Star comment: More than taking away a hot meal

In the debate about educational reforms nothing was said about children at primary schools being robbed of their hot meals.

But according to Councillor Cecilia Motley, who is Shropshire Council’s Cabinet member for education and skills, many Shropshire primary schools will struggle to continue to provide hot meals because of an unforeseen consequence of funding changes.

The council’s Shire Services currently provides the 131 Shropshire primary schools with a schools meals service. But from April they will have to apply directly to the Government for the money.

It is being claimed that about half of them, mainly the smaller, rural schools, will not get enough money and that that will mean that they scrap school meals completely.

If this gloomy prediction is anything like accurate, it is a most unpleasant prospect which will rightly dismay parents, many of whom have busy working lives and the knowledge that their child will at least be guaranteed a hot meal is a comfort to them.

Communal meals are part of the learning process for children, educating them how to behave in such situations. There has been too a revolution in the quality of meals which offer a balanced, healthy diet, which may be absent at home.

The alternative will be packed lunches. While schools have rules about what is allowed, the teachers have better things to do than go round doing inspections.

And while communal school meals, by definition, bring the pupils together and consequently promote the school ethos, packed lunches are a very individual affair.

It now falls on the council to work with the schools to come up with a way forward which will lessen the impact of a policy which, on the face of it, will take the food out of children’s mouths.

Comments for: "Star comment: More than taking away a hot meal"

ANDREW FINCH

Interesting topic although i, even after changes question the quality etc of so called school meals .

I find it very hard to believe that even with two working parents they cant find the time or sum up any effort to put a healthy cooked meal on the table in the evening for their children , it is more in the realms of cant be bothered.

Their is nothing wrong with a healthy packed lunch all it involves is the parent being bothered to make it , and re the comment Teachers have better things to do than monitor lunch boxes i doubt very much an actual teacher does this .

It also promotes self responsibility on part of the family, they must learn what is healthy and what is not if they choose to feed their children unhealthy food on a permanent basis and turn their children in to umpa lumpers then they are to blame, giving their children the odd apple or carrot at school is not going to benefit the children at all if they are being fed rubbish at home .

helen

Andrew-

So a child happens to be born into a family where the parents, as you put it "...cant find the time or sum up any effort to put a healthy cooked meal on the table in the evening for their children", or can't afford it for that matter, and that's ok, is it- as a society we owe that child nothing, not even a hot meal at lunchtime? Children have no say in the families or circumstances they are born into- it's pot luck. I thought that decent societies give a hand up to those who need it and surely that includes providing school meals for our kids. This government and our appalling council have their priorities all wrong.

H. St. John Peasbody

If parents cannot afford to adequately feed their child, they ought to consider contraception or abstinence. Or get their priorities right.

helen

I think that every child should be given a decent shot at life whatever circumstances they happen to be born into and whoever their parents are. And sometimes that means that they need a hand from the rest of us. It's not fair to punish or condemn children because of what their parents do/ don't do.

H. St. John Peasbody

I agree but having children brings responsibilities. Too many parents shirk those responsibilities.

ANDREW FINCH

Helen they have fed our children rubbish for decades did you miss that? as long as its hot thats fine as for the cant afford a hot meal at home behave .

James

Andrew, around 3,800 school pupils in Telford and Wrekin, plus another 3,100 in Shropshire took up the free school meals option in 2011. Figures here :

http://www.education.gov.uk/rsgateway/DB/SFR/s001012/sfr12-2011fsm.xls