Telford supermarket legal challenge thrown out
Tuesday 9th November 2010, 5:33PM GMT.
A court bid to challenge a decision which gave the go-ahead for a multi-million pound new supermarket in Telford has been thrown out, it was revealed today.
Telford Shopping Centre owners Hark asked for a judicial review surrounding the granting of planning permission.
Telford & Wrekin Council’s plans board gave planning permission for the Asda store to be built on the authority’s current civic offices site.
But the legal application was refused at a recent hearing at Birmingham Crown Court. Now Hark, which owns the centre where Asda currently has its store, is considering whether to appeal the decision.
A spokeswoman said: “I can confirm that the application to grant leave for judicial review was in relation to the granting of planning permission to build a supermarket on the civic offices site.
“The application to grant leave for judicial review has been refused.” She added: “We are therefore considering appealing this decision.”
A Telford & Wrekin Council spokesman said: “As this is a matter of continuing legal proceedings, we cannot comment any further on this issue at this stage.”
The council’s plans board had approved the application for the new 44,000 sq ft store in January this year.
The plans were passed despite objections from Hark, which had wanted Asda to stay in the centre.
The Asda store plans had been referred to the then Secretary of State but the application was not called in.
Hark also submitted plans of its own to build a £30 million “iconic” timber-clad building on the Red Oak car park to house a supermarket and other retail units, which has also been approved.
Hark had claimed the civic offices development would harm the town centre and cost jobs.
Bosses said it would continue to “vigorously” oppose the application, which it claimed conflicted with both national and regional planning policy.
Asda is hoping to open its new store by 2014.
Council staff are due to move to a proposed five-storey building.
By Lisa Rowley
Shropshire Star on Twitter
Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
Entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new Shropshire Star app
Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.

And where did the money come from that allowed Hark to pay their agents to mount this legal application…. erm perhaps the parking charges,
Report abuse
No self interest by Hark I suppose!!!
Report abuse
Lisa, what ‘harm’ are we to expect to the Town centre development if Hark spoiler campaign against Asda fails? Corps make these kind of claims to attempt to influence decisions then act as if they never existed. This claims been made in a legal manner so what ‘harm’ is there giong to be. (I doubt Hark will throw all it’s toys out of the pram).
Report abuse
It probably will cause harm to the Shopping centre but hopefully its redevelopment will make up for it.
The Asda application this relates to however will be a huge missed opportunity to improve the town centre overall. Its a generic supermarket development sat in the middle of a huge surface car park (as if Telford isn’t already blighted by them) with no activity on three sides of the propsed store. What we should be insisting on and the Council should have demanded from companies bidding to buy the site was a comprehensive redevelopment scheme with streets, squares, mixed use buidings of which a supermarket could have been one and hidden car parking either underground or in multi-storeys. Something that has actually considered urban design rather than how to squeeze as much money from the site for as little outlay as possible. Tesco were willing to regenerate Madeley, the town centre must be far less important to the council. Or maybe they just wanted thier own big fat payoff.
Report abuse
Its a waste of money redeveloping anyway. If shops inside the town centre can’t afford to stay in business, why should it be any different with shops in a new development?
Telford town is too small to cope with a huge redevelopment, why fix what isn’t broken?
Could it be because the council want to spend, spend, spend, on plush new offices. I wonder if it will improve council services at all?
The money would be better spent on the needy and the old people living in our community, who struggle to pay their huge bills every year.
Report abuse