Welsh Assembly’s windfarm plans ‘are flawed’

Wednesday 10th November 2010, 11:01AM GMT.

Welsh Assembly’s windfarm plans ‘are flawed’

A Mid Wales environmental campaigner has criticised the Welsh Assembly for its “flawed” plans to build dozens of windfarms in the area.

Peter Ogden, the Welshpool-based leader of the Campaign for the Protection of Rural Wales, said tackling the impact of climate change and reducing CO2 emissions was imperative.

But he criticised the Welsh Assembly for wanting to build industrial-scale windfarms in rural areas because he fears it could destroy the landscape.

Up to 550 wind turbines are set to be built across Powys in the coming years, which could take the total in the county to more than 700.

Powys County Council says up to 23 applications, totalling 548 turbines, have been or are about to be submitted, with many set to get the go-ahead under Government guidance.

Mr Ogden said: “The logic upon which TAN 8, which is a summary of windfarm developments, is based has been flawed from the outset and has encountered many problems during its implementation.

“The Welsh Assembly risks being blind to the damage caused to the landscape by a profusion of industrial- scale onshore wind power plants in remote upland areas. These developments are in fact totally unjustified, short sighted and contrary to sustainable development principles.

“The Welsh Assembly should strengthen mechanisms to get the right renewables in the right places and protect our landscape.”

It comes as developers announced that a fresh application for a small windfarm in Powys will be submitted after planning perm-ission was refused this year.

Cornwall Light and Power will submit the application for the site at Pentre Tump, near Presteigne, next year.


  1. 1
    windy miller

    These things are a blott on the landscape.
    How many jobs will be generated for the local economy – none
    How many jobs will their manufacture create in the UK – none
    The countries who will gain from these montrosities – France, Germany, Denmark.

    What this country needs is a proper thought out centralised strategy about how and where wind turbines are placed and not left to money grabbing land owners to get their pieces of silver.

    As for help climate change – what a load of cods-wallop

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Windy Bottom

    To answer Windy Miller, A modern wind farm requires about 50 staff to construct but most of them are tendered, short term jobs and no guarantee they will go to locals. Once running, a modern wind farm is remotely monitored, with a skeleton staff to maintain them of say 5 or ten engineers. For manufacture, most wind turbines come from abroad and there is little infrastructure available to build them in the UK and according to WAG, the ‘imperitive of preventing climate change’ means there isnt time to build new factories.

    There is no doubt that the human population must affect the climate of the planet due simply to their weight of numbers and need to consume energy that produces pollutants. Anyone who desputes this is clearly deluded. All of the other rubbish described about this issue, on both sides of the arguement is questionable.

    If I told you that we, as part of Europe, are about to embark and pay for a new international super-grid for electricity, using wind power in windy countries, solar in sunny countries and nuclear in the middle countries, trading between us whatever power each country produces, it all makes a bit more sense. It will need an ‘intelligent grid’. It will cost a fortune but will be more efficient as sharing resources always proves to be.

    What remains true and ridiculous is that we are devoting time, money and natural resources on a way of creating electricity that is probably the least efficient use of these resources as wind power is a rich mans dream and a statue to the misunderstanding of the need for the worlds population to protect its’ natural resources by making the most efficient use of them possible. The sooner we use up our natural resources the sooner we all grow poor and cold.

    It then wont matter what state the climate is in.

    The only time when wind power is the right thing to do is when there is no more efficient way to produce electricity. ie away from the national grid or when we run out of nuclear fuel (unlikely as we are now able to recycle much of it).

    Nuclear offers the highest energy density for its mass, the waste has many uses and I find it absolutely appalling that we are only just beginning to explore the possibilities of recycling nuclear waste to provide new fuel and even to heat our homes, for hundreds of years, for free. Now that really is effient.

    Wind power is a consumer fad that we are all part of and all guilty of contributing to. We play at being green while we buy cheap goods from countries still relying on coal for power. You and I are guilty of this, our government is simply trying to relieve us of our guilt.

    Unfortunately it’ll cost a packet.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Jimllfixit

    There is nothing wrong with WAG spending taxpayers money on wind turbines. They are not very efficient but they do produce ‘free electricity’ when the wind is blowing.

    WAG wants to build them in concentrated areas, if they did not do this, they would then definately pop up all over the place and reduce the value of the country to tourism.

    All that matters is that WAG must ensure that they do not trash the roads in the area, resulting in the local economy and roadside property being damaged. It takes a lot of heavy construction vehicles to build a wind farm, especially if they are packed together in zones. WAG never thought about the damage this development work is likely to do, but the local people did, unfortunately it looks like no one listened.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Nistagmus

    I was working on a perpetual motion machine to solve the world’s energy problems myself. I gave up when I realised I was standing on one.

    Report abuse



Video News From ITN

TWITTER

Shropshire Star on Twitter Shropshire Star on Twitter

Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

Entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new Shropshire Star app Get the new Shropshire Star app

Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.