New direct Shropshire to London rail service rejected again
The ORR said the proposal would cause “substantial detriment” to current users of the line
The bid for a new direct Shropshire to London rail service has been rejected.
The Office of Rail and Road (ORR) published its decision on the proposed Wrexham, Shropshire & Midlands Railway Company Limited (WSMR) bid this morning.
It is the second time the ORR has turned down an application for the new service.
The rejected proposal would have added a service from Wrexham to London Euston, with stops at Gobowen, Shrewsbury, Wellington, Telford Central, Wolverhampton, Walsall and Nuneaton.
Shropshire politicians including Shrewsbury’s Labour MP Julia Buckley, The Wrekin’s Conservative MP Mark Pritchard and Telford Labour MP Shaun Davies, and county business leaders have been pressing for the application to be approved.
In a report detailing its rejection the ORR said that Network Rail had opposed the WSMR bid arguing it would have eaten into timetable space currently reserved to cope with disruption.
It said: “Network Rail stated that it currently did not support any application seeking to use additional capacity on the West Coast Main Line South fast lines.
“All the proposed paths had conflicts against the base timetable, which Network Rail stated would have significant impacts on other services and service patterns across the geography.
“Network Rail expressed particular concern that WSMR’s plans would use firebreak paths and could be accommodated only with significant retiming of other services in the same area.
“Other concerns Network Rail cited related to adverse impacts on network performance, on overall network resilience and services, on punctuality and reliability across the affected routes, and on congestion issues at key junctions and high utilisation areas of the network.”
The ORR said it had commissioned “external analysis” which concluded the line is already congested and reiterated the need for “firebreaks” in the timetable to cope with disruption.
It said: “Our assessment identified there is still a significant, pre-existing performance issue caused by general congestion.
“This highlights the need for retention of ‘firebreaks’, which Network Rail has introduced in the timetable to assist with service recovery at times of disruption. Using these ‘firebreaks’ for running additional services would further reduce the ability for the timetable to absorb minor perturbation and recover good service.”
The ORR says it examined evidence from WSMR but said it was not enough to persuade it that the new service would not impact on the current timetable.
It said: “In June 2026 WSMR provided additional evidence it had commissioned. We have considered this carefully for consistency with the report we commissioned externally. Our view is that the WSMR report does not demonstrate the proposed WSMR timetable can be robustly accommodated within the existing timetable structure.
“Our external report reinforces our concern that using the WSMR proposed paths would further increase risks to resilience and performance unless the wider timetable is reviewed and rolling stock assumptions are resolved.”
The ORR said that the WSMR proposal talked about the creation of an alternative timetable to make space for the new service.
But it added that while a timetable change is being considered for the WCML it is not yet reached the point where it would demonstrate that the service would be possible without disruption.
It said: “The WSMR evidence submission proposed that additional capacity exists on WCML and describes that an alternative timetable is possible to create further available capacity.
“A significant timetable recast is being considered by industry on the WCML, but it is not sufficiently progressed for anyone to reach conclusions as to whether it might unlock additional capacity.”
The report concludes: “Therefore, we consider that WSMR could not be accommodated at present without a substantial detriment to users of the line.”
Responding to the decision Mrs Buckley said Shropshire “should not remain at the edge of everyone’s railway map” and that she will continue to fight for increased services.
Mr Pritchard branded the decision “completely wrong” and said he would keep fighting for improved services for Wellington.
Writing on social media Mrs Buckley said: “I am deeply disappointed in today's announcement that the proposed Wrexham, Shropshire & Midlands Railway (WSMR) service has not been approved.
“Shropshire remains the only county in England without a direct train to London.
“More than 10,000 people backed this service because they understand what better connectivity would mean for our businesses, jobs, tourism and opportunities for local people.
“Shrewsbury is an economic powerhouse for our region, yet once again other routes have been prioritised while our county remains underserved.
“A direct London service was projected to add around £9 million a year to our regional economy.
“This is a setback, but it is not the end of our campaign. I will continue to explore all options for increased services at Shrewsbury.”
Mr Pritchard said: “This is a huge blow for Wellington and Shropshire. Labour transport ministers and the Office of Rail and Road have got this decision completely wrong and I will keep up the fight for Wellington.”
Mr Davies said: “Today’s decision by the independent Office of Rail and Road is disappointing, but it is not the end of the road for our campaign for better rail connections for Telford.
“I know many people will be asking what happens next. Quite simply, we keep pushing.
“I will continue pressing the Government and rail industry for the more frequent, reliable and better-connected services that Telford residents and businesses need and deserve.
“There is also an important opportunity ahead. Next year, Avanti West Coast is due to return to public ownership under this Government, giving us another opportunity to improve services and revisit the case for a direct connection between Telford and London.
“But this is about much more than London. Telford and the wider West Midlands need better rail connections across the region, and I will continue making the case for more frequent, reliable and better-connected services.
“Better rail links mean better access to jobs and education, easier journeys for families and communities, and greater opportunities for local businesses and our economy.
“Today’s decision may be a setback, but it will not stop me campaigning. I will keep working with residents, businesses, the Government and transport decision-makers to secure the rail connections Telford and wider Shropshire need to grow, thrive and stay better connected.”
Responding to the decision WSMR said: “We are disappointed with the Office of Rail and Road’s decision to reject our application, especially after the effort we’ve made to overcome the concerns raised by statutory consultees over the past two-and-a-half years.
“Improving connectivity is a driver of economic growth and productivity, and WSMR would have unlocked much-needed educational, leisure and work opportunities for communities between North Wales, Midlands and the London corridor.
“Since our application was submitted in March 2024, we have received overwhelming backing from local people, businesses, councillors and MPs, who all recognise the urgent need for this improved connectivity. We are very grateful for this support.
“We now have to review the feedback from the ORR and statutory consultees before we can make a decision on next steps.”
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.