Some Telford boys of 11 have reading age of a seven year old

Friday 17th December 2010, 10:17AM GMT.

Some Telford boys of 11 have reading age of a seven year old

Thousands of boys leaving primary school – including many in Telford & Wrekin – have the reading age of a seven year old or younger, it emerged today.

Figures from the Department for Education revealed nine per cent of 11-year-old boys – about 18,000 pupils – failed to reached expected standards in literacy tests taken on leaving primary school, BBC Radio 4 Today’s programme reported.

In Nottingham, 15 per cent of boys failed to achieved Level 3 in tests taken just before they left for secondary school, the standard expected for seven-year-olds or younger.

At 11, the expected standard is Level 4.

In Derby, Manchester, Rotherham and Telford, the figure was 14 per cent.

Mike Welsh, president of the National Association of Headteachers and a primary school head, said the underachievement could be attributed to children with special needs.

He said boys’ reading was one of the top priorities for primary school headteachers but the Pupil Premium would not be enough to improve reading with specialist teaching.

Mr Welsh said: “The point is we need to actively work on it because there is a tale of underachievement.

“Children need to practise reading. The practice of reading at home with parents is absolutely vital.

“The role-modelling of writing as well. We have lost that in society where people used to write letters and the like. Again, the home has to work with the school and in school we are certainly working to put programmes together, working towards the Government’s Pupil Premium to support specialist teaching for pupils who are actually needing that intervention.

“At the moment the Pupil Premium has been set at £430 which is too low to have the specialist teaching. We are hoping that over the next few years it is going to rise so we can actually provide that.”

By Education Correspondent Dave Morris


  1. 1
    Lucius

    I’m sure there is a career as a Shropshire Star journalist waiting for them!

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    chris p

    Presumably you mean ‘tail of underachievement’?

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    ignorant git

    the truth behind these figures is that there are too many kids in schools whos first language is not english and teachers are not able to communicate to these kids when there are at least 20 different languages being spoken.
    a result of this is that native born english speakers are being held back and the exam results will reflect that for years to come and education standards will drop more and more untill the government sees sense and stops inward migration of all these foreigners.
    as far as many school leavers are concerned these days as far as employment goes in many industries are concerned,well they can forget it as they are un-employable because they cant do basic mathematical calculations in their heads or read and write to an acceptable standard.
    well i could go on and say more but wont as it would hit too many nerves and i am not racist either.
    i am of the old school who believes in calling a shovel a shovel and sod the p.c. crap brigade.

    Report abuse

    • Peter

      You’re clearly also of the ‘old school’ who doesn’t believe in punctuation either!

      There are very few schools in Telford where the proprtion of those with English as a second language is significant, and it’s quite astonishing how quickly these children pick up our language (they’re also well-supported by their parents in this) – would that our indigenous kids could apply themselves to learning foreign languages with equal enthusiasm and aplomb!

      The problem with reading amongst boys has nothing to do with immigrants, and your attempt to blame them is boringly predictable. It has far more to do with reading not being regarded as ‘cool’ these days, and our need to find ways of encouraging enthusiasm for this skill.

      Sadly, relatively few parents read to their children these days, and it appears that this is part of the problem – unless a child has been shown the simple pleasure of becoming engrossed in a story, and the stimulus to the imagination that this can provide, they’re unlikely to see reading as a pleasurable activity.

      The benefits of reading to children are well-established – I have two daughters, and have read extensively to both over the years, including amongst others, the entire of the C.S Lewis Narnia chronicles, the whole of the Harry Potter series and the Philip Pullman ‘Dark Materials’ trilogy.

      Both girls now have excellent reading skills, and an extensive vocabulary – I believe the simple task of 15 minutes of reading each night has contributed significantly to these skills.

      It’s far too easy to blame teachers, immigrants, the TV, game consoles etc. – the simple fact is that the solution to this lies first and foremost with the parents.

      Report abuse

      • idon'tbelieveit

        Peter, fully agree. I read to my son when he was young and at 14 he too has read all the CS Lewis books, Harry Potter, Darren Shan… in fact anything he can get his hands on.
        His peers gently make fun of him because they think his PS3 is underused but he enjoys reading.
        However, there are not sufficient books at school that interest boys and over the years I have made good use of local libraries and Waterstones to feed his ‘habit’!

        Report abuse

  4. 4
    Telford born and bread

    Wot thay on about Thar aint nuffin rong wif tha spelin in Tefard.Nuff said.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    Nistagmus

    Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Please provide it and whilst you’re at it please explain the reason why immigrants cause problems for boys (not girls) literacy alone.

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    Nightjar

    We are from Telford originally (before it was Telford!) and looked at the OFSTED figures before deciding that the best thing for us, and the childrens education, was to move away. We moved to an area with a much better possibility of a decent education and wouldn’t move back and neither would our kids. Why would the local lads need a good education? Afterall, the local factories are not employing them for their brain power are they, they can bring that in from outside…

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    Helen

    Sorry to sound like a stuck record but much of the blame lies with ‘trendy’ teachers and their methods. The entire education system needs completely stripping of political correctness and it needs to get back to basics.
    Bring back a traditional approach to education with a return to the ‘Three Rs.

    Turn the clock back 45 years and you’ll soon see an improvement.

    Report abuse

    • Nistagmus

      Please provide evidence to back up your claim that much of the blame lies with ‘trendy’ teachers.
      Please provide details of what the methods of these teachers are and how evidence of how they contribute to the problems of literacy.
      Please provide evidence of how political correctness causes males literacy problems but not females.

      Report abuse

      • Helen

        The proof is plain to see. Education standards were far better in years gone by. The statistics in this report speak for themselves – So those old style teachers must have been doing something right.
        Most people would agree that lack of proper discpline and the dumbing down of eductation have played a part in creating this situation.

        Maybe we should encourage former servicemen to train as teachers. Young lads need proper male role models – especially when there isn’t one at home.

        Report abuse

        • Nistagmus

          The article does not indicate whether there is a trend, whether the trend is upwards or downwards (although admittedly it is inferred), or when the trend began. So to extrapolate anything from a single point on a graph is difficult in the extreme, suffer from confirmation bias and likely to be wrong. You have no evidence and therefore the opinions expressed are based upon your world view. You move from the problem being PC to discipline (without indicating why there would be a gender bias) to dumbing down of education (same gap) to being not enough male role models. You cite majority opinion as proof whereas it is at best an indicator.

          I could, for example, claim, that boys literacy is lower because they are reading less then girls because they are being allowed to play console games which are primarily designed for boys because their parents are too exhausted in the evening to stop them because they’ve both been out working because they’ve been brought up (considering when they were children) to believe that money is more important than society ergo blame Thatcher. But I wouldn’t expect to be taken any more seriously than you should be.

          Report abuse

        • Peter

          Can you point me in the direction of your sources for the statement ‘Education standards were far better in years gone by’?
          Can I safely assume you have some statistical evidence to support this claim?

          Looking at the statistics provided by the National Research and Development Centre for Adult Literacy and Numeracy, they indicate that between 1948 and 1960, reading skills amongst 15 year olds made a steady rise (probably due to larger numbers of children subject to education to that age due to various Education Acts implemented in the 1940s), and since then have remained more or less static.

          So on the fact of it your assertion is not valid. Is there any conflicting evidence, or are you simply basing your views on your evident dislike for the teaching profession?

          I don’t know why you think ex-servicemen would be particularly good at teaching literacy either – is there any particular evidence that they are more literate than any other group in society?

          Report abuse

  8. 8
    Jesus H Corbet

    Sorry am I missing the point here? Doesn’t the article clearly state that 91% of Telford school boys in the sample group have an average or above reading ability?

    That’s a good thing imo. Seems like the author of the article(s), this one, and BBC R4, should have studied Statistics as well as Journalism.

    Report abuse

  9. 9
    The Infiltrator

    And some Telford 7 year olds will have the reading age of an 11 year old.Ah , but there is no headline there.
    Even worse , 50% of the population have below average intelligence.That is outrageous.
    I love the general ignorance about simple statistics.
    But seriously, the best thing about Telford is the M54.It means you can leave quickly.

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

TWITTER

Shropshire Star on Twitter Shropshire Star on Twitter

Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

Entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new Shropshire Star app Get the new Shropshire Star app

Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.