Watch: Residents and restaurant applicants face each other in battle over Shrewsbury tapas bar plan
Restaurant owners and residents clashed in a meeting set to determine the future of a 'quiet' part of Shrewsbury town centre.


On the passionate residents' side were two rooms full of objectors who want to be able to live their lives in peace and quiet - with one room filled with people viewing proceedings live and Shropshire Council's chamber at Shirehall watching via a live stream.
On the other side were the powers behind the hugely successful Dough & Oil and Oil businesses who say that they are willing to compromise but they do represent a vision of the the future of the town.
Aaron Brown, the Dough & Oil entrepreneur, wants to use a part of the The Parade Shopping Centre at St Mary's Place for a new Mexican tapas bar. It would use part of the terrace behind the building. He has the support of the landlords to do that in a bid to attract more customers to the venue.
A large community of residents lives above the businesses and in the quiet area at the back of St Mary's Church.
And in passionate and emotional speeches at a Shropshire Council licensing sub-committee meeting, residents spoke of not being able to sleep because of all the worry.
Stephen Lederer, who overlooks the site, said the prospect of noisy customers eating and drinking and chatting on the terrace "terrifies us".
"It has kept me awake at night worrying. What makes Shrewsbury special is the islands of calm," he said.
"We have managed to protect the town's peaceful places. Often the loudest noise is the birdsong."
He claimed that the terrace site "looms over us like an amphitheatre" and would be a "brutal assault" on the calm of the area.
"Our mental health is at risk."


Other residents during the near two-and-a-half-hour meeting on Wednesday appealed to the three councillors on the licensing sub-committee to side with them.
Some 79 objections had originally been lodged with six withdrawn after the applicants made concessions.
Liz Harrison, who lives four floors above the application site, admitted that she was "very emotional" about the issue and had already experienced noise levels "above acceptable" when hearing "screaming and shouting" from the site before it is even open.
Her claims that the applicant's staff were "singing at high volume" and shouting "FU, FU, FU" in an "intimidating" manner" when she was recording them, were denied by the business.
"The lack of respect does not bode well for the future," she said.
But Mr Brown denied her claim that he had "chosen to lie" instead of apologising.
He said: "This was not us at all."
Shrewsbury BID board member Viv Bhatia, who is a director of Dough & Oil, spoke with equal passion that the application represents the future of the town.
"We are here as responsible operators of Dough & Oil and Oil ," he said.
He added that St Mary's Place is a mixed used building and it is "struggling" and in need of something different.
"Dough & Oil is family friendly and Bobby's will be the same."


Mr Brown said even though the application was for licensed alcohol serving hours until 11.30pm Monday to Saturday, 10.30pm on Sundays and 2am on the days after Bank Holidays Christmas Eve, Boxing Day and New Year's Eve those would not be "executed."
The meeting heard that Bobby's would be a restaurant where people are allowed to drink and "vertical" drinking at the bar would not be allowed.
Mr Bhatia said: "The Parade needs something to re-invigorate it but it should be done respectfully for residents."
He said that problems in the area of "alcohol and drug abuse" could be eased if a business is allowed to open.
"We have been at Dough & Oil for six years and are responsible operators. Our purpose is not financial but to bring people together."
The packed room at Shirehall erupted in laugher at that point from the objectors.
And at that point sub-committee chairman Councillor Nigel Lumby told those present that he would not have the meeting turn into a "game show" and reminded members of the public to listen to proceedings.
Mr Bhatia said that if Shrewsbury is to "progress" the residents would have to "accept that change happens".


Mr Brown told the audience that he lives in Frankwell and hears noise from the Quarry and the Showground but accepts that it is a part of life living in a town.
But residents are so concerned some of them got together and engaged a specialist barrister, Duncan Craig, through solicitors at Hatchers, to fight their corner.
He said the application had caused a "huge amount of alarm" and slammed the licensing application as not being up to scratch.
"If you used a consultant you should be asked for the money back," he said.
"It is common sense that it will have a negative effect. This is one of the worst applications I have seen in 10 years.
"The people who sit behind me have great concerns that lives will be greatly impacted."
He asked the committee, if they are minded to approve it, to impose a condition that bans the drinking of alcohol on the terrace after 5pm and not at all on Sundays.
Resident Russell Harrison urged Mr Brown to withdraw the application but he said he would not.
Jason Freeman, for the landlords, told the meeting that a planning application for changing the use of the terrace would be submitted shortly.
Robert Bowland, a council Environmental Protection Officer said he objected to the licence would disturb residents with noise and smells.


"It is a difficult site to operate from without disturbing residents," he said.
"It would be a welcome addition to the town and very popular but maybe this is the wrong location for this type of venue."
But when Mr Bowland said that the venue attracted younger people who were possibly more responsible for noise nuisance than older people he was slapped down by a member of the sub-committee.
"How relevant is age?" asked Councillor Kevin Pardy.
Mr Boland replied: "It is about behaviour."
And Councillor Pardy replied: "It is irrelevant and should not have been mentioned."
Mr Boland agreed and withdrew the comment.
Peter Stewart, of Shrewsbury Town Centre Residents Association, said it did support a balance between residents and businesses.
But he added: "This is at the wrong place and at the wrong time.
"Profits and the enhancement of life are two different things."
But Mr Bhatia replied that for any business it is "really difficult just to survive.
"For the town centre residents to have a vibrant town it needs people like us.
"Responsible change has to happen."
He added that the proposal has "evolved" as they have listened to the views of residents.
"We are trying to bring something different to Shrewsbury, we need to live together."
Mr Bhatia concluded by saying that they had "compromised massively and we think you should too.
"We will be serving good food and you are all invited."
The sub committee retired into private session to consider their decision which will me published in five days.
The meeting was told that anyone who disagrees with the decision would then have 21 days to appeal to magistrates.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.
