the enquiry, and if it was focused purely on potholes, it would have excluded other highways work.

He said: “This may not be to Councillor Pardy’s liking, but since the elections last year, the majority of wards in Shrewsbury are represented by Liberal Democrats.

“It is therefore not surprising to learn that more potholes have been repaired in Liberal Democrat wards.

“Let me make it very plain to Councillor Pardy. I do not make any decisions on where potholes are repaired – I Iobby on behalf of all councillors but the decisions are taken by officers.

“Defects and their repair are identified on the basis of inspection policies approved by the council, which also accord with industry standards and codes of practice, and are determined on the basis of road hierarchy, defect severity and risk.

“In simple terms, on how many vehicles use a road and any potential safety risk. There is absolutely no political agenda to influence which defects are repaired first, or where they are repaired.”

Councillor Rosemary Dartnall, who read out her fellow Labour member’s question on his behalf at Wednesday’s Cabinet meeting, asked: “Does it mean that you’ve not raised this exact subject with officers directly and to ascertain whether they have decided to favour the administration councillor’s areas?”

Councillor Vasmer said:  “I would never do such a thing. I lobby on behalf of councillors to say a particular road needs attention, but I leave it to the officers to make the decision on whether action is taken or not.

“I never instruct any officer to do any pothole. My role is ensuring that the rules and regulations are followed by the pothole teams.”

Councillor Dartnall said she wasn’t questioning his procedures as a portfolio holder, it’s questioning whether he has raised the subject directly to officers to see whether they have decided where to prioritise Liberal Democrat wards.

“No, I have never nor would I have any doubt about their integrity,” said Councillor Vasmer.

Councillor Wagner, the deputy leader of Shropshire Council, also pointed out that about 70 per cent of the road network in Shrewsbury are in Lib Dem wards.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice