Objectors fear Newport will be killed by homes and supermarket plans

Tuesday 19th July 2011, 1:03PM BST.

The Newport sites earmarked for development
The Newport sites earmarked for development

More than 120 people turned out at a meeting in Newport to have their say on controversial proposals for hundreds of homes and a supermarket. The scheme was announced last month by Telford & Wrekin Council.

Objectors claim the plans for land north of Audley Avenue and either side of Station Road would create “a dead high street with a supermarket at the end”.

Developers want to build more than 600 homes, a petrol station and a huge supermarket on the site.

The proposers, Davidsons Developments and St Modwen, said it could create 500 jobs and bring investment into Newport.

But last night Newport mayor Councillor Roy Scammell told a meeting of the Newport Chamber of Commerce that, through various schemes, more than 1,100 homes were being planned for Newport.

He said the developments would mean more than 3,000 more residents over the next 10 to 15 years.

Councillor Scammell said the developments would see a ‘continuous building site’ in Newport and warned that the town could not cope with such huge expansion.

The meeting at the town’s Royal Victoria Hotel heard concerns about extra traffic, a lack of school places, the loss of greenbelt land and the effect of another supermarket – one 50 per cent bigger than Telford’s Sainsbury’s – on the town.

There were also concerns that the number of houses being put forward did not address local needs.

Carol Murphy, of Station Road, said it was not a case of saying no homes could be built, but that development needs should be agreed by the town council, the town residents and Telford & Wrekin Council.

Chris Degge, of Church Aston, said he felt Telford & Wrekin and the developers were telling rather than asking people in Newport what they needed.

Mr Degge said he feared the result would destroy the town’s identity and create a hybrid of Newport and Telford which he called ‘Telfport’.

Jonathan Dix, of Station Road, warned that the town would become like Oakengates, Wellington or Market Drayton and be “a dead high street with a supermarket at the end”.

And town resident Penny Greenaway said people had chosen to live in Newport because of how the town is now. She said if they wanted to live next to a supermarket they could move somewhere else.

The meeting heard concerns that the developers were applying for a bigger development than was needed, so that they could then reduce the scale of it to show that they were willing to compromise.

Councillor David Adams said if Newport needed another supermarket then a smaller development on the site of the former Royal Mail sorting office in Lower Bar would be a better. He said this would bring people back into the town, rather than draw them to an out of town site.

But David Parker, of the Newport Regeneration Partnership, warned that the clock was ticking. He said a supermarket application was submitted last week and it took around 13 weeks for an application to be determined.

He urged people to write letters of objection to Telford & Wrekin Council based on planning issues rather than emotion. He said individual letters always carried more weight with planners than petitions.


  1. 1
    Hilary Pollard

    Why do all these people keep complaining about new supermarkets? In Madeley traders have an ideal opportunity to rent shops and be on display before people get to the new Tesco. Seems like people don’t see the opportunity.

    Wrekin Computers could have done a roaring trad if they had stayed there :(

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Anon

    What did these 120+ people propose be done with the land instead to benefit the town?

    I assume they came armed with alternative proposals

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    ANDREW FINCH

    I doubt the development would harm newport to be honest the high street is not very inspiring and the shops errrm a little dated, some a little down market ,with the risk of offending someone it really does need to improve.

    Report abuse

    • Stephen Davies

      How exactly would another supermarket, one that is planned for the outskirts of the town, benefit Newport? It is highly unlikely to attract people into Newport if they can buy everything they want under one roof, and with a new petrol station also planned they are not even going to need to drive into Newport to fill their cars up. The town would die, out of town/town outskirts supermarkets kill town centres and they have been doing so around the country for several years.

      Report abuse

      • Black Country ex-Pat

        I am a Newport resident but I object to what you say about the building of an out of town supermarket killing the town centre. For starters, the quality of High Street shops in Newport is very poor. I’d rather go to Birmingham to purchase clothes or shop online for a greater choice of electrical goods and books. What do you have left from that? Nothing but Estate Agents, Hairdressers , Charity stores and overpriced sandwich shops. I would prefer a petrol station on the edge of town as using the Shell garage is a nightmare to wait for and exit from even on a weekday 6-8pm. Also, the existing supermarkets in Town do not cater for all demographics (Waitrose, Co-Operative). Not all residents can afford their prices so the Town would benefit from a supermarket with competitive prices.

        Report abuse

        • Mark

          Right, so you’re saying that the best way to get new businesses into the town centre and encourage people to come into the town is to build a huge supermarket – one that stocks everything – away from the town centre.

          You, sir, are a genius.

          Report abuse

        • Karen Yardley

          As a Black Country ex-Pat then you will know what the huge out of town shopping mall Merry Hill did to Dudley then.

          Report abuse

        • Wile Coyote

          I think what he’s saying is that the shopping in Birmingham (40mins down the road, nation’s 2nd city, you may have heard of it) has better shopping than Newport (small, historic market town.)

          Really? Better shopping in Birmingham? You are indeed, sir, a genius!

          Report abuse

    • John

      Out of town supermarkets are fine as long as high street shops and sales are able to draw in the crowds still. The best way to solve it, is to improve Newport shops, not moan about an out-of-town supermarket. You do both at the same time

      Report abuse

      • Stephen Davies

        The trouble is the high street shops, and I mean independent shops here, cannot compete with the supermarkets when it comes to prices. They do not have the buying power of the supermarkets nor can they sell products at less than cost price as supermarkets frequently do to entice customers through their doors.

        Report abuse

  4. 4
    Wile Coyote

    Ah, the uninformed claptrap just never ends does it?!

    This proposal is a death knell for Newport High Street, similar proposals have killed off numerous ‘towns’ in and around Telford.

    Market Drayton is just one such example.

    There is absolutely no need for a new supermarket to be built on this beautiful greenfield site, there are plenty of brownfield sites for both this and the majority of the proposed houses.

    Hilary- I don’t think you understand what it is you’re talking about.

    Anon- The land is greenbelt it doesn’t need anything to be done to it, it benefits Newport from simply being there.

    Andrew- I appreciate that Newport High Street could do with some improvements but an out of town supermarket isn’t going to be the catalyst for that!

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    Colin.D.

    120 people turned up to object. Out of a population of circa 14,000 that seems like a very apathetic response.

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    The Original Jake

    What Newport really needs is a monorail.

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    John

    What Newport really needs is a port…

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    Shropshire Lad

    As a Newport Resident i feel qualified to comment on this issue, the developments are a consequence of the ever increasing population and a fact of life. What is needed is an improved infrastructure to meet the new demands ie school/Doctors/transport links. The Supermarkets are already well used in Telford/M Drayton/Stafford by residents so i don’t see that affecting the High Street. The shopping centre of Newport died a long time ago and is not unique in this. That doesn’t mean that Newport is any less a lovely place to live and bring up a family. The high street is still a vibrant and busy place at time day and night so don’t talk of Newport as a ghost town!

    Report abuse



Video News From ITN

TWITTER

Shropshire Star on Twitter Shropshire Star on Twitter

Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

Entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new Shropshire Star app Get the new Shropshire Star app

Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.