Councillors accused of point scoring and damaging staff morale over finance criticism
Less information could be made public about Shropshire Council’s finances after leading councillors accused opposition leaders of political point-scoring.


Councillor Gwilym Butler made the comments at a cabinet meeting during a heated discussion about the £23.6 million hole the council is facing in its budget for next year.
The funding gap for 2024/25 had previously been estimated at around £1 million, but councillor Butler told members this had been revised due to inflation and unforeseen pressures in social care.
Councillor Roger Evans, leader of the Liberal Democrat group, voiced concern that the predicted shortfall was “more than we predict we will have in our reserves” – even if the planned £51.4 million in savings the council says it will make this year is delivered in full.
He added: “I’m not sure where this council is going in the future. Are we managing [our finances] or not?
“As an elected member, nearly half of this council is being kept completely in the dark.”
His concerns were echoed by Labour group leader Councillor Julia Buckley, who said many areas targeted for savings had not been consulted on.
However council leader Lezley Picton said only policy decisions had to come before cabinet for a decision following a consultation, not all “operational” changes.
Councillor Buckley also queried why members had not been provided with monthly financial updates as promised at the start of the year.
She asked: “Why is there such a lack of transparency? Why don’t you want scrutiny over this?
“It is because you’re hiding something, or is it because you don’t have any grip of the numbers?”
Councillor Picton responded: “When we have been open and transparent, frankly, the opposition groups have taken every opportunity to twist that and turn it into political messages.
“And you wonder why we haven’t got this wonderful open and transparent way of dealing with you?
“What is going on in terms of some of the comments that have been made, both in the press and on other forums, is out of order.”
Councillor Butler said he had made every effort to “open the doors of transparency” since he took over as portfolio holder for resources in May 2021.
But he said the relentless criticism from opposition councillors could lead to a reconsideration of this approach, as it was affecting staff morale.
Councillor Butler said: “I don’t have to bring quarterly reports on the medium term financial strategy to cabinet. I don’t have to do monthly reports to anybody.
“But I am trying my best to be open and transparent for the staff as well as the residents of Shropshire.
“As the leader has said, everything that we try and do we are just opened for criticism and it is used as a political football.
“I think we as a cabinet need to reassess our situation of what we do have to share and what we don’t have to share moving forward for the benefit of this council.
“Let alone it being used for political purposes, yet again all the opposition are doing is not trusting the professional nature of our senior staff – and I will not have that happen.
“And if that means me not putting further reports in that I don’t have to deliver, that’s a decision that, with the leader, I may well take.
“What’s the point of putting our staff out to dry? There is no trust from the opposition in the running of this organisation.”
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.