Business and civic leaders in Whitchurch today spoke of their mixed feelings towards proposals put forward by two supermarket giants to create new stores in the town.

Tesco has revealed plans to expand its current operation in the town by creating a new store and petrol station at Edgeley Park – just two weeks after rivals Sainsbury’s announced plans for its own store off London Road.

The news has been greeted with mixed opinions by key figures in the town who think that it could stop people going elsewhere for their shopping, but could also have damaging effects on shops in the High Street.

Councillor Alan Chesters, mayor of Whitchurch, said: “I think a new Sainsbury’s store is very good news as I think it will rejuvenate that end of town.

“I have more concern over the Tesco plans because it involves a big move from the town centre to out of town and think there will be some consequences.

“I know some people are concerned they will affect High Street shops, but they have survived during the Tesco era, so why can’t they survive alongside Sainsbury’s as well.”

Linda Bate, chairwoman of Whitchurch Chamber of Trade and Commerce, said: “I know some people think Sainsbury’s coming to Whitchurch would mean people will stay in the town rather than go elsewhere for their shopping, but others think it will kill the High Street.

“I am sure news of Tesco’s will be met with similar reaction.”

More than 500 jobs could be created as part of the proposals, with the Sainsbury’s scheme poised to create 250 positions, while the Tesco scheme could create work for about 300 people.

The Tesco plan involves the redevelopment of Whitchurch Rugby and Hockey Club but is subject to approval by the club before a planning application is submitted.

Meanwhile, Oswestry Coalition, who for the past several months have been engaged in their own town’s “Store Wars”, is urging people in the town to organise themselves now if they want to fight plans for a new supermarket in their town.

By James Pugh