Teen beauty spot drinkers are ramblers, not rebels
- Dave Burrows
Can’t see video? Update Adobe Flash Player
Video may take a moment to load. Return to Video Index
Families and friends of victims of the Shrewsbury explosion today said they were “shocked” and “disgusted” that no-one will be held responsible for the blast.
And relatives of the victims are today seeking legal advice with a view to making civil claims for compensation.
The Health and Safety Executive’s report of its probe into the explosion at 1-5 Bridge Street on January 3 last year was released yesterday and revealed no evidence of any breach of relevant safety legislation.
The incident left 12 people injured, five seriously including panto star Kiley McDonnell, flatmates Scott Godbold, Sarah Pearse and Sam Devine-Turner and their friend Annie Davies.
Mr McDonnell, who lives in London, has been told he will never walk again.
Today Steve Godbold, father of Scott, said he was outraged at the HSE’s handling of the matter and the findings of its investigation.
He said he was also planning to speak with a solicitor today into the options open to his son in pursuing a civil claim.
Mr Godbold also questioned why there was no mention of BT in the report after it emerged last year that National Grid, in a solicitor’s letter, made allegations about the telecommunications giant relating to the cause of the blast. At the time BT said it believed there was no evidence against it.
Mr Godbold said: “I am seeing a top solicitor and I am not happy at all.
“I was shocked when I read the report. I wrote to Nicola Wade (the lead HSE investigating inspector) in an e-mail recently slamming her for not keeping the families informed. It’s taken over a year for it to come through.
“As for Scott and the other victims, they should have been kept informed about the investigation and to hear nothing until this report came through is disgusting.
“I am very concerned about their (HSE’s) findings. Scott was badly injured in the explosion but poor old Kiley is never going to walk again. He is 33 years old and, because of this, he’s going to have a terrible game trying to claim any sort of compensation.”
Another family member of another victim of the explosion, who wished to remain anonymous, said they were “stunned” by the outcome of the report. They said they were planning to pursue civil legal action.
Paul Bailey, landlord of the Yorkshire House where victim Miss Devine-Turner works, and who organised a £7,000 fundraising event for the victims, said: “Somebody needs to take the blame for that (the explosion), it’s disgusting in my opinion.
“You cannot have individuals residing in a flat and then burdened with a massive explosion which could have claimed their lives and no-one is being held responsible for it.”
Hatice Celebi, who is a partner in Stitch in Time, a clothing alterations shop, in Mardol, and whose husband runs The Star Kebab and Pizza, also in Mardol, said the businesses suffered physical damage in the blast.
She said: “Our insurance company wants to know who is responsible for it.”
By Russell Roberts
Shropshire Star on Twitter
Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
LIVE traffic updates
Road, rail and airport - latest
Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new Shropshire Star app
Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.

where there’s no blame there’s no claim…
Report abuse
..and that won’t please some people!
I wonder how they would feel if they shouldered responsibility if there was insufficient evidence?
Report abuse
So three people lost every thing they owned and still bear the scars both emotionally and physically.
One young man has lost the use of his legs and his life has changed forever.
No one to blame no one to held accountable what if some one had lost their lives no one to prosecute for breaches of health and safty which rules are held up like a paragon of virtue.
As they say ‘Wrong on so many levels’ what if it happens again because nothing was done about the gas pipes under Shrewsbury which where laid down when Noah was a lad.
Report abuse
Now this may be a little difficult for people with an agenda to understand but if evidence found does not lead to show anyone was at fault or that occurences were beyond their control then no matter what you do they cannot be held accountable. People are all to keen to play the blame-game in the hope of lining their pockets.
Well done HSE staff for doing your best, although I sense that unless someone is hung, drawn and quartered some will not be appeased.
Report abuse
I was very sad when the explosion happened and caused horrible injuries to many people.
But the incident has been thoroughly investigated by an organisation that doesn’t take sides and doesn’t hesitate to lay blame where blame is due.
In the end, if this was a genuine unforeseen accident as they say, there’s no point in being “disgusted” with that outcome. Sometimes there’s no-one to blame, it just a cumulation of unfortunate coincidences. Life can be random like that.
If those concerned wish to claim civil compensation, I wish them luck, especially Mr. McDonnell who could obviously put any cash to good use. But in the end, without wishing to sound callous, all of these people survived a horrific explosion which could easily have killed them and a more measured and calculated way forward may be to be thankful that they are still able to express shock and disgust and move on from that horrible event.
Sometimes, pure, “no-blame” accidents happen and the best way to be reasonably sure to receive money as a consequence is to take out life insurance, critical injury insurance or even just accident insurance. If any of those involved had done that, they would have received some money already which would have helped them move on with their lives. Like all of us, they are still vulnerable to future accidents of course, but I am sure that this event will already have convinced them to have already taken out a policy against potential future and I’m sure that they’re now fully covered.
Last points: if any of them owned certain credit cards or operated certain bank accounts, there may be a small possibility that their card or bank contract has a “free” element of insurance, shown as a contract clause which covers them for such incident just for being a client and they could get a bit of a pay-out from their issuer. And does Mr. McDonnell’s actors union not have injury insurance included as part of the benefits of being a member?
Report abuse
Sometimes no one is to blame, accidents happen.
Report abuse
It’a disgrace, someone must be to blame. Those young people are scarred for life.
Report abuse
Bad things happen.It isn’t always someones fault.Sometimes it is just bad luck and slightly bad judgements.
Worse things happen in Iraq.
Report abuse
I can only assume by your insensitivity that 1/You are either playing Devil’s Advocate or 2/You have been drinking the chemicals from underneath the kitchen sink.
“Worse things happen in Iraq”
Yes, they do. Perhaps you should study the John Pilger documentary “The War You Don’t See”
Then take a trip up to A&E and ask someone who has worked there for ten years if they have ever come across a genuine blameless accident.
Twelve months of expensive London barristers and the HSE dragging their heels and passing the buck has led to this conclusion. The most upsetting thing about it all is it is the young and less savvy that have had their lives ruined.
Report abuse
“somebody must be to blame”….why?
The basis of most fault-finding is based on was the incident foreseeable and could the respondants (defendants)have carried out any actions that could have prevented the final outcome? Not a chance, who could have foreseen it happening? Despite experts examining the scene they are unable to point the finger of blame and then would it stand up to the rigors of a court case?
If I have one piece of advice – Mr Godbold save your money, 99% lawyers do what they do for the money. Any number of experts they are prepared to offer you will do so if you’re prepared to pay, you may as well put the money on a 99-1 outsider racing at Kempton Park
Report abuse
Hope those sniffing for a payout had ATE insurance, cos if not they are a whole lot poorer now with their ill-thought and premature legal action…
Unlucky doesnt seem the right term… Tough luck might be more appropriate…
Report abuse