Developer's appeal for self-build houses plans fails
Plans were originally submitted in October 2024
A developer has had its appeal for permission to build five self-build houses on a former sand quarry dismissed.
Bear & Co originally submitted an outline application for the scheme in Ruyton-XI-Towns back in October 2024.
The site, off Olden Road, was previously a sand quarry and part of the Colemere Ramsar site (a wetland of international importance).
At the time, a planning statement submitted by Creative Planning said access to the site would be via the existing entrance, with an access track that runs from the entrance towards the western boundary, parallel to Olden Lane.
A new footpath within the site would connect to the existing footpath on the northern side of Olden Road, the document added.


However, the proposal attracted nine objections from members of the public, with no submissions in favour.
Ros Slowley said: "The latest suggested 'solution' to the inadequate visibility issue is, in my opinion, totally ridiculous, out of place, expensive to build and maintain, unworkable on this busy road with all manner of vehicular use, and is a cynical attempt to gain planning permission at the umpteenth attempt."
It was considered by Shropshire Council's northern planning committee last February. However, it was refused due to the "unacceptable impact” on highway safety, with members concerned about "inadequate" visibility and "substandard" access arrangements.
The developer appealed the decision and it was considered recently by the Planning Inspectorate.
However, despite inspectors concluding that the proposed development would not unacceptably harm highway safety with regard to access, the appeal was dismissed. This was because the inspector was not satisfied that the required mitigation for the Colemere Ramsar site had been legally secured, and the proposal could have an adverse effect.
Following the decision, Councillor Robert Jones, who represents Ruyton and Baschurch, said: “The dismissal of this appeal is very welcome, but I am concerned and disappointed by the inspector’s conclusion that the proposed access arrangements, including relocating the speed limit and introducing a road build-out, would make the development safe in highway terms.
“Local people know this stretch of road well and significant concerns remain about visibility, speeds and road safety.
"While the appeal has been dismissed, I remain worried that a future application could seek to rely on the inspector’s findings, and I am not convinced that the proposed mitigation measures would work safely.
“I will continue to oppose inappropriate development on this site and to put the safety of local residents first.”
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.