Offended by political correctness

Tuesday 31st March 2009, 9:00AM BST.

Emma SuddabyIs it right for people with disabilities to fall into the same social category as ex-offenders and drug users? asks Emma Suddaby.

Every few months the Shropshire Council magazine is delivered, uninvited, to my door. It gatecrashes through my letterbox and is treated to a serious mauling by my canine doorman, who takes his security duties very seriously indeed.

By the time I get to it, it’s in tatters on the floor. What do I do? Do I smooth its ripped pages, lavish attention on the news it brings? I’m afraid not. I mutter about the mess and scoop its many tattered pieces straight into the bin.

But bearing in mind the changes afoot with regard to the new unitary council, this time I thought I’d show their poor, molested magazine some mercy. I decided to actually read the spring issue and make its short, traumatised life worthwhile. Now that I have, I remember exactly why I tended to avoid this sort of super-politically-correct, squeaky-clean exercise in customer relations.

Reading through it I notice again and again many mentions are made of the council’s “vulnerable’constituents”. Vulnerable is not a word many have ever used to describe me, but like it or not it is the category I fall into. Along – according to Shropshire Council magazine – with ex-offenders and those with a history of substance misuse.

Thing is, I find it quite offensive to be perpetually lumped in with the dishonest and the self-indulgent. And it’s not the first time in life, in a wider sense, that I’ve noticed a tendency to group those with disabilities – through no fault of their own – in with a section of society whose problems are somewhat more self-inflicted.

I’m being very careful what I say, it may be after all that a large part of my readership are just about to reach for their seventh double whisky, before heading out the door, toolkit in hand, for another night on-the-rob!

But I’d like to bet I’m not the only “vulnerable” resident who’s growing tired of having my problems and needs likened to those of an ex-offender or a crack addict. And I can’t be the only one concerned that the pool of resources available to help a disabled person live an independent life are equally as accessible to those whose problems stem from their own self-destructive actions

So I’m afraid I haven’t been moved to save the next edition of Shropshire Council magazine from the violent assault I know is awaiting it, next time it pokes its bland and “appropriate” pages through my letterbox. And I certainly won’t feel guilty as I dispose of its unread remains. It’s left me feeling uneasy about our new council.

Mind you I’m not sure why I’m surprised . . . only a council could produce a magazine that is so inoffensive it ends up offending me!


  1. 1
    ty

    i advise that you watch ‘Stuart Lees Comedy Vehicle’ from BBC2 last night @ 22:00.

    That should clear it up for you.

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Clive Dean

    Interesting that someone who, quite rightly, wishes not to be pigeonholed instantly pigeonholes others! An ex-offender making a determined effort to get back on track and lead an honest life comes up against this sort of prejudice constantly no matter what circumstances may have led to his offence.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    andrew finch

    I could not agree more,PC clap trap has now become so over the top it has become offensive to most people. I have read literature given out by some houseing associations it is so insulting it speaks to its tennents as though they are brain dead oiks who cant think for themselves. Lets face it many hold down good jobs or businesses but cant move on due to the cost of houses so they stay in a cheap rentED property etc.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Annie

    I can understand why you might think that you should not be included in that group. However, people with substance misuse are not generally “self-Indulgent” many have reached this point in their lives as a result of bad experiences in their lives i.e. sexual and physical abuse in childhood or parents with addictions etc. Alcoholism is a chronic relapsing illness and is often misunderstood. On the surface it might appear to be self inflicted but there are far few deeper issues involved for people to judge.People are vulnerable for many reasons but the stigma attached to substance misuse means that other vulnerable people do not want to be categorised with them.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    Peter

    It looks as though Emma has a bit of a chip on her shoulder, and is looking around for something to feel discriminated against about.

    Whilst I wouldn’t condone the self-indulgence of addicts and the criminality of ex-offenders, they are where they are, and they both represent groups for whom a little investment of the right sort of time and resources probably represents a good investment when it comes to the long-term cost to the Council Tax payer.

    Perhaps Emma would be happier if we substitute the word ‘expensive’ for ‘vulnerable’?

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    eva land

    There are physical challenges and mental challenges that people face in different degrees in their lives but none are more disabling than narrow mindedness.

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    Jack Spencer

    I am in no group, subgroup, or anything else. I am nothing but what I am. The council may object, but there it is!

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

TWITTER

Shropshire Star on Twitter Shropshire Star on Twitter

Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

Entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new Shropshire Star app Get the new Shropshire Star app

Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.