It's the light stuff for Carl

You may have seen Assistant Editor Carl Jones on BBC's The One Show last night, in a feature about his disdain of energy-saving lightbulbs. Here he finds some moral support.

Shropshire lighting shop owner Howard Jones
Shropshire lighting shop owner Howard Jones

“I had to ring you up to let you know that you are 100 per cent correct,” said Shropshire lighting shop owner Howard Jones.

Now that’s the way to get a journalist on side – particularly one who’s faced his share of vitriol for non-PC opinions about eco-friendly lightbulbs.

SHREWS 5HOWJ 4

I’ve got plenty dotted around my home, but when you’re trying to read the paper they’re simply not as bright as the old incandescent bulbs the European Union is seeking to outlaw.

Readers poured out their opinions, making my initial blog one of the most talked-about articles in the past year and bringing it to the attention of BBC’s The One Show, which sent a crew to Shropshire Star HQ to see what all the fuss was about.

They carried out a fairly un-scientific experiment, broadcast last night, designed to see if people really can tell the difference between the old and the new. Yes, I got it wrong – but that was only because they added a red herring, in the form of a silver-sheened halogen bulb!

But Howard Jones, who has been in the lighting business for nearly 20 years, and runs Timothys at Mardol in Shrewsbury, is on my side.

He says he’s currently doing a roaring trade in old-fashioned commercial lightbulbs which he’s imported from America – exploiting a loophole which gets round the latest EU regulations banning their sale.

“What people don’t realise about the new eco-bulbs is that they diminish and deteriorate. The process begins almost straight away, as soon as they are switched on.

“The old bulbs remain exactly the same until they ping off and have to be replaced, but if you look at eco bulbs, they start to go purple and black – technically they are still working, but the light they give out becomes really dim.

“You are not wrong in what you say,” adds Howard. “That is why there is a big demand for the old bulbs, and why we continue to stock them.”

Comments for: "It's the light stuff for Carl"

julian

What a scoop. The chap who sells the old style, difficult to get hold of lightbulbs agrees with you that they are better and that you should keep buying them from him. Got to love it when people are so against anything energy saving and green that they are willing to spend more money than they need to. All the best with your old school bulbs.

Matt

The halogen ones are the bulbs that should be banned. They are supposed to be more enviromentally friendly than incandescent ones yet each bulb is normally 35-40w and people put 8, 10 or more into a room such as the kitchen.

Ian Fursland

Howard, Oh dear that is not very clever! Eveready and Powertech lamps flaunt the EU Directive and the NMO are at present hot footing it up North to dish out some good old fashioned impounding of contraband. I don't think the ER ones are even Rough Service. Says so on teh box but inside they are standard ones. Importing them from America does not get around the Directive Loophole and, let's face it, the Yanks are 120v and have never used a bayonet cap so that's just a porky pie to get the NMO off your back. It's against the rules to sell for domestic use. Business users can happily purchase away.

Matt, Halogen ones are due for Phase out in 2016.... Shows you the technology is not there yet does it!