Letter: Biomass best idea for Bishop’s Castle

Friday 17th February 2012, 8:00AM GMT.

Bishop's Castle High Street
Bishop's Castle High Street

The directors of Bishop’s Castle Biomass Power Ltd are extremely disappointed with the breakdown of negotiations with Shropshire Council over the terms of the lease for the site of the combined heat and power plant.

Anyone believing in the need for renewable energy, whether for reasons of climate change or energy security, should be deeply concerned by the current outcome. All alternatives to biomass have serious drawbacks. Wind power is intermittent and requires fossil fuel backup and new pylons.

Solar power produces nothing at night and is expensive in the UK, which will be reflected in electricity bills. Neither wind nor solar create long-term local jobs. Anaerobic digestion requires the transport of large amounts of farm slurries or food waste, or use of substantial areas of good agricultural land to grow input crops.

Biomass power plants using locally-produced forestry residues, by contrast, can cleanly replace base-load electricity from coal-fired power stations. There are hundreds of biomass plants in Europe and around the world, and the technology is proven, safe and reliable.

Many communities depend on them for renewable electricity, heat, and for long- term local employment. An appropriately sized plant, sited near to consumers, requires no pylons and avoids the huge power losses associated with long distance transmission. It also stabilises local electricity supply. The by-product, heat, can be distributed to nearby buildings or recycled in processes such as wood pellet-making.

Bishop’s Castle is losing the chance to minimise its carbon footprint and become one of the country’s ‘greenest’ towns. The many full-time jobs that could be created in the fuel supply chain, the energy plant and the businesses that would be developed as a result of a stable electricity and heat network will be forfeited.

The opportunity of a substantial reduction in heating costs of the SpArC leisure centre and swimming pool in its hour of need, as well as the Community College, church and other premises, will also be lost. We remain strongly convinced of the need for safe, sustainable and viable renewable energy solutions.

The Directors
Bishop’s Castle
Biomass Power Ltd

See also:


  1. 1
    Karen Bavastock

    I am speechless!!! Havent they put these arguments to bed and come up with some more convincing arguments!!! Dont patronise us by telling us that solar panels dont produce anything at night – I think we are intelligent enough to know that solar panels need the sun and the sun doesnt come out at night. I could go on and on at every sentence in this statement however our well researched data is available on the internet and we let everyone make up their own minds. Where appropriate biomass can work. We just need more appropriate renewable energy schemes in our town to enhance the many we already have!!!

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Michael Dawes

    This scheme failed to win any perceptible community support. The Directors constantly refused.often agessively to answer legitimate questions and did not give evidence at the Public inquiry. More significantly neither did their engineer C.J.Day Assoc who seem to be in liquidation.
    They repeat the claim of heat supply to local premises despite the fact that they could not persuade the inspector of its credibility and they have done no work to illucidate the engineering or financial viabilty . They have been told in terms that their flimsy and uncosted offers are unwelcome by the potential claimed beneficiaries. A recent report from Arups for DECC makes clear that plant of less than 50MWe are unviable unless the fuel is free. Claims of power stabilisation are denied by the local electricity supplier and a similar plant at Eccleshall has to shut if the grid goes down. It has also had to have in excessive of £1 million spent to control pollution. Ofgem figure show it to be much less efficient than claimed and in any event the developers own figures indicate a thermal conversion of about 15%. Drax can burn the same fuel at about 40%. Do these people not know a turkey when they see one or have they bought the “Kings New Clothes”

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    PETE FROM WEM

    come to Wem or anywhere else in Shropshire, we would welcome the investment, we want to be greener, support more forestry and we are not NIMBYS, forget about Bishops Castle, come and set up shop in Wem and we will welcome you with open arms

    Biomass CHP is a great way to generate green energy and should be supported

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Michael Dawes

    Pete from Wem, whoever you are. A suggestion before taking such a dramatic step perhaps you could invite the “directors” and myself to an open public debate on the matter in Wem. I am always happy to discuss the matter in public and we shall test the claims that you and the developers make on behalf of this technology.
    And
    Why do the very small numbers of “apparent supporters” of this scheme always hide behind pseudonyms and resort to abuse. Lets have your arguement and full name Pete.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    Dudley from Wem

    I’m a bit confused about this letter from The Directors. My understanding was that this group had already got Planning Permission, despite overwhelming local opposition. The project has failed because they couldn’t agree terms for the lease of the site. This is presumably because, despite substantial financial subsidies that would effectively be paid by Electricity Consumers, the plan was still not financially viable. To try to grab the moral high ground based on their Green credentials is somewhat amusing

    Report abuse



Video News From ITN

TWITTER

Shropshire Star on Twitter Shropshire Star on Twitter

Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

LIVE traffic updates

Road, rail and airport - latest Road, rail and airport - latest

Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new Shropshire Star app Get the new Shropshire Star app

Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.