Leader: The picture is mixed on High Streets

Tuesday 13th December 2011, 12:30PM GMT.

Leader: The picture is mixed on High Streets

Mary Portas says many High Streets are dying. She might be pleasantly surprised if she came to Shropshire.

Good occupancy rates, thriving streets, maybe even some market stalls . . .

Then again, she might find evidence to support her contention. Empty stores, boarded up stores, For Sale signs . . .

It is the most mixed of pictures, and within Shropshire there are some towns, like Bridgnorth, where the traditional High Street scene seems secure, and others where the pressure is clearly telling.

Decline comes by a succession of little defeats. In Oakengates, the family store of Owen’s has had to close its doors after over 140 years. Fred Roberts in Cross Street, Ellesmere, has been another to call it a day, after nearly 140 years.

They are representative of the smaller independent retailers which give the special character to towns and the shopping experience they offer.

The planning template now seems to be of the “give them a supermarket” variety. Madeley got one. Dawley is to get one. Hadley is to get a Tesco Express. There are contentious supermarket plans on the table in Newport. A new Sainsbury’s in Whitchurch is coming with the sweetener of the firm giving almost £500,000 towards town improvements.

It is like a tidal wave and yet the smaller traders are somehow having to compete. Commercially, it is always going to be tough. Nevertheless, town centre traders in Shrewsbury who sell the things that you cannot get in supermarkets are holding their own.

But with supermarkets selling an ever widening range, the niche markets are shrinking.

The key perhaps is to see things not just as a commercial fight, and to work to make town centres attractive destinations in themselves, where there are things to do and see, and they are pleasant places just to hang around.

The fear of repossession:

Out on those High Streets, and in those supermarkets and out-of-town shopping centres, there is a veneer of normality.

Recession? What recession?

Behind the facade is another story. According to the homeless charity, Shelter, the Telford & Wrekin area is one of the worst places in the West Midlands for home repossessions, with 625 in the borough between October 2010 and September this year.

As repossession is generally a last resort, it is an indication of just how bad things are.

It is all very well talking about the need to build houses and expand the number of affordable homes to help people onto the housing ladder, but the cruel truth is that home ownership is demonstrably beyond the means of many people.

And what has happened to those who have lost their homes? They have become invisibles within the system, who will perhaps reappear at some stage in some other set of statistics.

For every person to have lost their home, there will be others who live in fear of it happening.

Those who have no worries about their jobs or finances this Christmas can count themselves very lucky.


  1. 1
    Katherine de Gama

    Something Portas didn’t say is that beautiful towns like Shrewsbury or Ludlow will always succeed because people always like wandering about and, then, spend money.

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Peter

    Whilst some of the repossessions happening at present are genuine tragedies, involving the loss of family homes, we should also bear in mind that a significant proportion are in fact buy-to-let properties, being lost as a result of the great property bubble having finally burst.

    There is a housing shortage and a homelessness problem in this country, but that’s largely caused by a lack of affordable and social housing. We had a much larger problem with repossessions leading to homelessness in the last recession back in the ’80s.

    This time around, we have yet to see the effect of the attacks on jobs in both the public and private sectors, occasioned by the government’s attacks on jobs and growth. The worst in terms of loss of family homes is unfortunately yet to come.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    philp clayton-smith

    Mary P Also said free parking would help regenerate town shopping,
    hospitals loose a fortune by having private parking services manage there car parks…What are there finace managers in hospitals being paid…
    a donation point for parking maybe a way forward.

    As for housing,
    the housing market is in a slump because 1st time buyers need to save upto 30k as a deposit,
    So as the tax payer has bailed out the banks i think the banks should look at 40 yr mortages for 1st time buyers to help them get the housing market moving…

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Bill

    Having posted (yesterday) copy of a piece about Shrewsbury retailing following the Portas report (extracted from the BBC website) I’m very disappointed it hasn’t appeared as it made some sensible criticisms and constructive suggestions

    Perhaps thr writer of the leader hasn’t seen it?

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-16162250

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    towbar

    Mary Portas ??? Another self appointed expert full of pointless advice..High streets which have a good mix of businesses selling a wide range of merchandise and services which potential customers require at prices which are acceptable SUCCEED. Those which do not FAIL. Simples!!!!!!

    Report abuse

    • Nistagmus

      Strictly speaking, she was appointed by the Government.
      If she was really an expert, she’d have realised that it would be a complete waste of her time. She can come up with the most brilliant idea ever, it matters not a jot.
      The whole report thing is just a bit of Government PR bluff to make people think they were doing something about the issues and drafting in a ‘celebrity’ to make it onto people’s radars.

      Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

TWITTER

Shropshire Star on Twitter Shropshire Star on Twitter

Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

Entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new Shropshire Star app Get the new Shropshire Star app

Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.