Rallying call to save Royal British Legion clubs
- Today's leader
Blog: Shropshire hospitals decision made, but many worries remain
Friday 25th March 2011, 11:13AM GMT.
Blog: Health bosses have given their backing to a big shake-up of services at Shropshire’s two main hospitals.
Someone asked me, as I left the last of four meetings called to discuss the proposals, whether I was surprised the plans had won support, writes Dave Morris.
No was my reply.
Since last August, when we first got to hear of the ideas for change, I have always felt there was a good chance they would be approved.
Adam Cairns, the “new” chief executive of the Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital Trust, has been far more convincing over the need to reshape (or reconfigure, as officials say) services at the Royal Shrewsbury and Princess Royal.
He has stressed time and time again that maintaining the status quo is not an option, that the plans have been driven by clinicians, and that changes are necessary to main safe and sustainable services.
Mr Cairns has also been very forceful with warnings that if key services are not reorganised then Shropshire risks losing them to other centres such as Stoke and Wolverhampton.
But not everyone is happy – far from it.
A strong campaign has been run to keep women and children’s services at Shrewsbury with more than 33,000 people from across Shropshire and mid Wales signing a petition.
Some clinicians at the Royal Shrewsbury have also voiced concerns.
However Mr Cairns appeared to have won the argument with influential players even before the county’s NHS trusts had met to decide whether or not to sanction the proposals.
Support in principle had come over the last few weeks from the Shropshire Council cabinet, Telford & Wrekin Council and health watchdogs.
That said, 33,000 people cannot be ignored and they have raised genuine fears, in particular over the danger extra travel times pose for mums and babies in emergency situations.
Mr Cairns and other NHS leaders have said the recent consultation has been tremendously worthwhile, and that they will on board the concerns that have been expressed as they now move forward to draw up more detailed business plans.
They will need to work hard to carry the public with them and allay worries. They will have to prove that the changes they want are safe and in fact services will be better.
If they don’t, then the road ahead is going to be extremely rocky – and 33,000 people will be ready to pounce on the first failed promise or serious incident.
Shropshire Star on Twitter
Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
Entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new Shropshire Star app
Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.

Thank you for blogging about this, as someone who was born at the Royal Shrewbsury Hospital when it was I think, still known as the “new” one it’s very interesting to keep up. Dave, please could you share any links/resources in the Star about news of how Shelton Hospital has fared in any shake-up or anything you have blogged about it? I seem to be having problems with the search facility and mental health provision is an area I’m interested in. Thank you if you do genuinely have time to help me with this and if not, of course no worries!
Report abuse
I am not surprised either, the decision was made and then the ‘consultation process’ had to be seen to be there for the rest of us.
The protests, the meetings and the petitions were a waste of time and effort, but had to be allowed to go ahead to satisfy the masses.
The ‘Decision’ was cut and dried from day one and I am sorry for those of you that raised your hopes and were convinced that your campaign would have an effect.
Report abuse
Hello Dave Morris
People in the County are concerned,fired by half truths & misinformation,it is natural,we are all concerned, we all want the best for our loved ones
However,when at PRH, one sits beside patients,from Bridgenorth & areas north,east & south of the PRH. The catchment areas are not [a]The County against [b]Telford We should be one, working together, for everyone.
The last petition of 25k, has fewer numbers,
than The David Wright mp. led petition, based on the Telford Clp. PLUS the Mark Pritchard mp.led petition, based on The Wrekin Clp.
Please,please please, look at the facts
[1] A & E at both sites 50 times more people,travel from Salop to Telford,each morning, than the other way around, Great/ Super –helping Telford, working in Schools,Factories, the Hospital & Care Homes, Retail etc, You are more prone re-injury, at work than at home. Think about it! [A&E PRH] !
[2] Mother, two children, no Car, living on Sutton Hill.
Return journey RSH.Six Busses min- time 4 hrs.
15 mins PLUS time in Hospital [ Say 6hrs +]
A shuttle service PRH to RSH,both ways is planned.
It is easier & quicker, to move Top Women & Male Consultants,from A to B & visa versa, than you & me.
One County, TWO Hospitals, working together.
Edwards of Ironbridge{TELFORD} Long Mynd,
Much Wenlock,Shrewsbury, Ludlow & the Wrekin &
The Iron Bridge, belong to us all. Please share our Hospitals.
Report abuse
Its a sad result. Now SATH will need to invest over £29 Million in the changes which can take upto 5 years to implement.
You would think that with all the published issues which South Staffs had that Shropshie and Telford Hospital Trust would be wary of these changes.
I just hope that these board members are held responsible when there are problems.
I cannot see any benefits moving these services to telford unless a full emergancy unit is kept at RSH as in the 15 – 20 mins it takes to get to telford some one could die.
I would like to know out of the population catchment in the area if 33000 people were against this then how many were for it – oh yes just the ones on the board.
Report abuse