Rejected care home would be like 'four-star hotel', developers tell planning appeal

A new 66-bed care home at the centre of a planning appeal would be “like a four-star hotel”, the company behind it has said.

placeholder image

Representatives from LNT Care Developments made the comments at an appeal hearing before planning inspector Michael Cryan, urging him to overturn Shropshire Council’s refusal of the scheme on the outskirts of Market Drayton.

However, officers from the council’s planning, conservation and environmental health departments said the authority’s decision should be upheld on the grounds that the site, at Sych Farm to the north of the bypass, was unsuitable for a care home and was allocated employment land.

They said future residents would be subject to unacceptable levels of noise from the Gingerbread Man pub next door, nearby industrial units and road traffic, and further argued that the farm buildings on site were heritage assets which should not be demolished.

Alistair Wood, planning and development manager at LNT, told the hearing that Adderley Parish Council supported plans and, in his belief, the application should have been decided by Shropshire Council’s northern planning committee.

However Philip Mullineux, development manager for the north of the county, said the parish council had not raised any material issues and the scheme was therefore decided by officers.

Planning policy officer Liam Cowden said that while the council was not against new care homes in principle, it would prefer to see them used only for specialist and end of life care, with older people instead supported to stay in their own homes as long as possible.

Turning to the chosen site, Mr Cowden said Sych Farm was in “a successful, upcoming area” for business and industry, including units owned by Müller and the busy livestock market, and was therefore valuable employment land.

However this was rejected by Mr Wood, who said: “I think it’s been proven over quite a long period now that this site isn’t going to be redeveloped for employment purposes.”

He pointed out that plans were approved in 2009 for six live-work units, which never came to fruition, and no other applications had come forward.

But Mr Mullineux said the council had seen no evidence that the landowners had attempted to market the site for its allocated use.

Mr Wood also claimed the council’s argument that the farm buildings should be retained due to their historic significance meant investors would be even less likely to take on the site for redevelopment.

He said: “I think the council has shot itself in the foot by taking such a stance with the heritage asset.”

This was disputed by Mr Cowden, who said the county was known for its heritage assets and this would be a feature of interest, making the site more attractive.

“There’s no evidence at all to support that,” responded Mr Wood. “After 30 years of this being a protected employment site, nothing has happened.”

He said the care home would create 48 full-time equivalent jobs and would be in a “sustainable, accessible” location.

A needs assessment commissioned by LNT found there was demand in the Market Drayton area for a new care home, he added.

Jo Kemp, senior planning manager for the company, said: “We have built well in excess of 200 care homes. We choose sites very carefully based on where we believe there is a market demand.”

She said the home would be “like a four-star hotel” with spacious en-suite rooms and extra facilities like a cinema and salon.

However Mr Cowden told the hearing the council was not impressed with the applicant’s needs assessment as it focussed exclusively on Market Drayton and its hinterlands rather than the wider north east Shropshire area.

Turning to the issue of noise, public protection officer Nick Hughes said external fans on the nearby pub would cause unacceptable levels of noise in more than half of the care home’s bedrooms, unless residents kept their windows closed.

He said there was “no evidence” that other solutions – such as changing the layout of the building – had been investigated.

Ms Kemp said the layout had taken noise into consideration, but was also restricted by a watercourse and trees.

Mr Cryan will issue his decision report in the coming weeks following a site visit.

Related topics:

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice