Anger at care cost decision
Wednesday 21st October 2009, 9:00AM BST.
Relatives of an 82-year-old woman who requires constant nursing today spoke of their anger after being told she is no longer entitled to hundreds of pounds of NHS-funded care.
The family of Beryl Knafel, of Sutton Farm, Shrewsbury, said it was a “total fiasco” and an “absolute joke” that she was not going to receive the financial support.
Mrs Knafel suffered two strokes at the start of the year and is in a nursing home.
She is doubly incontinent, has vascular dementia, and cannot move without the aid of a hoist.
But, having reviewed her case, Shropshire County Primary Care Trust now says that in its opinion she does not have a primary need for what is known as “continuing health care” and only qualifies for personal and social support.
Mrs Knafel’s family say her care costs are about £780 a week, to which the trust will contribute £106. They plan to appeal and will speak to MP Daniel Kawczynski.
Daughter Susan Evans-Jones said: “She can’t do a thing for herself. If she doesn’t deserve full funding, then I don’t know who does. It’s a total fiasco, an absolute joke. We feel so very angry over what’s happening.”
Another daughter, Kim Cliff, said: “It’s appalling the stress that families have to go through. I just don’t know how the trust can justify its decision.”
Chris Morris, from the PCT, said: “Continuing health care is a complex and sensitive area which can affect individuals at a very vulnerable stage in their lives, and Shropshire County PCT works with patients and their families to provide the support and help where it is appropriate to do so.
“Once an initial assessment has been made for continuing health care, eligible care will be funded by the NHS. This is subject to rev-iew at three months, then every year or sooner if needs change.
“If care needs change, the funding arrangements may also change. Continuing health care funding is not awarded indefinitely.”
Mrs Morris added: “Shropshire County PCT provides an appeals process for anyone who has been previously provided with continuing health care funding, but after a review may have had funding reduced or stopped. Funding continues to patients whilst the app-eals process is taking place.”
By Health Correspondent Dave Morris
Shropshire Star on Twitter
Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
Entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new Shropshire Star app
Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.
Is this the Shropshire County Primary We Don’t Care Trust?
Report abuse
Hmmmm, I’m afraid she’s too old. You need to be of working age but never intending to work – and have a big family and large-screen tv – to qualify for help these days. Those who worked hard and paid into the system get little or nothing back.
Report abuse
disgraceful treatment of somebody who obviously does need this standard of care.It seems to be another case of red tape and budgets ,no longer can people rely on care in their later years when they need it .
Report abuse
My Mother in similar situation. This decision has nothing to do with Health Care needs, but everything to do with reducing their budget deficit.
Report abuse
My mother is in the same situation and has just had her CHC funding withdrawn. This decision has nothing to do with my mothers health condition, but more to do with reducing budget deficits.
Report abuse
Perhaps if the people making these decisions werent on such inflated salaries and pensions there would be more cash where it is needed and deserved. It isnt only bankers and politicians who are present day highwaymen !!!!!!!
Report abuse