No end in sight to overcrowded train service

Saturday 17th July 2010, 11:30AM BST.

No end in sight to overcrowded train service

Problems with overcrowding on trains in Shropshire which has seen one service being dubbed the “sardine express” looks unlikely to be sorted out before 2015, it was revealed today.

Wellington Town Council held a meeting with train company London Midland to get answers about rush-hour crowds on trains travelling through the county to Wolverhampton and Birmingham.

But Nicola Moss, from London Midland, said the company could not sort out the problem immediately because it is in a contract with the Government to carry out the service only until 2015, with no guarantee the contract will continue.

Mrs Moss said it would therefore be financially impossible for the company to lay on extra carriages because it would not be able to claw back enough revenue to pay for them between now and 2015.

Councillor Denis Allen, from Wellington Town Council, said it was a problem faced by all operators of the line and said it was not a direct fault of the train company.

Mrs Moss said: “We don’t have any spare rolling stock (extra carriages) so there’s nothing that we are not putting on our services, everything we have is in use on a daily basis.

“The costs are very high in purchasing rolling stock and as a franchise we run until 2015 and for new rolling stock we would need further funding from the Government.

“We are working to see if a business case can be made but we will have to wait and see what happens after spending review plans.”

On the current overcrowding she added: “Now we have systems in place to count the number of passengers and we do our best to match the number of carriages we have to the busiest services so we can do the best we can.”

Both Wrekin MP Mark Pritchard and Shrewsbury MP Daniel Kawczynski have raised concerns over the packed train carriages.

Mr Kawczynski called for a debate in the House of Commons about the issue while it was Mr Pritchard who coined the “sardine express” phrase to a transport select committee when he called for a limit on the number of passengers in carriages, which train operators have no legal obligation to meet.

Mrs Moss added the company was announced as the most improved operator this year and said it is working with the Department of Transport in a bid to secure more funding for rolling stock.


  1. 1
    Vicky

    You are confusing one company with another. The sardine express was an Arriva service which only ran 2 carriages at a peak time. I dont think it will get any better as the government are trying to get out of a commitment made by the previous administration of providing 1200 new carriages to alleviate overcrowding. Train companies try and run their services on the subsidy they receive from the government and grants from local authorities. In my experience they do not seem to be bothered about collecting fares on trains as they are looking to shut ticket offices and are prepared to loose revenue at stations by not providing ticket barriers or spot checks.Most private companies would be chasing money not losing it.

    Report abuse

    • Matt

      Vicky, the problem with overcrowding on Sundays IS caused by London Midland. London Midland could run trains on Sundays, but prefer not to bother, leaving the only service on the line on a Sunday to Arriva Trains Wales. So of course Arriva trains are overcrowded on Sundays.

      Report abuse

      • Vicky

        Matt your comments are valid. What I was pointig out was the sardine express was run by Arriva on a weekday and as their franchise runs out in 2018 I believe, it would of been good if the paper had sought their views on the subject. London Midland are unlikely to run services on a sunday on our route from what Ive heard. They are running the Shrewsbury staff branch down, i.e. not recruiting when people retire/leave. What will they will do when their numbers dwindle so low they cannot run a service? This might have something to do with the train cancellations last saturday.

        Report abuse

  2. 2
    Jayne Oliver

    But now that his government is in power, surely Mark Pritchard can push through this limit on the number of passengers in a carriage. If he can’t, then why did we vote for him?

    Report abuse

    • Matt

      At least Mark Prithcard represents the views of rail travellers.

      His near neighbour, David Wright seems not to bother, even though Telford station is in his constituency.

      Report abuse

  3. 3
    Jayne Oliver

    What’s wrong with asking the govt to sort out the trains?

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Brizziewig

    Oh boy! Are you going to miss the 2012 Olympics?
    I drive a mobility scooter, all trains in Queensland have access for; wheelchairs, prams, bicycles and mobility scooters.
    You are in the ‘dark ages’ in the UK.
    What will the PAROLYMPICS do?

    Report abuse



Video News From ITN

TWITTER

Shropshire Star on Twitter Shropshire Star on Twitter

Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

Entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new Shropshire Star app Get the new Shropshire Star app

Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.