Leader: Banks need to clean up their act
Hard on the heels of the scandal of Barclays employees rigging interests rates comes a new banking scandal engulfing a number of leading names in the industry.
Hard on the heels of the scandal of Barclays employees rigging interests rates comes a new banking scandal engulfing a number of leading names in the industry.
The Financial Services Authority has found evidence that banks mis-sold products to protect small businesses.
They are now likely to face compensation claims which could cost billions.
The banking industry has worked for generations on the basis that banks are honest, trustworthy, and deal in a prudent and straightforward way with your cash.
When the bank manager deigned to give you an audience, he – it usually was a he – would look down his nose and make you feel that you were not very good with your money, and certainly nothing like as good as him and the financial wizards running his wonderful organisation.
Maybe there was once a time when that was true, before arrogance and recklessness fuelled by uncontrollable greed turned it into an industry of people gambling with other people’s money.
While the banks generated cash for the economy, politicians were happy to look the other way, with powder-puff regulation.
Instead of being the wise and trustworthy harbours of financial expertise for customers, we now know they were just pigs in a trough, working in their own interests, lining their own pockets.
If there is any message to come out of the scandals, it is that if you have a system in which people can get away with it, they will get away with it, and the idea that bankers know best and can be left to police themselves is naive in the extreme.
They have betrayed ordinary people and through their actions have brought hardship to millions. If ever there was a sector which needed to go back to basics, it is the tarnished banking industry.
Comments for: "Leader: Banks need to clean up their act"
The Original Jake
This is probably a gross over simplification, but what's worrying is that back in the Eighties the manufacturing sector was left to fester and die, while the financial sector was encouraged to flourish and prosper, driven entirely by greed and fuelled by relaxed regulations. Wealth was seemingly created from thin air. Now, like a house of cards, it all seems to be collapsing. What's Britain's fall-back position. Oh dear, we don't have one because we don't make anything any more.
pickaxe
I agree with a lot of what you say Jake - but have to nail the myth that we don't make anything anymore. As a nation our manufacturing base is over twice the size it was in the 50's (and that is discounting impact of inflation). OK - it is clearly a smaller proportion of the economy as a whole, but it is still a lot bigger than it ever used to be.
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/02/22/manufacturing_figures/
The Original Jake
Interesting article, but it doesn't really say anything about what's being produced or how the money flows. What I had in mind was the bedrock of all manufacturing, the primary and secondary heavy industries.
For example, our steel making and car manufacturing industries are, to a large extent, in foreign ownership. So while manufacturing output may appear to be up, the money is flowing out of the country. If Redcar steelworks wasn't viable for British Steel (and subsequently Corus), how come the Thai firm, SSI, has invested heavily and reopened it? Llanwern steelworks has bitten the dust. Coryton refinery is closing.
It seems to me that perhaps more - or higher value - stuff is being made by fewer people (i.e. lower employment) and net profits are being siphoned off into foreign investors' pockets.
JOHN JONES
Just a few of the companies that I'm researching in Shrewsbury, for my history project
"Rolls Royce" In September 1978 employed 2,900 people, On site now about 500 [ 2 firms]
" Stadco" In January 1975 employed 500 people. On site today about 300.
Warner-Swasey, in 1974 nearly 500 people, closed in 1976.
"Vaughan Associates in the 70's employed nearly 180 people. closed in 1982.
"Salopian Industries" In 1972 employed 180 people. now closed.
"Hartley's" employed 400 people in 1972 Now Closed.
" Bibby's" employed 150 people now closed,
" Mulitlift" employed 40 people in 1977 now closed.
The list goes on and on.
Doubter
I wonder if the arguments that bankers are so well paid because "they would go abroad or elsewhere if not !" still holds firm?
Not in my world, greedy greedy bankers some of which "earn" £6/8 million a year and still expect £million+ bonuses even if failing to make a profit as if the mega salary is not enough!
What some have done is Criminal and they should be brought to book as a normal working class or even poor person would be.
Jeepers
I think everyone is away now of the fecklessness of the banks. Are they going to improve their act on their own?
Of course they're not. Start *jailing* some of them though and things might just start to change a little.
I'm rather amused though how the Financial Services Authority hasn't been gutted from top to bottom. This organisation was either unaware of all these activities for years or chose to sit by and do nothing about them for years - 'light touch' regulation (probably poltically motivated) at best.
Shouldn't the FSA be paying the price too? Clearly we have here an organisation that is no more fit for purpose that the banks they are supposed to monitor...
Jeepers
Er...I meant to say above "everyone is AWARE now of the fecklessness of the banks."
Sorry about that. My anger got the better of me while typing :-)
adam
they should be nationalised until every paid has been repaid with interest then we can profit from their sale
Roger
It is strange how false impressions are arrived at.
The Government invested money into banks in two ways. 1. Cash which has now all been repaid, and 2. Capital injection in form of money for new shares. In the case of RBS the government owns the bulk of the shares and this is effectively Nationalisation. In the case of Lloyds’s TSB it amounts to just under 45% which gives the Government effective control. So you have your wish and have had it for the last 4 years. We are now waiting for the share price to rise so that the government can sell off the shares. Could be at a profit but that will take time. The Tories were talking about selling part off cheap to the Arabs to spur the market. After the adverse public reaction, nothing more has been said. A sort of soft U turn.
John Howard
"Instead of being the wise and trustworthy harbours of financial expertise for customers, we now know they were just pigs in a trough, working in their own interests, lining their own pockets." What else do you expect from private business, or our elected representatives for that matter? We seem to be wallowing in an era of greed and corruption that appears unstoppable.
James
'They have betrayed ordinary people and through their actions have brought hardship to millions. If ever there was a sector which needed to go back to basics, it is the tarnished banking industry.'
Better late than never. Just don't spoil this encounter with reality by telling us we're 'all in it together' or how doctors/teachers/firemen should 'share the pain'.
Instead, could we have a campaign for the bankers who caused the crisis to be rounded up, dangled off Canary Wharf (by the braces would be good) and pinged up and down a few times till all the money they stole from us falls out of their pockets? This will then be redistributed to those whose pension plans have been affected. The bankers will then be carted off to do 30 years free community service. As a starter, perhaps they could steward the olympics and sleep under Londom Bridge at nights. Cameron and Osborne could join them there and swap yarns about fagging at Eton, or whatever.
Sound good?
Roger
My problem is the title of the article;
Leader: Banks need to clean up their act
The banks have had a thirty year run of light touch regulation in a free market economy. Look at where that has led us. They are now dishonoured, disgraced and dishonest. The very last thing that we need is the banks to sort themselves out. Self regulation has failed and now it is time for stiff regulation. Imposed on the banks. If that means that the casino gamblers move somewhere else and the dishonest dealers go with them, so be it. I think we need to get back to my word is my honour.. Yes we manage billions of pounds of overseas money here and it brings good returns and pays a lot of tax. But why are overseas money men holding their money here? because of the old integrity. If we don't clean it up that money will go away. I think it will stay here if we are seen to ahead of the curve regulating and making investments safe.
The original Jake is right that our decimated manufacturing base is not fit to take over as the engine house of the economy. We need Training in skills education of engineers and investment in British industry and most important of all, respect for Engineers instead of the current situation where accountants and bankers always win the argument because they know what they are doing. We know now that they don't. If the country is to survive as a leading nation we have to start making goods for selves and for export using British companies creating wealth that stays here.
Colin.Dodd.
I must admit to being more than a little puzzled by the recent banking revelations.
If people rob banks,they go to jail.
If bank(er)s rob people,they get obscene bonuses and bailouts.
Answers on the back of a fat cheque.
low finance
it is now obvious the big 4 banks cannot be trusted with our money, but there is a white knight about to charge down our high streets. the co-op bank are buying 600 bank premises from lloyds tsb who have been forced to sell them by the regulators. soon the big 4 will have competition from the co-op bank, virgin money, supermarket banks, santander, and various building societies.
which bank has no merchant bank arm, has never been accused of mis selling, nevor fiddled the libor rate, and never been brought to its knees by lending too much. i give you the co-op bank and when it opens near me, helpful banking will take on a whole new meaning.
i also believe the co-op bank has a policy of always investing in the shares of green companies and certainly not arms companies. i cannot wait for the co-op to rid us of spivs barrow boys, crooks and back hand bonus rogues.
hurry up co-op bank and rescue us from the con merchants!
Huw Peach
There is a branch of the Co-op in Britannia Building Society in the square in Shrewsbury.
The best way to change the banking culture in this country is, like low finance (#9) says, to move your bank account to an ethical bank.
Check out the website Move Your Money UK for advice on how to get your money out of the big 5.
Triodos is a good bank, which only invests in sustainable businesses. We have had an account with them for years, and are glad that our money is invested in businesses which are helping build a sustainable future.
But there are plenty of others like the Ecology Building Society and Shared Interest etc
Surely after this week of appalling revelations about the current state of our banking culture, the only way of cleaning it up is to move our money to institutions with strong core values and sustainable principles.
Andy
Dont forget nationwide!
30 years banking with them - missed one direct debit... instead of hitting me with a fine they notified me by letter that they had paid it and offered me the chance to put it right, along with whatever support i felt i needed.
Bless em!
Ken Adams
I was shocked to find out that the banks are responsible for introducing 97% of our money and the government only 3%. Thus it seems printing money has been privatised, unfortunately were we to print out own money we would go to prison. When you have private institutions controlling 97% of the countries money those who are in charge of just 3% had better tread carefully.
John
BACK IN THE 'BAD OLD DAYS' - the 60's and 70's the majority of the working population were paid weekly with a pay packet in CASH.
Oh how the banks bowed and scraped and made promises if you put YOUR CASH into THE BANKS MONEY PIT.
I suggest when you are paid... take out evry penny not needed to pay bills and put YOUR CASH IN YOUR WALLET ... OR biscuit tin hidden in your house.
Watch the banks squeal and twitch with horror
heeh heh ... as the cash flow trickles down
low finance
i agree let us not forget nationwide, i at present bank with the helpful bank which now opens 2 days a week in my market town. i only keep £10 in that acount and put any other elsewhere.
on the savings side national savings are in the process of closing their card account and deposit bank unless you transfer to telephone or internet banking. er no thanks.
post office savings have introduced a card account called instant investor but you need £500 to open it. a non starter for most.
so hurry up co-op and other worthy institutions, clean up our high street soon ,please
Huw Peach
Yes, Nationwide comes out well in the Ethical Consumer's free guide to Banking Current Accounts, as do other Building Societies, Credit Unions and ethical financial institutions
Ethical Consumer is 'the UK's leading alternative consumer organisation'.
Their website would be a good place for people to start the process of moving their money into institutions which cleaned up their act a long time ago.
The Original Jake
They seem to have stepped up their TV advertising lately. I can't say I blame them.
that bird
the first thing barclays should do is to rebrand their name and motif. i suggest they change their oomygoolie bird to a set of scales and change the colour to green red or any other colour than that which reminds us of fraud, wrongdoing and theft
Roger
Quotation from Wikipedia on the "Big Bang" in 1986 For those in any doubt about when it started.
"In the UK, Big Bang became one of the cornerstones of the Thatcher government's reform programme. Prior to these reforms, the once-dominant financial institutions of the City of London were failing to compete with foreign banking. While London was still a global centre of finance, it had been surpassed by New York, and was in danger of falling still further behind.
Thatcher's government claimed that the two problems behind the decline of London banking were overregulation and the dominance of elitist old boy networks and that the solution lay in the free market doctrines of unfettered competition and meritocracy."
Huw Peach
Yes, the damaging deregulation of the financial system started here in the UK with Mrs Thatcher in the 1980s.
However, according to Ann Pettifor, whose remarkably prescient book, 'The Coming First World Debt Crisis', came out in 2006, the de-regulation of the WORLD's financial system started even earlier, in the early 1970s.
You can read bits of her excellent book online on Amazon's website.
See pp 27 and 28 for her account of how capital flows and trade were regulated by the Bretton Woods system until politicians started the process of de-regulation, which has ended so disastrously.
For those who think that banks can be relied upon to clean up their own act, Pettifor's words (p28) are sobering:
'It is important for our democracies and the empowerment of citizens, to understand that the system has been constructed by political process.'
'It can only be transformed or dismantled by elected politicians, because it involves changes to legislation and regulation put in place by their predecessors.'
The best non-partisan way to ensure that proper regulation of the financial system is achieved, is a full and independent inquiry of what has gone wrong in the banking world, whose recommendations can be implemented by politicians.
Ann Pettifor has a petition on HM Government's website (15,341 have signed so far), calling for a full and independent inquiry into wrongdoing and ethics of bankers:
'We the undersigned call for an independent, judicial public enquiry into fraud, wrongdoing and ethics of British banks, their management and their staff, and the role of the British Bankers Association.
The terms of reference of this inquiry should also include the manipulation of interest rates on about £225 trillion of assets.
The inquiry must have full powers to compel witnesses to appear on oath, and to obtain all forms of evidence.'
http://epetitions.direct.gov.uk/petitions/35421
Ken Adams
Name added thank you
Huw Peach
Thanks, Ken.
15,378 have now signed. 37 in just over an hour.
Word is getting out slowly but surely. Please help spread this further.