Circular reasoning

Monday 19th October 2009, 8:00PM BST.

From giant gyratories to miniscule mini-islands, there’s more to roundabouts than meets the eye, writes Ben Bentley.

Roadworks on Ketley Brook Roundabout last year

They drive us round the bend and make our offside tyres as bald as Kojak’s pate.

What is there to love about traffic islands?

Well, there must be something because the British road traffic island is 100 years old and is still going strong – particularly in parts of Shropshire. If half the world’s roundabouts are in France, then the other half must be in Telford.

  • What’s your favourite/least favourite Shropshire traffic island? Tell us about it in the comment box below and help us to compile the 10 best and the 10 worst

One hundred years ago, of course, the traffic island was a different story. When the first British roundabout was built in Letchworth Garden City in 1909, white van man would have been dashing around it in a horse and cart.

But things change, and so do roundabouts. As I discover on my circular voyage of discovery, island-hopping around the town, today they are sites for works of art and havens for flora and fauna. Parks have been built on them. Makeshift football pitches even. And people have lived on them, disproving at a stroke that no man is an island.

I’m watching the world go round by standing in the middle of the Ketley Brook roundabout. Accessed by an underpass, it is the calm at the centre of a motoring storm as the air of tranquility is pierced by the sound of car horns around me.

Lined by trees and plants and berry bushes, there’s every reason to believe you could survive here. Indeed there is evidence of human life, in the form of burnt grass and, nearby, a pair of rather charred knickers.

With increased levels of traffic have come modifications to help the hapless motorist negotiate the common island. Lights have been fitted on many – including, controversially, here at Ketley Brook and at Emstrey in Shrewsbury.

Kevin Beresford, president of the Roundabout Appreciation Society, is also driven to distraction by them.

“The one thing that infuriates committee members of the UK Roundabout Appreciation Society are those blinking traffic lights,” he says. “Surely there is just no need for them.

“A roundabout filters traffic perfectly well without those tedious things holding you up. Although it has to be stated they do allow you a longer, loving look as you drift slowly around your glorious gyratory.”

And then there is the island you don’t even know you’ve visited until you’ve probably caused a road traffic offence.

All hail the mini-roundabout, the one that looks like a blob of paint on the road that no one actually drives around but goes straight over. It is, I conclude, wholly appropriate that the painted mini traffic island has become known as the PMT.

“One thing that winds our committee up, are people driving over PMTs,” says Kevin. “They should be observed and navigated accordingly.”

Near the Beveley Road junction with Holyhead Road in Ketley I watch as an average of one out of every five drivers goes straight over the painted pimple or, worse still, goes round it the wrong way, continental style.

Further on, the Greyhound Roundabout is island paradise. While cars zoom around it, the woodland within it provides the perfect habitat for birds and an abandoned shopping trolley.

Trench Lock is a monster and, in an ornamental arrangement of rocks, even appears to have its own mini Stonehenge, while high trees provide a meeting point for magpies – Telford branch.

Islands do, of course, provide prime advertising space. Passed by endless streams of circling motorists, they are used to sell everything from coffins to air-con units.

Passers-by prone to influence here are encouraged to buy workwear. Those positioned near entrances to hospitals are prone to being sponsored by legal eagles touting for business by putting up little signs on them, asking: “Had an accident recently?”

Trench Lock is a reminder that roundabouts are not all round. Teardrops, oval, square and egg are just some islands that send us tootling around in fancy shapes.

This one is more magic roundabout, judging by some of the driving on display.

The perfectly formed rail freight island at Hortonwood is another wildlife heaven, while Garrison Roundabout is a landmark for its twin cannons.

Off Wrekin Drive in Donnington is a roundabout that is also a walled monumental garden with benches and a tribute to the fallen in the Great War.

Perhaps motorists can judge an island on its sponsor. Priorslee Roundabout is sponsored by M&S. With its pretty flower beds and manicured grass, this isn’t just a roundabout – it’s an M&S roundabout.

So yes, there’s plenty to like about roundabouts. Kevin Beresford, aka ‘Lord of the Rings’, says one of his favourite ’bouts is in Shropshire and gets pride of place in the organisation’s book Roundabouts of Great Britain.

“The very first picture in that book is one of my all time favourites, a delightful gyratory from Ironbridge.

“The ’bout is made up of beautiful brick work, wrought iron and a towering tree, a cracking combination representing a town that heralded the Industrial Revolution.

“The one thing that makes traffic islands great are their infinite variety. They are so expressive, you can put anything on a roundabout – statues, sculptures, laser shows, cinemas, gardens in full bloom, you name it.”

“I’m sure if Andy Warhol was still alive we would see giant soup cans adorning our islands.”

At Telford’s Forge Retail Park I find a roundabout with a sense of humour. Passing motorists concentrating on the road ahead may not have even noticed, but it features giant metal sculptures of a three-pin plug, a carrot, the key to a sardine tin, an armchair and, as chance would have it, some great big cans of food.

Andy Warhol might be dead, but at this Telford road junction his memory is very much alive. In a roundabout kind of way.


  1. 1
    GB

    “They drive us round the bend and make our offside tyres as bald as Kojak’s pate.”

    Surely as more weight is put on the nearside tyres, they’re the ones that will go bald first?

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Magic Roundabout

    My favourite would have to be the Garrison Roundabout in Telford with the army guns. Reminds me of Britains great ‘island’ military history.
    Which one is your favourite and why?

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Peter

    What a delightful article! I’m no fan of the roundabout but a wonderfully tongue in cheek analysis of these frustrating but probably helpful devices. Why can’t more of the islands be planted up or characterised in some way? I love the wildflowers on the PRH island. I am also guilty of driving over the painted pimples…

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Nik Johnson

    Which Roundabout is your favorite in Telford? Mine is Chetwynd Aston, the one with the sheep…what’s yours????….

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    Jake

    Fun article :-)
    As for a favourite… either the one on Marshbrook Way in Muxton, as it means I’m nearly home, or the one with the steel sheep at Chetwynd Aston, as it means I’m nearly at The Fox!

    Those “painted pimples” though – if they didn’t insist on painting them offset halfway into the adjoining road then there would be no need to drive over the top of them. Changing bearing by 45 degrees, then another 45 degrees, all within a radius of a few feet, is just silly.

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    Tamsin

    I miss the pink pyrimids by the PRH and i even quite liked the cubes of crushed cars by sainsburys m54 exit. But since neither of those are as exciting i dont really have a favourite anymore, possibly the priorslee one, as it is well maintained and quite pretty, but most of all means im nearly home.
    I do however avoid one in particular… that one between muxton and asda donnington… the one by the hedgerows… that roundabout is leathal in the wet, i was the 3rd to crash my car there in the same day! if you drive past u may see a diversion sign propped against the crash barrier that is slightly raised out of the ground… that was the scene of my poor little KA’s demise

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    winja

    There is one island I particularly love.

    It’s in the middle of Hortonwood Enterprise Park, and it gets very greasy in the wet. And it’s where I practice power oversteer in the MX-5! 90 degrees of opposite lock on the exit is my best so far.

    Not strictly a roundabout, but I love the Brockton Loop as well (when it’s quiet). Great for exploring understeer, then lift-off oversteer in a front wheel drive car. You need to do a minimum of 50 around it for that, though.

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    Suellan Fowler

    Roundabouts and their lights don’t slow traffic down – the people who don’t know how to use them do. However when I passed my test it was always left hand lane to exit before 12 o’clock and right hand to exit after 12 but with some of these new roundabout systems such as Trench Lock that rule no longer applies – maybe we now need specific roundabout driving courses!

    Report abuse

  9. 9
    brian2

    Suellen,

    “Roundabouts and their lights don’t slow traffic down ”

    Funny that, cos they slow most people down when the lights turn red….don’t you stop then?

    As for roundabout usage, you can try the highway code or in the case of larger roundabouts like trench lock….follow the writing on the road….don’t forget to slow down if the light turns red though (oh and indicators help us other drivers)…. ;-)

    Report abuse

  10. 10
    brian2

    My favourite roundabout is any one without lights on or road markings, telling you that you can only use the left hand lane for turning left…..pointless on both counts.

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

TWITTER

Shropshire Star on Twitter Shropshire Star on Twitter

Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

Entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new Shropshire Star app Get the new Shropshire Star app

Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.