Shropshire TV licence dodgers in court
Tuesday 9th November 2010, 9:00PM GMT.
TV licence dodgers in Shropshire have been slapped with fines totalling thousands of pounds after a spate of sting inspections across the county.
A total of 47 people caught using a TV without a licence were given fines ranging from £475 to £105 by magistrates in Telford yesterday. The largest fine of £475 was to Josephine Kinnare, 27, of Mansell Road in Telford.
Magistrates heard Kinnare already owed £978 in unpaid TV licence fines from previous court hearings.
Ben Lynham, 21, of Market Street, Oakengates, Telford, was fined £110 after he wrote a letter to the court and admitted having no licence.
Two people out of the 47 appeared in court and pleaded guilty to using a television without a licence.
They were Simon Davies, 24, of Waybridge in Telford and Leanne Humphries, 26, of Brindleyford Common, Brookside in Telford.
Mr Davies said: “I have no excuse for not having a licence apart from just separating from my partner and moving to a new address, so I have had other things on my mind.”
Miss Humphries also admitted not paying the licence fee and said she was low on funds. Other people stated via letter to the court that they could not pay the licence fee because of family bereavements, changing addresses, disputes with the licensing authority and being forgetful.
In a recent league table, Telford was found to be one of the worst areas in the West Midlands for TV license evasion.
Mark Whitehouse, for TV Licensing, said: “Overall, TV Licensing caught 33,887 evaders in the West Midlands.
“While people are usually proud to see their town in the top 10, this is one league nobody wants to top.
“The high number of licence fee dodgers caught in Telford is evidence of TV Licensing’s success in enforcing the licence fee on behalf of the honest majority who pay.
“We offer a range of ways to pay, including monthly direct debit, and the option to spread the cost with weekly payments.”
For details, visit www.tvlicensing.co.uk
The court list
£475 fine
- Josephine Kinnare, 27, of Mansell Road, Telford.
£425 fine
- Debora Phillips, 39, of Halifax Drive, Telford.
- Zoe Rowden, 27, of Festival Gardens, Telford.
- Dawn Westwood, 30, of Southfield, Sutton Hill, Telford.
£340 fine
- Amanda Pullen, 40, of Burtondale, Brookside, Telford.
£250 fine
- Katie Brennan, 20, of Crown Mews, Newport.
- Ashley Broomhall, 21, of Orient Court, Gresley Close, Telford.
- Nicola Burton, 30, of Bishopdale, Brookside, Telford.
- Lisa Cartright, 29, of Orient Court, Gresley Close, Telford.
- Annette Chadwick, 37, of Copperbeach Road, Telford.
- Tara Corbett, 23, of St Brelade Close, Telford.
- Claire Ellis, 26, of Eyton View, Telford.
- Rachael Faulkner, 28, of Wildwood, Woodside, Telford.
- Laura Glenholmes, 21, of Bevan Close, Telford.
- Nicholas Harris, 21, of Sandpits Road, Ludlow.
- Claire Harvey, 24, of Wantage, Woodside, Telford.
- Sarah Ingram, 25, of Mortimor Place, Ludlow.
- Rachael Kill, 29, of Willowfield, Woodside, Telford.
- Lisa Lloyd-Edwards, 34, of Victoria Court, Hadley, Telford.
- Emma Nock, 31, of The Grove Estate, St Georges, Telford.
- Miss Emma Owen, 27, of Wombridge Road, Telford.
- Gemma Phillips, 26, of Waltondale, Woodside, Telford.
- David Ralphs, 31, of Peacock Grove, Telford.
- Nyree Rawlison, 26, of Pool Meadow, Telford.
- Owen Roberts, 24, of Grizedale Drive, Doseley, Telford.
- Jenny Smith, 27, of Martin Road, Wellington.
- Steven Taylor, 23, of Church Street, St Georges, Telford.
- Phillip Venables, 22, of St John Street, Wellington.
- Dian Witts, 57, of Webb Crescent, Dawley, Telford.
- Lesley Young, 48, of Leonard Court, Oakengates, Telford.
£200 fine
- Shirley Williams, 60, of Waltondale, Woodside
£175 fine
- Angela Skitt, 42, of Briarwood, Brookside, Telford.
£165 fine
- Dave Mooney, 41, of Springhill Crescent, Madeley, Telford.
£160 fine
- Leanne Humphries, 26, of Brindleyford Common, Telford.
- Jemma Tucker, 25, of St Matthew’s Road, Donnington.
£150 fine
- Penny Gonko, 30, of Woodrose, Woodside, Telford.
£110 fine
- Kerrie Jordan, 23, of Grinshill Flats, Severn Drive, Telford.
- Ben Lynam, 21, of Morson House, Market Street, Oakengates, Telford.
- Anna Plant, 34, of Bracken Way, Newport.
- Carol Smith, 33, of Wealdstone, Woodside, Telford.
£105 fine
- Simon Davies, 24, of Waybridge, Woodside, Telford.
By Peter Finch
Shropshire Star on Twitter
Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
Entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new Shropshire Star app
Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.

Good on em the Tv licensing authority sucks
Report abuse
The BBC’s tv licence should be scrapped. Most it’s programmes are cheap, dumbed-down or politically correct rubbish.
Report abuse
Totally agree, what a waste of time and resources taking these people to court. It should be scrapped, and there are worse offenders out there who basically get away with murder!! Name and shame whats that going to achive????
Report abuse
I think you need to take your remote in for repair. Ask them to check for a short circuit on the “1″ and “3″ buttons.
Report abuse
You call the BBC Programs dumbed down, hate to to think what you think of ITV’s offerings such as X Factor, Britains Got Talent, I’m a Celebrity get me out of here, Harry Hill’s TV Burp, etc
The BBC for its Licence Fee offers good value for money, with excellent programming, not just ratings chasers like ITV.
The majority of viewing here is the BBC.
Report abuse
Yet another nice bit of free advertising courtesy of the Star.
Report abuse
Why not just give up the plastic idiot box altogether. It’s actually quite easy.
Report abuse
Good advice there oldbeastie.
I haven’t had a TV for nearly 20 years.
However, over that 20 years I have been persistently harassed and threatened by TV Licensing who seem to believe that you’re not telling them the truth and having a TV is somehow a mandatory condition for life in the 21st century.
Report abuse
Ta Steve
I live in a house of flats and as they have no lawful right to entry I could get away with it easily if I desired but I have no interest…or kids. Can’t even be bothered with i-player!
Report abuse
I hope you are using a library computer as the TV license covers for this being in your home as well because you can click onto links on the BBC website to watch some programmes as they are being broadcast which is what you pay a license few for.
Report abuse
Ok I’m replying to myself but this i really not about the subject under discussion so I’ll say sorry now.
when I have posted on here in the past I have noticed some spelling mistakes and thought “Damn I’m so stupid but I was sure that I checked my spelling”
this latest post has now appeared after being moderated and the word “Few” has appeared near the end and I am 99.97% sure I did not type that!!!
Report abuse
Oops just realised what I did few was meant to be fee sorry I’ll go away now…
Report abuse
Actually, this is incorrect. Read through their terms and conditions. It is worded in a way that implies you need a license merely for owning a computer, but later makes clear it is only necessary if you watch live BBC streams. Your browsing history is easily monitored, so as long as you are telling the truth you needn’t give in to them. It’s just coercion through fear, otherwise known as bullying. Also notice how their officers are called ‘The Enforcement Team’ these days! Ludicrous. Also, never sign anything. It’s a contract. Sign any correspondence “The Occupier”. Use their own rules and terminology against them and it is possible to get out of ‘needing’ a license as long as you are telling the truth about watching live streams and T.V ownership. Phew… Sorry for the long post!
Report abuse
Pete
In real terms I think this is one that would have to be tested in the courts.
Having access to t’internet and therefore live streams to the bbc is provable on the licensing authorities part, then the defendant may have to prove that they didn’t look at the live streams.This could be difficult.
only a theory tho
Report abuse
What do you point your furniture at if you haven’t got a telly ??
Report abuse
Tongue in cheek question, I’m sure :-) But wouldn’t it be nice to point the seating at other seating for a change, so that people are facing other people, not the TV?
Report abuse
The Shropshire yet again leads the way in groundbreaking local story making!!! How very lazy!
Report abuse
While I accept that non-payment of the licence fee is anti-social, in that it simply means everyone else has to pay more, I can’t help feeling that the Star’s publishing the names, ages and addresses of those fined is a bit excessive.
Why not fill your pages with the details of everyone convicted in the local courts – I’m sure it would make interesting reading for someone.
Report abuse
41 names published, 32 appear to be female.
Not the usual crime sex ratio.
Who were the other 6 – Shropshire Star staff?
Report abuse
No they were court officials and magistrates
Report abuse
Bout time the bloated BBC was cut down to size.Rather have the adverts!
Report abuse
Although they have broken the law, their crime is in a lower scale to drink-drivers, robbers etc.
How about the Shropshire Star printing their details on a weekly “Court’s Page” to name and shame the aforementioned more serious crimes.
Report abuse
Name and shame?
How very Victorian of the Shropshire Star.
Report abuse
Especially when stories on the website are normally very truncated versions…
Report abuse
This is disgusting! There are people who commit worse crimes than this and get their identity protected! Name and shame some of those! Peadophiles have their identity protected, a yobbo 1 month under the age of 18 can remain anonymous!
No wonder the legal system cannot cope with the amount of offenders in the system if they are wasting our time and money chasing money for the BBC!
Report abuse
time to scrap the licence fee.
what a waste of money, the bbc should be set free to advertise like all other stations.
name and shame for tv licence…
shame on you shropshire star,
can’t you find any real news.
Report abuse
Hmmm i see they are doing the old name and shame trick.
If they made decent programs i wouldn’t mind paying the licence fee but all they seem to do is dish out repeat after repeat this i object too.
Abolish the licence!!!
Report abuse
I hope the Shropshire Star is going to play fair and also publish all the names, ages and addresses of all those that live in Shrewsbury and other parts of Shropshire who fail to pay for their TV licences – or is this another one of your swipes just at the people of Telford.
Report abuse
Don’t worry about it. This really won’t change the rest of the countries perception of Telford – just reinforce it.
Report abuse
The issue with this is by law you must have a TV licence these people broke the law so they are prosecuted thats what happens to people who break the law in such a clear black and white way no pun intended . Although I believe the licence fee should be confined to history and it should be pay per view etc ie choice given to the viewer. If the BBC are so confident they provide the wonderful service they do people will pay per view with out it being enforced by law.
Report abuse
I’ve just had mine this morning £145.00, someone has to pay millions to a few overpaid
bums
Report abuse
When people break the law, i am all for name and shame but it has to be done in equal measures. Those names on the list could take legal proceedings against the paper for ‘right to privacy’, ‘equality rights’ or ‘discrimination’. Why, because even though the information provided is a matter of public record from the court, the paper does not do the same in equal measure to other shropshire residents who are convited of other crimes. The paper will claim ‘Freedom of the Press’ but again, it has to be measured equaly with those recorded as commiting other crimes of which the paper does not report.
If anything, those on the list could complain to the Press Complaints Commission for biased reporting.
shame on you shropshire star, get your act together and treat every one fairly.
Report abuse
I totally agree with Andrew Finch. If the BBC opted to go to pay per view it would test their product. You don’t hear Sky or the other independant providers bitching about their fees not being paid. I don’t have a license, and I don’t have a TV. I’m breaking no laws, I don’t watch TV on my computer or any other media, but still get hounded by the licensing “authority”. I’ve passed it to my local MP and would advise any other non-TV owner to do the same. Vamperic, you’re incorrect – you don’t need a TV license for a computer. Don’t make statements that you heard “down the pub” without checking facts.
Report abuse
Looking at the replies here I see there is a lot of confusion over the law. You do not need a licence to own a TV as long as you don’t use it to watch TV programmes as they are broadcast. What else can you use a TV for? Seemples – watching DVDs, video tapes, gaming machines and home security CCTV for instance. As long as the TV is not connected to an aerial or connected to any other device capable of receiving TV as it is broadcast no licence is needed. Nor is a licence required for a set-top box as long as it is used solely for listening to sound broadcasts (TV and radio)as long as it is only connected to an audio system and nothing else capable of displaying a picture – the sound-only (radio) licence was abolished back in 1971. The idea that you need a licence for a PC is untrue because TV Licensing can’t prove that is your intention – a computer has many other uses. Believe it or not neither is a licence needed to watch “catch-up” TV on line – only TV being broadcast at the time. Given bandwidth limitations at present that just isn’t an option except for the fortunate on ultra-fast fibre-optic broadband connections. You can kill someone with a hammer but hammers are readily available and legal to own because most people buy them for lawful use, like PC owners. Just don’t watch TV at the same time as it’s being broadcast on anything and you are completely within the law. However watch out for TVL’s dirty tricks. Don’t let them in to “inspect” your equipment as they aren’t qualified, and will try to operate it in such a manner as to receive “live” TV in order to secure a conviction. Likewise if one of their “enforcement teams” arrives at your front door don’t say anything other than to tell them to sling their hooks.
Report abuse
I get a sick sense of satisfaction from this article. One of the fools on this list is one of my exs, one of the ‘complete cretin’ variety. The day we split up, he tried to leave his TV here passing it off as kindness. What he was actually doing was trying to avoid having to buy a TV License for his flat. So obviously for some of these people its not a case of forgetting, its a case of plain stupidity and going out of their way to avoid it. I’m a single mum, I still have to pay it, I’m exempt from council tax but I still have to pay my TV licence. For the thirty-odd quid it costs every three months what exactly is the issue?
Report abuse
Soapbox, much?
Report abuse