Pensioner who died of pneumonia after going into Shropshire hospital for knee replacement had asked to stay in but was sent home, inquest told

A pensioner who died from pneumonia after going into hospital for a knee replacement had asked medics to keep him in for another night but was sent home, an inquest heard.

Peter Hendry, aged 75, died at Royal Shrewsbury Hospital (RSH) a matter of days after the surgery at Robert Jones and Agnes Hunt Orthopaedic Hospital (RJAH) in Gobowen.

  • Sign up for our FREE weekly Nostalgia Newsletter - with scores of archive pictures and exclusive features on the history of Shropshire and Mid Wales - all sent to your inbox every Friday. Sign up here

It was later discovered that he appeared to have suffered a heart attack two or three weeks before his operation.

An inquest into the death of Mr Hendry was held at Shropshire Coroner’s Court, Guildhall, Shrewsbury this week. The courtroom was filled with Mr Hendry’s family members, medics who were involved in his care, and lawyers.

The court was told that Mr Hendry, of Llanymynech, near Oswestry, had his surgery at RJAH on May 21, 2024 and was in good spirits - described as “the fittest patient on the day” by specialist knee surgeon Dr Tosan Okoro.

He was discharged the following day, after asking to be kept in for another night as something didn’t feel right.

On May 23 he was suffering from chest pains, shortness of breath, loss of appetite and vomiting.

His son Sebastian initially called RJAH, but said he was told it was likely to be routine sickness after an operation, and to try and get his dad to eat and rest.

However, Mr Hendry's condition didn’t improve and he was taken to A&E at RSH.

He was taken into the intensive care unit and died in hospital on May 24.

Four medics gave evidence at Mr Hendry’s inquest.

RSH anaesthetist Dr Matthew Quarmby said Mr Hendry had “community acquired” aspiration pneumonia which was “quite severe”, and that his records suggested he had suffered a recent myocardial infarction - also known as a heart attack.

However, no symptoms of a heart attack showed up in his pre-operative assessment.

Dr Okoro said Mr Hendry reported no medical issues, and that if there had been a suggestion of heart problems, the operation would not have gone ahead.

Dr Quarmby said there is a possibility that Mr Hendry could have had a heart attack and not known about it.

“It’s not uncommon for people to think they are having indigestion when they are actually having a heart attack,” he said.

Mr Hendry’s own father died in his 60s from a heart attack and, given that history, his family asked why he had not received a Troponin test - a blood test commonly used to diagnose a heart issue - in his pre-operative assessment.

But Ruth Longfellow, chief medical officer at RJAH, said guidance from the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) does not recommend blanket tests for pre-op patients who do not present any heart symptoms themselves.

The hearing took place at Shropshire Coroner's Court at Guildhall, Shrewsburyplaceholder image
The hearing took place at Shropshire Coroner's Court at Guildhall, Shrewsbury

“There are a number of organisations that write the guidelines on pre-operative assessments based on evidence and by people with expertise,” she said, adding that it was unlikely that the protein levels in Mr Hendry’s blood would be raised, given it was believed his heart attack happened two or three weeks earlier.

Dr Longfellow said she was “satisfied that a thorough pre-operative assessment” was conducted.

The family also questioned why the hospital discharged Mr Hendry after he had asked to stay in.

“We don’t force people to go home,” said Dr Longfellow, adding that evidence from thousands of patients shows that they recover more quickly in a home setting when they are fit and able to leave hospital. 

Ian MacLennan, assistant chief nurse at RJAH, said the discharge of patients is managed by a group of experienced nurses who have several criteria which a patient must meet before they are considered safe to discharge.

“There was mention in the records that he was considered safe [to discharge],” Mr MacLennan said.

However, he said that in light of Mr Hendry’s death, the hospital has now brought in a procedure where if a patient meets their criteria for discharge but still does not feel ready to go home, their surgeon is consulted and will make the final decision.

The hospital has also changed its practices dealing with telephone calls, as it was an agency nurse who took Mr Hendry’s son’s phone call. More calls are now being made to discharge patients and matrons are advising people.

The family also asked why Mr Hendry was not given antibiotics for sepsis for an hour and 14 minutes, when the target is an hour for severe cases.

Dr Quarmby said the time was unlikely to have made any difference and that Mr Hendry received “high quality” care in the emergency department, including receiving oxygen.

Heath Westerman, deputy coroner for Shropshire, Telford and Wrekin, said he would deliver his conclusion within seven days.

“It is quite complex and I don’t want to rush things,” he told the court. 

Mr Westerman will also consider whether to write a Prevention of Future Deaths Report relating to this case.

Related topics:
Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice